Camping with city folk dillema.

I think the biggest distinction here is what you "need" to bring, versus what you "want" to bring... :) Could I get by with a small axe, sak and FB? Sure. Do I want to only have that at my disposal? Hell no, I take every chance I can to use my gear which isn't often enough...

I like being the only one in the group that's prepared for when the shit hits the fan/zombies show up uninvited. :)
 
I should clarify that when I am car camping all I need is the axe, small FB & SAK combo.

When car camping....I say have a car crammed full of knives. Try 'em all, throw 'em at trees, find which ones work best. It's when you are away from the car that you want to limit the amount of stuff you are lugging around. Then you limit yourself to the couple knives you know will work efficiently.

Maybe that's cityfolk thinking!
 
I don't camp with city folk, nor do I camp in campgrounds!:p

One knife, one axe and one handgun serve me well.
 
I think you're crazy if you allow other people to affect your judgment on what you feel the need or desire to carry, providing you are breaking no laws. If you care what they think you are borderline crazy IMO. Hell, I don't care if they're inlaws it's none of their business.
 
It appears to be a choice of carrying knives to facilitate camping or going camping to facilitate playing with knives.
 
I may have been crazy but i used that tomahawk, or weapon as someone would like to call it, to kill a very aggressive copper head.
 
we talk all the time about getting the "city folk" to accept our hobby and not see knives as a threat, but they cry when they see the 16 different knives you bring camping...i'm not sure that is the correct was to assimilate them to the way of life...

If you are teaching someone who is afraid of guns that they shouldnt be afraid to you pull out your 44 magun with hunting scope and your BCA AR15? or do you first show then the Walther p22 and get them used to that first?

When you go camping by yourself or with other knife people feel free to bring all the knives you own and borrow 27 others...when camping with "city folk" maybe you should just bring the knives you will absolutely need. There is a time and a place to do things and I'm not sure you chose correctly
 
we talk all the time about getting the "city folk" to accept our hobby and not see knives as a threat, but they cry when they see the 16 different knives you bring camping...i'm not sure that is the correct was to assimilate them to the way of life...

If you are teaching someone who is afraid of guns that they shouldnt be afraid to you pull out your 44 magun with hunting scope and your BCA AR15? or do you first show then the Walther p22 and get them used to that first?

When you go camping by yourself or with other knife people feel free to bring all the knives you own and borrow 27 others...when camping with "city folk" maybe you should just bring the knives you will absolutely need. There is a time and a place to do things and I'm not sure you chose correctly

Good points....

It is quite possible those people could be seen as certifiable psychopaths by a lot of people. ;)

Knife people or not.....
 
The last time I went camping, I spent three hours waist-deep in an almost frozen lake, chopping up a fallen tree that was thicker around than I am for a raft. My tools? CS Trail Hawk and a Tramontina Bush Knife. Now that's camping!


So no, you're not crazy. Yet. ;)
 
we talk all the time about getting the "city folk" to accept our hobby and not see knives as a threat, but they cry when they see the 16 different knives you bring camping...i'm not sure that is the correct was to assimilate them to the way of life...

If you are teaching someone who is afraid of guns that they shouldnt be afraid to you pull out your 44 magun with hunting scope and your BCA AR15? or do you first show then the Walther p22 and get them used to that first?

When you go camping by yourself or with other knife people feel free to bring all the knives you own and borrow 27 others...when camping with "city folk" maybe you should just bring the knives you will absolutely need. There is a time and a place to do things and I'm not sure you chose correctly
Words of wisdom.
For example, I bought a little .22 rifle, for the sole purpose of teaching my wife to shoot and getting her comfortable with firearms. Now that she's gotten used to them, and was gently eased into the whole operation, she LOVES shooting the big, black Mossberg 12ga. :cool:
 
Each person must decide on what they carry. Your skills and tools are there to make tasks easier than without them. I might carry a pistol on my next backpacking trip, and I hope I never need it.
Blades I want to use them and will. I've carried enough unused gear over the years to know what I'll use and what to leave. Yet, each situation has variables. I've gone out with only a Leatherman, and with success. Yet, if I had ever lost my LM or other gear, then I would have been kinda screwed.
My friend knocked my pack down a big hill once. I got it back, but at that moment I realized I was unprepared without it.

Take what you want to the woods, but have a plan B for when your gear fails or is lost. Point is, if everything is in your pack or back at camp, how good are your skills to deal without, once you are lost or injured?
Rule #9 applies at all times, and the more you know means you need less gear to get by.
 
Crazy? no, lil over the top? yes imo, when i go out i pack my CCF hawk, my leathermen and, my BRKT Gunny along with a bow saw. the bow saw and the hawk being the things that i dont EDC.
 
After reading all the posts, I've come to this point with a few things that need to be said.

It does not matter a whit if you're camping with city folks or boy scouts or any other group of people. You have to keep in mind, that we, the knife knuts, are only a fraction of 1% of society at large. Most of the "normal" people out there will carry a sak or some other knife on a camping trip and be fine. And in truth they are. But we knife knuts who are obsessed over anything with a blade will over load ourselves with cutlery, to the point that the so called "normal" people will look at us like we are nuts, because we are. We're not the norm, and when you venture outside of what most people are used to, you will get looked at a little funny. Get over it.

