Cold Steel Spike-Scimitar

Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Messages
2,197
Specifications:

Blade Thick: 7/32"
Blade Length: 4 1/2"
Handle: 4" Cord Wrapped
Overall length: 8 1/4"
Weight: 2.5 to 2.7 oz
Steel: 420 Sub Zero Quench

Why:I was looking into getting a small fixed blade for the purpose of a light user/back up blade. Basically, something I could use for my standard EDC chores if I carried it alone as well as being excellent for SD. Stumbling across the Cold Steel Spike at SMKW for a rather reasonable price I ordered the Scimitar variant.

First off, there are now 7 variants of the Spike in the Cold Steel line up. I chose the Scimitar because I wanted that extra grip the pommel and jimping would provide, liked the false edge, and I feel that curvature of this knife will slash and cut the best out of all the variants.

Sheath
The knife comes with a SecurEx sheath with grommets and lashing loops. However, it has no belt clip so you'll either have to use the supplied bead chain (which is a bit larger and heavier than the kind on your dog tags), or rig up something of your own. I've tied a piece of 550cord to the top grommet and the other side to my belt loop and carried it in my pocket (front or back). That way, when I draw it the sheath stays behind and only the knife comes out. I've also found I can simply push the sheath off like I would push a thumbstud while the knife is in my pocket but that is by no means a high stress, life or death situation technique.

Handle
The handle came supplied with a cord wrap of some kind of synthetic thread. I was not satisfied with this at all. The handle is thin enough to begin with, there's no reason to use the thinnest wrap available. Essentially, the supplied wrap doesn't increase the diameter in any noticeable way. I then wrapped the handle with gutted 550cord right over the supplied wrap. This made the knife much more comfortable and secure. However, this knife is still best used in SD with the saber grip (shanking style), or hammer grip (reverse or standard). Using the jimping is something reserved for EDC tasks IMHO. The ball on the pommel is rather attractive and does enhance the grip. It could be used as an "impact device" but chances are if this knife is drawn in anger the only impact is going to be the blade hitting bones.

Blade
The knife came, typical Cold Steel, shaving sharp. So sharp in fact, that when I accidentally stabbed my palm ever so slightly it bled uncontrollably until I applied pressure and clamped down on an artery. Now that its healed substantially, its very clear that the piercing ability of this knife is nothing but needle-like. There is no doubt that this knife will be vicious in a self defense capacity. Stabs through multiple layers of carboard were easily done and it zipped right through 550cord. The mirror polish is "pretty" as my sister said but it just isn't my style. I'd send it out for a durcoat or the like if that wouldn't cost more than the knife itself. If I'm ever feeling the itch for a subdued coating the rustoleum or krylon will come out.

Use
Is this knife better than an Emerson LaGriffe, Spyderco Spot, or Hideaway Knife? It depends on your priorities. They seem pretty much even. For the reach you lose when going to one of the other three you get more security in the hand. Also, the Spike will stab far better and by my best estimations slash equally if not nearly as well. If you're more inclined to the "standard" knife shape then this is a better choice. Thinking out of the box, it could be tossed in BOB due to its small size and weight but again, that depends on what you'll use it for. I don't think the tip would handle battoning well (other variants may be better), size may be an issue for those who like a larger knife, and you'll never chop with this one.

csstoreonline_2034_16257079












 
Last edited:
If you don't mind my asking, how's the edge retention?
The 420J2 construction has steered me away from these knives in the past.
Thanks.
 
I have the original Cold Steel Spike; I bought it without having a particular intention as to its use, but it has found its way into a hidden mesh pocket in my shaving kit as a backup knife on vacation, etc. The most exciting use it has seen was opening some package and slicing a few tags out at Philmont when my Military was behind in my tent. While not the same size, it has been since replaced in this role by the Buck Hartsook. The edge retention wasn't bad, but I've found that Bos-treated S30V takes a better edge and holds it longer.

In regards to stabbing the Spike, I'd want a tight grip. It lacks a full-on guard, and thus makes me nervous to put a lot of force behind blows, whether it be for testing or potential self defense situations. It's not a bad knife, but I'll stick to a firearm for SD. :D
 
I really like the Spike series from Cold Steel. They cut well and are light enough to carry just about anywhere. I have not done any edge testing. From cutting a few things here and there, I'd say the edge retention is fine for a SD knife.
 
I used it for food prep, beef and pork, on a cutting board (obviously) and its still just as sharp as when I recieved it. If its being used for SD retention is a moot point, however I don't think that any issues one might find would be so awful as to take it off the EDC list entirely.
 
I have the original Spike.
I must say, it was a bit of a revelation to me. The blade's extreme sharpness seems to be so out of context with the thickness of the spine coupled with the short span from spine to edge. I would not have thought it possible for something that thick to be that scary scalpel sharp.
The thing cuts and stabs like a demon on a rampage. I can easily see how you accidentally opened a minor artery with it. The good part is, it should heal quickly and cleanly. That's about the only joy one can get from cutting oneself with an extremely keen edge.

Thanks for posting this review as I had no idea the Spike Scimitar even existed. (I've been kind of out of touch with the knife world for awhile.)

So, funds permitting, I have put the CS Spike "Scimitar" on my very short "must have" list. :D
 
The blade's extreme sharpness seems to be so out of context with the thickness of the spine coupled with the short span from spine to edge. I would not have thought it possible for something that thick to be that scary scalpel sharp.

Agreed. This knife really dispells the notion that one has to have a thin blade and/or a high flat grind to be scary sharp; and this isn't even some super steel!
 
Interesting review! I've been looking at the spike series for a while now. I may pick this knife up in the future!
 
Good review. This may be one to pick up.

Btw, you list the steel as 420, and someone else says 420 J2. Is it the J2 steel or is it 420HC, or non of the above?
 
Good review. This may be one to pick up.

Btw, you list the steel as 420, and someone else says 420 J2. Is it the J2 steel or is it 420HC, or non of the above?

420 is a class of its own, as well. If it were 420HC it would be mentioned- that's a hell of a step up from either 420 or 420J2.
 
I wish they didn't have THE SPIKE blasted across the blade.

With so many historic and purpose driven representations/versions I wouldn't be surprised to see a bayonet version soon. Hey, after all it is Cold Steel! You could mount it on your Glock.

Gibby
 
Btw, you list the steel as 420, and someone else says 420 J2. Is it the J2 steel or is it 420HC, or non of the above?

I just copied and pasted the specs of the Cold Steel website so I think that's the proper designation. Previous models may have been J2 or maybe they are doing a switch to the J2.
 
Cold Steel is being a bit evasive when they describe the steel used in the line. "420 Sub Zero Quench" is all they say, which isn't much.

Regarding sharpness, yes, any acute angle, from just about any kind of steel could be sharp. Even a 90º angle could be sharp enough to slice you up. Regarding the Spike series, having a zero edge makes up for lots of thickness. Honestly, I wish more manufacturers would not shy away from the zero edge. That simple grind could make a decent slicer from almost any blade shape or steel.
 
Back
Top