camp stove recommendations?

Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
48
Greetings W%SS...

I'm using the winter months to slowly accumulate some backpacking/camping gear. Next on the list is a camp stove for areas where no ground fires are allowed. My price range is up to $100. I would like a stove/pot set combo if possible. Ive looked at some traiga alcohol setups, as well as MSR gas style type as well. I've never used a camp stove in my life. Looking for ease of use, durability, not much of a weight weenie. Suggestions? Maybe with lynx of reliable retailers for that stuff?
 
Mine is a MSR Whisperlite and a Dragonfly. I prefer liquid multi fuel stoves and for this type, IMHO, MSR makes the best.

A lot will depend on your priorities and what type of camping you do.
 
I've got a Vargo Triad titanium stove. Perfect for a "weight weenie" even though this is not your major concern. This thing ways just about NOTHING!! And it is very very small. The weight is in the fuel itself. I think I could survive quite comfortably for a week or more on just a quart of alcohol if I had to. Very cool from REI around $30 but might not be what you are after. Let us know what you decide. -DT
 
I've only done car camping the past few years. The last time I backpacked was early high school for about 5 days on the AT with a group. Almost 15 yrs ago. I guess I couldn't go wrong by starting out with a alcohol stove style mess kit for like $20 and work my way up from there. I found both aluminum and stainless steel. Whats the difference other than weight?
 
For me, it's a Coleman single burner, liquid fuel, and my own homegrown alcohol stoves. I use both with great results. This past season I brought a can of chicken soup that had ice in it, up to a boil in about 7 min. on my alky burner.

Beckerhead
 
Mine is a MSR Whisperlite and a Dragonfly. I prefer liquid multi fuel stoves and for this type, IMHO, MSR makes the best.

A lot will depend on your priorities and what type of camping you do.


+1:thumbup: I have both of these as well... and the MSR Pocket Rocket. I think I prefer the Whisperlight International for winter use, mostly because it fits inside my pot set and the Dragonfly doesn't, although the Dragonfly simmers a bit better. Very reliable, well built, and completely field maintainable .

I've burned about every type of fuel in the Whisperlight including diesel, gasoline, AvGas, Jet-A, Jet-B; it burns about anything, but Naptha (white gas/Coleman fuel) definitely burns the cleanest.

For car camping I have a two burner Coleman propane stove and a three burner Jiffy Range.
 
I've been using a JetBoil a lot. Very simple and efficient, cooking pot locks right on top of the burner.

The only drawback is that it uses canisters of isobutane/propane. These are available almost everywhere, but the systems lacks the versatility of some of the multifuel stoves.
Personally, I haven't found this to be a problem, but it is a consideration. Nevertheless, I really like this stove.

Edit: this stove limits you to a single tall pot. If you were thinking about making Pad Thai out on the trail, you'll need a different stove. But for dehydrated foods or heating up a can of Dinty Moore, it can't be beat.
 
Last edited:
For simplicity sake I carry a Pocket Rocket. Yeah, the fuel canisters aren't the best in very cold weather and the thing can't simmer very well, but it'll boil water for you in a flash and it packs reasonably small. I usually grab a new fuel canister if I'm going on a longer trip, so I've got a few partially full ones laying around. I use them for overnights or weekend trips where I could use a fire if it runs out on me.
 
For simplicity sake I carry a Pocket Rocket. Yeah, the fuel canisters aren't the best in very cold weather and the thing can't simmer very well, but it'll boil water for you in a flash and it packs reasonably small. I usually grab a new fuel canister if I'm going on a longer trip, so I've got a few partially full ones laying around. I use them for overnights or weekend trips where I could use a fire if it runs out on me.

I like that pocket rocket, but I feel like Im getting ahead of myself looking into the pricier models right now. Think I'm gonna "rough it" with the swedish mess kit alcohol style for now and see how that goes.
 
Heres one I just ordered, I like the simplicity and lightweight factor of the Ti. 30 bucks from Tad Gear.:thumbup:

vargo_triad_d3_340.jpg
 
Jet Boil is neat.

I use a Coleman F1 for a single burner butane stove and hiking with others. Under 3oz and puts out 16,000 BTU's.

Hiking solo, I use a Brasslite alcohol stove or an Esbit solid fuel rig. All I'm cooking is a couple cups of hot water at a time, so weight and space rule.

Car camping, we use a Coleman 2-burner white gas stove I bought 30 years ago in a thrift store for $5. I've replaced the pump leather and the generator a couple times.

I have a Coleman Peak 1 unleaded gas one burner that is used for simple car camping and part of our disaster kit. I got it at a yard sale for a few bucks. It could be used for hiking, but it is heavy by today's standards.

If you are just making oatmeal, coffee, and dehydrated dinners, the one-burner butane stoves are great. The Coleman F1 and the Pocket Rocket are both good examples. There are some models with built in lighters. Most will boil a quart in ~3 minutes.

If you use them a lot, mark the partials and/or weigh them and compare to full and empty cannisters to gauge the fuel left. One way to handle a lot of partials is to get a lantern that uses the same cans and burn the leftovers for light. I haven't had much problem figuring out what was left. If the weather is humid, you will see the fuel line on the side with condensation. They are good with a group where you need to crank out a lot of hot water and each member of the group can carry a share of the fuel with no extra expense for liguid fuel bottles-- no leaking fuel in your pack either.

