Collectors making knives

Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
29,205
How many of the collectors here have tried their hand at making a knife? I'm just wondering, because I'm going to give forging a go at Josh's hammer-in. I figure it will help me appreciate better what goes into making knives, and who knows, maybe I'll get the bug.
 
Last edited:
good on ya Keith! I highly recommend to anyone who loves knives to try making one or two. That process for me so far has been awesome.
 
I haven't tried. I'd probably take off a hand or at least a finger in the effort. That said, it on the list of things to do once just to say I did it. Like skydiving. Look forward to catching up with you at Josh's show in June, Keith!
 
Forging a small to medium sized blade is the easy part, relatively speaking. Larry, Wes and Tim teach kids to do that at hammer ins. It's the stuff you do afterwards that will drive you crazy.:eek: Now when you move up to forging big honkin' bowie blades, it gets a little trickier.
 
How many of the collectors here have tried their hand at making a knife? I'm just wondering, because I'm going to give forging a go at Joss' hammer-in. I figure it will help me appreciate better what goes into making knives, and who knows, maybe I'll get the bug.

I have made 4, 2 from forgings, and two from stock removal.

I have designed about 10, and had them made, either into production knives, or total customs.

And I think you mean Josh's hammerin, not Joss's.

Best Regards,

STeven Garsson
 
I haven't gotten to the forging stage, but just attended my first hammer-in this past weekend and it was great. Was a little too crowded in the shop for everybody to hammer some steel, but sure learned a lot on the sidelines.

I would highly recommend Tom McGuinnis' two-day fixed blade class in Ozark, MO. I took it in '07, then I did a folder class there, instructed by Don Hanson, this past February. Both classes were very informative and help raise the awareness as to what is involved in this custom knife world to achieve the work that so many great makers do.

I sat next to Kyle Royer during the fixed blade class two years ago. He was sixteen, and doing some fancy filework with ease on the last day, while I was sweating out finishing mine without filework before they closed the shop for the day! Go figure. :D

- Joe
 
there's been some talk elsewhere of knife makers charging people for their time as teachers, and I think that's a really relevant avenue for increasing the bottom line if it were planned right and you could handle people.

I try not to ask for too much advice in my own endeavours for several reasons, one of which is to avoid being a 'borrower' of information. I want to be able to provide something in return. In this regard, I already have 'bills' to pay, (not to diminish any gift of generosity, it's just the way I roll). I am acutely aware of leverage, I watched lots of nature shows about gorillas;)

For myself, I have a wish list of makers I'd want as weekend mentors, (hopefully lifelong mentors if I dare to dream) who I'd rather spend money learning from than acquiring from. I mean, when you're buying a knife, you're buying the maker's knowledge and insight into the making of that knife, but if you're buying a lesson you're buying the maker's knowledge and insight into making knives, while all the while filtering that into your own dialectic through a collaboratively made item.

I'm going to save up for lessons and tools, and put the acquisition of new knives on the back burner. The more I think about knives and the more time I spend on the making of such, the more I see things about many of the knives I see that don't sit right with my eye. I feel that making a knife is making me a better judge of what I do and don't like, than simply buying knives that I like the looks of, and learning through buy-all and error;):D.

I really learnt almost everything I truly KNOW and keep with me about bicycle geometry from designing then welding/brazing a couple of frames. They are not exceptional or beautiful, but to me they say as much about my education on the subject as any degree or diploma would, (not that I have either, except from bike school...)
 
Forging a blade will at least give me an idea of what is involved. That can't be a bad thing. Of course I have seen others make knives, but they have all made it look so easy because of the amount of their level of experience.
 
Jim Siska invited me and Stabber Jr to his shop to finish off our Forged Blades:)

Next I am going to attend Joe Szilaski's class:thumbup:

I'm Hooked so I will attend all Hammer in's I can:thumbup:

Your right Joe, The guy Helping me and all the other Fella's Said that the Big ones are MUCH harder.
 
I suspect a few makers started out as collectors before trying their hand. I have no doubt it will be a valuable and informative experience for you Keith. Fun, too.

Ricky - I want to see those finished knives. :thumbup:

Roger
 
Knifemakers make it look so easy, it's probably a good idea for collectors to experience first hand that grinding or forging a knife is not an easy task.

I plan on taking the ABS Introduction to Bladesmithing course when I can make the schedule work. I've visited the school in Old Washington on several occasions while classes were in progress and it would be both an educational and enjoyable experience for a custom knife collector.
 
About as close as I will ever get to even attempting to forge will be to look at Kyle Royer's WIP threads.
 
Will be giving it a go soon. Just waiting on a couple books from Amazon. They were suggested by a few makers on BF. Will see if I got the "right stuff"
 
For Sure Roger:thumbup:

I would figure Your right. Most probably collected then said "I can make this knife"
I suspect a few makers started out as collectors before trying their hand. I have no doubt it will be a valuable and informative experience for you Keith. Fun, too.

Ricky - I want to see those finished knives. :thumbup:

Roger
 
I was collecting knives by Loveless, Herron, Brend, Moran, Ruana etc before I made my first knife.
BB
 
A friend of mine and his family attended a class at Audra Draper's home. He told me they had a great time and both he and his children got to make or at least start on their own knives.

My friend is rather reclusive or he'd tell the whole story.

For me, I have no interest in making a knife.

Win
 
Back
Top