Comparation Gerber Gator vs. Morakniv Garberg knives

My attempts with Stainless steel strikers was not very good but, then again they were generally cheap stamped blades and not a higher quality stainless steel.

Regarding 1095, 1075, O1, 52100, etc. really depends on the heat treat just like stainless steels. I have some Newt Livesay Wicked Knives that are very rust resistant for a carbon steel and hold an incredible edge. I have also had a lot of mass market 1095 knives that were okay but, nowhere near as good as this. In general, I would say that carbon steels are easier to get a 'good' heat treat but, very few really hit the upper tier quality similar to Newt in a knife that is mass produced or ~$100~$150. A lot of mass market stainless has a subpar heat treat IMHO. I even had a Benchmade folder that was over-hardened and rusted and chipped easily. :(

Morakniv is one of the brands that has not disappointed me regarding relatively cheap stainless steel utility knives. I use a lot of their blades and find their normal stainless to be very good for everyday uses. The Garberg takes this to the next level with 14c28n! This is an under-rated stainless IMHO. :thumbsup:

Their are better stainless steel blade stocks available but, they come in at higher price points so, they should perform better when you are talking about 2 or 3 times the cost! Of course, can I really expect to touch up the blade on a river stone or concrete step?

So, while not a super premium option, it also has a very modest cost while delivering most of what the super premium knives do. While I don't want to give up my other knives, if all I had was Morakniv models, I could live the rest of life very happily! :)

After hours of watching reviews, in this moment I think I would go on Terava Jaakaripuukko 110. Its a carbon steel knife, full tang with an amazing leather sheath. The price is less than Garberg. Initially I said NO but I started to appreciate it more and more. I'm still waiting for 4-6 weeks and I'll have to make the final decision...
 
W wackafew -> did you mod that to give it more of a drop point blade shape?

looks really cool. didn't think about doing that tbh.

joe
 
W wackafew -> did you mod that to give it more of a drop point blade shape?

looks really cool. didn't think about doing that tbh.

joe

No modification on the blade, other than a little flitz and 000 steel wool to clean some of the original forged finish off the blade.
 
L Lika If your going to use the knife with a ferro rod or flint to start fires, then carbon steel is your only choice. Stainless won't spark.


I just doublechecked, and my Kansbol in 12C27 still throws a huge shower of sparks off a ferro rod. A stainless Companion won’t throw them off an unground spine, but will off the blade (not recommended). No idea what either will do with flint, or what other stainless steels will do, but Mora put a 90-degree spine on the Kansbol for a reason.
 
I did it!
I've a new Terava Jaakaripuukko 110!

In March, at the srart of the lockdown, I was staying with my son while I recovered from knee replacement surgery. That gave me the opportunity to spend a couple of lovely afternoons in the back yard with my grandson, turning big sticks into little sticks. I brought out my Kansbol and the Jaakkaripuukko.

As much as I like my Kansbol, the Jaakkari was the better cutter, by a small but clear margin. For his part, the boy was happy with his Marttiini, which is his favorite knife.
 
In March, at the srart of the lockdown, I was staying with my son while I recovered from knee replacement surgery. That gave me the opportunity to spend a couple of lovely afternoons in the back yard with my grandson, turning big sticks into little sticks. I brought out my Kansbol and the Jaakkaripuukko.

As much as I like my Kansbol, the Jaakkari was the better cutter, by a small but clear margin. For his part, the boy was happy with his Marttiini, which is his favorite knife.

Yes, endeed, the TJP is an awsomw knife! Good handle, very sharp blade, carbon steel...it's like a beast in the wood.
 
Back
Top