If you are winter camping, then the liquid fuel stoves like the Whisperlight mentioned above and other MSR stoves are the best choice. Butane and alcohol stoves are cranky in the snow and cold.

Esbit stoves are cheap and store well. I have the original folding stove and a "wing" stove made of titanium that weighs nothing. It works great for a small titanium pot with a little foil for a windscreen. If you can get a flame of any kind going, you can light the fuel and boil a couple cups of water at a time. Some use Esbit stoves made of wire and beer cans. The Esbit fuel tablets also make for excellent emergency fire starters, giving you 15 minutes of 2500F flame to get your firewood going. Great for solo, but slow for groups unless you are just making hot drinks for a day hike. They are a great backup for a butane or liquid fuel stove that breaks down.

Alcohol stoves are good in moderate weather. They are light, relatively inexpensive, and quiet. Denatured alcohol fuel is found in nearly any hardware store, paint store, or marine supply. Watch the fumes as there is a lot of methanol in denatured alcohol. If you don't mind the expense, Everclear high proof "white lightning" will work and you can have a Gatorade cocktail while dinner is cooking. Brasslite makes excellent stoves and there are a bunch of pop-can stoves out there. Trangia has made burners for years and they have pot kits to go with them. As with the Esbit stoves, they are best for boiling a couple cups of water at a time. They can be difficult to get going in cold weather and can use a larger portion of the fuel to get the stove up to full operating temperature. If you are camping in moderate temperatures, they work well. Use a little caution as you can't always see the flames-- they aren't for kids to play with.

Pressurized liquid fuel stoves need maintenance and I check mine before a trip. Jets plug up and pumps can fail. Any stove with a hint of a leak needs to be set aside and repaired. I had an o-ring leak on an MSR rig with all too spectacular results. I got it shut down and the flames out before it got to the fuel bottle. Just keep in mind that you are working with a slightly refined flame thrower full of burning gas.

And I never cook in a tent-- the carbon monoxide and flames around all that fabric are Murphy's Law waiting for a new chapter. A flare up may find you without facial hair or shelter. There's all kinds of arguments on this subject--- I'll opt for a granola bar until I can cook outside.
 
Heres one I just ordered, I like the simplicity and lightweight factor of the Ti. 30 bucks from Tad Gear.:thumbup:

vargo_triad_d3_340.jpg

They are tiny and light and they SUCK. Sorry. Maybe the newer ones are better. Any of the pop can stoves I have tried out-performed this one. The Brasslite Turbo models look a little weird, but they turn out 2-3 times the heat of the Triad.
 
Heres one I just ordered, I like the simplicity and lightweight factor of the Ti. 30 bucks from Tad Gear.:thumbup:

vargo_triad_d3_340.jpg

That is the one I have. Never used it to be clear, but by my math many days on a quart of fuel assuming two three times a day. Weighs next to NOTHING.
 
For simplicity sake I carry a Pocket Rocket. Yeah, the fuel canisters aren't the best in very cold weather and the thing can't simmer very well, but it'll boil water for you in a flash and it packs reasonably small. I usually grab a new fuel canister if I'm going on a longer trip, so I've got a few partially full ones laying around. I use them for overnights or weekend trips where I could use a fire if it runs out on me.

+1..Well said...For backpacking/hiking I have the Pocket Rocket/Titan Kettle Combo and I love it. I have only used it to boil water for Ramen Noodles and hot beverages and it does that quite well. I also picked up a similar stove made by Coleman at my local Wally World. It's called a Peak 1 Single-Burner Micro Stove. It is a little bigger/bulkier/heaver than the Pocket Rocket but it was only ~$25 so it's really not a bad little stove for the money. Additionally, FYI the Coleman and MSR isobutane canisters are interchangeable. For other activities where weight is not an issue I would suggest any of the Coleman-type single or 2-burner propane stoves...
 
I have the Snow Peak titanium canister model with the auto igniter. I've used the Whisperlite International a lot and like it for a liquid fuel stove. I've also used the Jetboil and although I like it for boiling, I find the Snow Peak a little more versatile (if you want to fry/brown something).

DancesWithKnives
 
i prefer alcohol stoves. no moving parts and next to little or no maintenance. just need to carry alcohol. alcohol over here is relatively cheap, i buy 4L jugs at the local hardware store for about 10-15bux. i have wood burning stoves, canister stoves, multi-fuel stoves as well as alcohol stoves and have to say i prefer the alcohol stove the best.

i think sportsmansguide would be a good place to pick them up as you can get them for fairly cheap and shipping within states is much better then shipping to canada.

good luck on your quest for a hiking stove.

JC

p.s. are u lookin to do cooking or just boiling water? because gas stoves provide better temperature control then alcohol stoves do.
 
I've been using a JetBoil a lot. Very simple and efficient, cooking pot locks right on top of the burner.

The only drawback is that it uses canisters of isobutane/propane. These are available almost everywhere, but the systems lacks the versatility of some of the multifuel stoves.
Personally, I haven't found this to be a problem, but it is a consideration. Nevertheless, I really like this stove.

Edit: this stove limits you to a single tall pot. If you were thinking about making Pad Thai out on the trail, you'll need a different stove. But for dehydrated foods or heating up a can of Dinty Moore, it can't be beat.

I have the same stove, Rotte. Have you seen the group pot or the frying pan for these? I think the group pot is my next purchase. And I hope all components will fit inside.
 
Back
Top