• Preorders are LIVE for the 2024 BladeForums Traditional Knife

    Traditional Knife Information Thread - make sure you go in there and read up.

    Requirements: Be a Gold or higher member or have been a member of the forums since 6/2023 with at least 100 posts in the Traditional Forum. Preorder is for people who live in the continental US only, international orders will be separate.

    Delivery expected in Q4 2024, hopefully before the holidays.

    User Name
    Serial number request

Couple spends week trapped in the snow; woman later dies

Joined
Oct 3, 1998
Messages
2,832
http://deseretnews.com/dn/view/0,1249,465031137,00.html


Backcountry trek turns into a deadly ordeal

Couple spends week trapped in the snow; woman later dies
By Pat Reavy
Deseret News staff writer

George Metcalfe and Rachel Crowley had only planned to take a quick weekend road trip through some of southern Utah's most picturesque landscape. But what they didn't realize was the area was also some of the state's most rural and rugged land, an oversight that would prove to be fatal.

The two spent nearly a week trapped in a Jeep in the backcountry of the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, eating only Skittles and sunflower seeds while waiting and hoping that someone would find them. When they finally decided to hike out of the area, Crowley was already very weak from cold and hunger.
Just four miles into their hike Crowley could not go any farther, and Metcalfe had to make the toughest decision of his life — to go on without her in an effort to find help. It would be the last time he would see her alive.
The tragic story of the couple ended late Monday morning when a cattle rancher discovered Metcalfe. A short time later, Crowley's body was recovered.
Metcalfe remained in stable condition Wednesday at Garfield Memorial Hospital in Panguitch where he was being treated for hypothermia.
Their ordeal began Feb. 22 when Metcalfe, 26, from England, and his girlfriend, Crowley, 27, from Massachusetts, flew into Las Vegas where they rented a Jeep and went off on a sightseeing expedition through Zion National Park, Bryce Canyon and Kodachrome State Park.
The couple then wanted to visit the Grand Staircase, Garfield County Sheriff's Sgt. Danny Perkins said.
On Feb. 24, the couple took their Jeep on a dirt pass they thought would be a shortcut to Escalante, Perkins said. About halfway there, their vehicle became stuck in the mud in an area known as Trap's Wash.
"This is mean country," Perkins said. "They didn't realize it would be as rural as it was."







Apparently believing that someone would eventually drive by and see them, Crowley and Metcalfe stayed in their Jeep.
But no one ever drove by. To make matters worse, 2 feet of snow fell in the area over the next few nights.
On Saturday, after spending five nights in the Jeep with only a bag of candy, sunflower seeds and snow to eat and no winter clothing, the couple decided to try to hike out.
But after only four miles, Crowley was too weak to continue. Perkins said the couple spent the night under a tree. On Sunday, she told Metcalfe the best way to find help was for him to go on without her, Perkins said.
"They knew they were in trouble. They talked about dying. It was extremely hard for him to leave her, but she was unable to go, and he was quite weak himself," he said. "It's a heart-wrenching story."
Metcalfe left Crowley at 7 a.m. and walked through the snow all day Sunday and through the night. The temperature dropped into the 20s during the night, but the wind chill made it even worse, Perkins said.
By this time, friends and family of both Metcalfe and Crowley were looking for the couple. The two had not told anyone where they were going.
Quincy, Mass., Police Capt. Allen Gillan said his department was notified by Crowley's family that she was missing. After tracking down credit card records, police were able to trace Metcalfe to Utah where authorities were notified.
After walking more than 20 miles, Metcalfe was spotted Monday about 11:45 a.m. by rancher Vance Pollock.
"He was just staggering along," Pollock said after spotting Metcalfe. "This gentleman's in serious trouble," Pollock told his son, Shannon, who was with him.
When the Pollocks reached Metcalfe, he was weak, distraught, hungry and suffering from frostbite and hypothermia, Vance Pollock said.
"I don't believe he would have lasted a few hours if I hadn't of found him," he said.
Pollock put Metcalfe on his four-wheel ATV and drove back to his truck where he called for police on his two-way radio. Shannon Pollock tried following Metcalfe's tracks to look for Crowley, but his ATV became stuck in the snow, and he was forced to walk himself.
A short time later, a search helicopter was able to pick up Metcalfe's tracks and followed them to the tree where Crowley's body was found.
An autopsy will be conducted, but Perkins said it appeared to be a combination of starvation and exposure.
Even though the couple had purchased maps of the area, Perkins said it's hard for out-of-town visitors to comprehend the remoteness of the area.
He hopes map makers will take the initiative to make it more clear so a tragedy like this can be prevented from happening again.
"You need to put on maps in big bold red letters, 'You do not travel these roads under any adverse weather conditions.' Even in the summer those roads are treacherous. People from metropolitan areas are taken back by the remoteness of the unpopulated landscape. They had no idea that this was such a remote area. They thought it was a shortcut that people used all the time," Perkins said.
Vance Pollock concurred the area is tough even for people who are familiar with it.
"It's dirt, it's sand, it's clay, it's cold. It's just really a tough area out in the middle of nowhere," he said. "(Metcalfe) did the only thing he could do. I was very glad I located the gentleman."
 
