I was just forwarded an email to check out this thread.... there have been a number of points that have been brought up that need to be answered.
First off, I haven't seen the other threads, but in this one Dennis is 100% in the wrong. Whatever his true motivations, RGRAY posted just a link to some pictures of the knives in mention. The post hasn't been edited, so we know that's *all* he posted. Dennis decided to jump down his throat and IMO, that was undeserved.
Second, regarding Dennis Wright's new "No Sales to BFC members" policy... if Dennis doesn't want to take business from BladeForums.com members, I'm sure that they will be more than happy to buy Chris Reeve Products elsewhere. It's his perogative. I highly doubt if he's going to ask every customer where they got his information from, so I don't think it's a policy that is going to work, but that's just me. If he wants to grand stand, that's his perogative.
Third, regarding our "dealer" policies... Dennis posted the following -
"The owners and administrators consider those of us dealers who post here and do not pay to advertize, as freeloaders and parasites, possibly with reason. I do not care to be categorized as such."
That is not the entire truth, and is a mischarecterization, something I have explained over and over again, despite Mr. Wright's protestations otherwise.
Our policy is that if a Dealer is using BladeForums.com to make sales, then they should turn around and help support the site they are making money off of. If a dealer posts knives for sale, actively tries to gain customers through BladeForums.com, and doesn't want to support the site, then yes, they are freeloaders and parasites, there's no other conclusion about it. There is no free lunch.
Call up Tactical Knives or BLADE Magazine and ask if they will allow you to advertise for free. Go to any Knife Show and ask where the free tables are. You'll quickly get my drift.
If a dealer doesn't make any sales of BladeForums.com, doesn't post knives for sale, doesn't actively promote their business through BladeForums.com, etc, and doesn't want to advertise, hey, I've got no problem with them. They don't bother us, we don't bother them.
All I'm asking for is some reciprocation from the dealers that *do* make money off us. I don't think that's an unfair request. As such, we limited the Knives For Sale: Dealer's forum to paying advertisers only.
Personally, I wish Mr. Wright the best of luck with his new policy. Perhaps he should remove his store contact information from his signature file so that he doesn't have to pay for calls on his 1-800 number since he's not going to be selling to BladeForums.com members anymore... it'd give him every opportunity to live up to his promise, and would remove any uncertainty about incoming calls. I'd also be curious as to how many customers he's gained from the forums, but that's just for personal edification...
Spark
------------------
Kevin Jon Schlossberg
SysOp and Administrator for BladeForums.com
Insert witty quip here
[This message has been edited by Spark (edited 05-20-2000).]