If you are going camping with those other people, Why not be a little more circumspect than you would be when by yourself. Part of being a part of society is getting along with others, and that means not ramming your love of something in their face. Recognize that we are not "normal", and take a little care. Bad behavior by just a few, can mess it up for the many. I see a lot of these posts, and it seems to me that a certain number of young knife knuts like to act like they are just going along, but I think a great many of you get off by flashing your cutlery, and going a bit over board to mess the the people. You enjoy the reaction of the sheeple as you call them.

If you hate how knives are portrayed as weapons, you only have to look toward Hollywood and the knife manufacutures as the guilty party. The knife makers pay for product placement, and you all buy the increasingly outlandish cutlery because it's featured in some movie, video game, or TV show. How many of you have bought some tiger striped bladed knife because it was on NCIS?

If your going camping with people who are not knife nuts, the best way to alienate them to your hobby is to show up like a pirate going looting. Why not just have one or two very nice knives, one folder and one sheath knife, and if they show interest in what you are carrying, pass it over to them, and let them examine it while you explain the good points of better cutlery? Start slow if you're trying to show them the way to a better knife, but don't bludgeon them with knives by showing up looking like some charater out of a video game. Show some adult restraint. Going camping in the lower 48 states is a pretty tame business. You're not going to be hundreds of miles off in a wilderness. You're not a mountain man, buffalo hunter, or commando. Take it easy on the non knife nuts, because they vote too, and we're too few. We can't afford to alienate people to our hobby.

Carl.
 
After reading all the posts, I've come to this point with a few things that need to be said.

It does not matter a whit if you're camping with city folks or boy scouts or any other group of people. You have to keep in mind, that we, the knife knuts, are only a fraction of 1% of society at large. Most of the "normal" people out there will carry a sak or some other knife on a camping trip and be fine. And in truth they are. But we knife knuts who are obsessed over anything with a blade will over load ourselves with cutlery, to the point that the so called "normal" people will look at us like we are nuts, because we are. We're not the norm, and when you venture outside of what most people are used to, you will get looked at a little funny. Get over it.

If you are going camping with those other people, Why not be a little more circumspect than you would be when by yourself. Part of being a part of society is getting along with others, and that means not ramming your love of something in their face. Recognize that we are not "normal", and take a little care. Bad behavior by just a few, can mess it up for the many. I see a lot of these posts, and it seems to me that a certain number of young knife knuts like to act like they are just going along, but I think a great many of you get off by flashing your cutlery, and going a bit over board to mess the the people. You enjoy the reaction of the sheeple as you call them.

If you hate how knives are portrayed as weapons, you only have to look toward Hollywood and the knife manufacutures as the guilty party. The knife makers pay for product placement, and you all buy the increasingly outlandish cutlery because it's featured in some movie, video game, or TV show. How many of you have bought some tiger striped bladed knife because it was on NCIS?

If your going camping with people who are not knife nuts, the best way to alienate them to your hobby is to show up like a pirate going looting. Why not just have one or two very nice knives, one folder and one sheath knife, and if they show interest in what you are carrying, pass it over to them, and let them examine it while you explain the good points of better cutlery? Start slow if you're trying to show them the way to a better knife, but don't bludgeon them with knives by showing up looking like some charater out of a video game. Show some adult restraint. Going camping in the lower 48 states is a pretty tame business. You're not going to be hundreds of miles off in a wilderness. You're not a mountain man, buffalo hunter, or commando. Take it easy on the non knife nuts, because they vote too, and we're too few. We can't afford to alienate people to our hobby.

Carl.

Excellent post. :)

As you said none of that really helps out our cause at all, all it does is hurt it in the end.
 
I carry EDC 4 knives so I don't think you're crazy at all. When I'm out in the woods, I have those 4 with me plus a fixed blade or two. People used to call me crazy, but now when something unexpected happens I'm the one they ask "Hey, can you...???".
You carry 4 EDC knives? Yup, you're crazy. One good folder and a good multitool is enough.
 
You carry 4 EDC knives? Yup, you're crazy. One good folder and a good multitool is enough.

Yeah really. LOL

When I see people all loaded up with knives and or guns I really question their motives and or sanity...

I will usually put some distance between them and me....

Even if I walk into a gun store and I see the people all loaded down with guns I will usually walk out. ;)

That macho crap is a HUGE turnoff for me....
 
Last edited:
Crazy? no. Excessive? yes. Since you're calling it "camping" and you're doing it with "city folks", I assume it's not a 6-day hike into the wilderness far from civilization. For non-primitive camping a multitool and a fixed blade are enough. Beyond that it's about "want", not "need".
 
As far as the original post, who wants to carry all that stuff?

I agree with the fact that I'm a knife knut, and am always looking for reasons to use my various knives. But truth be told, on most camping trips, I can get by just using a leatherman juice or a sub 3" fixed blade. Sure, all the extra knives are fun, and camping is supposed to be fun, so I say carry what you want, but don't be surprised if others think that it's overkill.
 
When camping with city folk, just bring a single smatchet. Everybody loves a smatchet.
 
Back
Top