Here's the Jeep:

ut_copdept.jpg
 
Thanks for posting this story for us. I've picked out below a few of the more obvious mistakes that we can all take to heart whenever we venture out. These mistakes were exacerbated by the fact that these folks were also quite far from their homes & families (UK & Massachusetts). And yes, I recognize how easy "after the fact" hindsight makes it to critique their efforts. ;) The harder task is to remember and implement the lessons oneself on the next trip out.

1. Not better notifying family and authorities in the area of the who/what/where/when/how of their trip.
2. Insufficiently researching the climate & topography of the area, the season, or even basic survival resources needed for this part of the earth at this time of year. Also, the altitude of the Colorado Plateau can be mountain-high country, even as it is flat desert all around you. BTW the clay mud out there in that desert can be so slick (ZERO TRACTION!!) that 4x4's whose wheels aren't even up to the rim into the mud have been known to simply sit it out for a day or so until the dang stuff dries out enough to stiffen up, stop being so greasy, and support traction to get the vehicle on its way.
3. Apparently they had trouble reaching an obvious conclusion. Spending five days hoping someone else will happen along to find you seems a bit overly optimistic, especially given their lack of food or clothing resources. After about the second day and no one else passing their location, the fact that the road is seldom traveled should have been pretty obvious.
4. Buying the maps for the area is a good move. But it's also important to grasp the info they give you (i.e. there is no one out there for a very long ways) and couple it with a large overdose of caution, then use that info as motivation to stock extra provisions and protect the participants by notifying authorities & family with all relevant info.

Apparently Metcalfe's determination was in good working order. He spent 29 hours hiking out in the cold & snow.
 
Thanks for posting the story. It is a shame they did not have the benefit of forums like this to study BEFORE they ventured afield.
-carl
 
Southern Utah is a dangerous place. It has extreme temperatures, very little available water, and many areas that are so remote that rescue is nearly impossible.

If they had been stuck in the summer, they both probably would have quickly died.

The lack of winter clothing really surprises me. You would think that coming from fairly cold climates, they would be smart enough to bring along a coat, or a thick sweater, or something. It's not as if Utah is known for its warm, Mediterranean climate - after all, it did host the WINTER GAMES just last year.

Even in the middle of summer, temperatures in the high mountain regions of S. Utah can easily drop below freezing.

I am sort of surprised that the rental jeep didn't have a lo-jack type device in it - where the couple could have been tracked down. They must have rented it for a long span of time.

Or that no one missed them.

Anyways, I don't think the maps are to blame. Maps shouldn't have to be labeled with all possible dangers ("Danger, Cliff: Do not drive off!"). Really, the blame lies with the couple and their poor planning.

If the couple had bothered to ask even one knowledgable person if it was a good idea to go off-roading in the middle of winter with no food, warm clothes, radio, etc - then tragedy would have been averted.

Or if they had bothered to spend 2 minutes on the internet, looking at S. Utah weather conditions and reading about 4-wheeling dirt roads in the winter...

