I bought 3 Case Stockmans between 1999 in 2001. I was quite unimpressed by the fit and finish of them. Not enough walk and talk for my tastes, and far too much horizontal blade play. The bone scales were nice, but the fit and finish wasn't even close to comparable Old Timers or Bucks at that time.
Judging by the praise here, Case has either stepped up their fit and finish substantially, or the other brands have fallen down to their level.