Overall, a very sad story.

-- Rob
 
http://www.sltrib.com/2003/Mar/03072003/utah/35972.asp

Lost Couple Were Near Cabin


Vance Pollock, standing, and son Shanon rescued George Metcalfe in the Utah wilds. (Mark Havnes/The Salt Lake Tribune)
BY MARK HAVNES
THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE

CEDAR CITY -- At one point, George Metcalfe was within 300 yards of a cabin that, had he known it, might have turned a deadly tale into a lifesaving event.
On March 1, five snow-filled days after their Jeep became stuck in the wilds of southern Utah, the 26-year-old London man and 27-year-old Sharon Crowley, of Quincy, Mass., were in dire circumstances while awaiting rescue.
They were surviving on Skittles candy, sunflower seeds and snow. Their Jeep had run out of gas and they were running out of options, prompting the pair to backtrack on foot across the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in Garfield and Kane counties in an effort to reach the starting point of their ill-fated journey.
A day later, Crowley could not continue their trek. So Metcalfe, at his friend's insistence, pushed on alone to find help, leaving her under a tree where they had spent the night. At one point, Metcalfe unknowingly trudged within 300 yards of a cabin that was just off the road. The cabin was one of three built by a cattleman's association in the area to prevent just such a calamity.
Just before noon on Monday, March 3, cattle rancher Vance Pollock and his son, Shanon, rescued Metcalfe, who was by that time staggering, delirious and waving a red shirt.
Metcalfe was taken to Garfield Memorial Hospital.
A few hours after his rescue, Crowley's body was found under the same tree where Metcalfe had left her.
The cabins, which might have altered the outcome of the couple's fatal trip, are not advertised. But people who live in the area know where they are if they get trapped in the rugged area. The buildings are always open and well-provisioned.
And people do get stuck on the back roads that snake across the monument's clay-rich soil, and are usually rescued by ranchers.
"One drop of water can make a road as slick as ice," said Tropic resident Vance Pollock. "If it weren't for the cattlemen, there would be a lot of people stuck out there. You don't see a lot of [Bureau of Land Management] rangers out there."
In the past, Pollock added, trucks and trailers have been left stuck all winter in the area. He once had a truck mired for almost two months.
During some seasons, the road gets so mushy in the day from snow, frost or rain, it bogs down four-wheel drive vehicles.
"We just build a fire and wait for it to freeze until it is solid again," Pollock said.
Pollock's wife, Jeannene, says it is worrisome waiting for stranded relatives to return. "For a mother, it is always scary," she said.
Vance Pollock advises anyone heading into the area, at any time of year, to go equipped with a parka, food, water, warm pants and sleeping bag.
His son recommends a good map and matches. "Bring tons of matches," Shanon Pollock said. "The Air Force uses the area as a low-level flying range and could easily spot a fire."
Since Metcalfe's release from the hospital Thursday, he has avoided talking to the news media and is reportedly headed back to London.
He has at least one admirer, though, who is not as reticent.
"He had the mental toughness and motivation to make it," Shanon Pollock said. "Not only did he not have any food or nutrients other than snow, he had to go up and down a lot of hills. He's the hero if anyone is."
 
These two dorks were the quintessential bliss ninny yuppies.

From the very moment they decided to rent a Jeep (obviously having seen too many 4x4 SUV ads on teeeeeveeeee), take off to get at one with and commune with Ohh Sooo Friendly Gaia & Ma Nature, they were practically doomed.

No knowledge of ANYTHING having to do with the outdoors, no equipment of any kind, no clothing other than their yuppy summer clothes, just equipped with their supreme arrogance and supposition that nothing could possibly go wrong... and if it did, Big Brother & Big Nanny would toodle along rapidly and take them back to Yuppyville, poste haste.

So Pollock says that the young man was a "hero?" Bull -- Oney!! The moronic young man HELPED get his idiot girlfriend killed, along with equal assistance from her.

Cleansed the gene pool a bit, I'd say.

L.W.
 
Why L.W., whatever do you mean?
It only took them five days to decide to do something about their situation.
Five days...that's mindboggling.
 
Back
Top