• Happy Thanksgiving to all of you! I hope that you all have something to be grateful for this year and for many years to come

  • The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is available! Price is $250 ea (shipped within CONUS).
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/

  • America has reached 250 years, and I am grateful to be here, in the best country in the world. Thank every one of you who helps make this country a better place, those who have gone before and risked it all, and those who've paid the ultimate price to make the United States what we are today.

    Happy Birthday America! Let Freedom Ring for all time!

CPM S30V Overheat

J

John L

Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Messages
1,330
I heated to 2000 for 15 minutes. Tempered at 600 for two hrs. Tempered again for two hrs....then ..I guess I had misprogrammed my evenheat...and I ramped up again to 2000. So...I figure I would just temper again twice at 600. .....You guessed it..it ramped again up to 2000 after two tempers at 600. Gees..You'd think I would learn. Can I temper again or just scrap it?
 
I think I would redo the heat treat. 15 minutes sounds okay for the soak. I soak S30V at 1950 F. and temper at a lesser temperature. But if you've been having good results .....

rlinger
 
John L said:
I heated to 2000 for 15 minutes. Tempered at 600 for two hrs. Tempered again for two hrs....then ..I guess I had misprogrammed my evenheat...and I ramped up again to 2000. So...I figure I would just temper again twice at 600. .....You guessed it..it ramped again up to 2000 after two tempers at 600. Gees..You'd think I would learn. Can I temper again or just scrap it?
Click to expand...

Was it still in the foil during all this? If so, I agree with Roger in that you should just normalize and re-treat.
 
Hello Scott: Thanks very much for your offer..but I don't expect you to cover my mistakes. Very nice offer however. Thanks again. I finished the knife today and have been cutting up a storm ever since and seems to be fine.
 
John, Let us know how the blade performs long term ---this is interesting. Did you do a cryo cycle on it ? I have found S30V to be very forgiving and it is hard to blow the grains on this one. The other day I was heat treating and working on another project at the same time and forgot I had a blade in the furnace. This one was S90V and it got soaked for 4 hours at 2150. I figured that one is scrap --and it is-- as far as a blade to sell. So I decided to do a little testing with it. I clamped the tang in a vice and hit the blade a pretty good whack with a hammer. I expected it to break but it just went boing. I then ground some off to see if I could see any unusal grain structure, again it looked normal. I did a hardness test and it was RC 62, So far so good so I put it in the LN2 overnight and did a temper at 400. I came down to 60, just like you would expect for a normal heat treat. I will finish it into a useable knife and give it some more testing. Again I can't sell it but can maybe gain some more information on this class steel. After this radical soak it still seems to be just as tough and hard as a normal heat treat. It amazed me.. PHIL
 
Phil, I realize you have extremely high standards, but if the blade passed all your tests and Rockwells fine, what's the problem with selling it?
 
Phil: I did not cryo it as I have now good way to do it yet. Maybe later. Blade seems to be holding up fine. I opened some huge cardboard boxes with it over the weekend and I can't really tell the difference between the first and the fifth box...maybe a tiotal of 60-70 lineal feet of cutting. Who knows?
 
Danbo, This blade is so far out side of the normal soak time that it would be a risk to give it to a customer. If I had a lab where I could look at the microstructure then it would be different. I will keep it for myself, use it hard around the shop and maybe learn from this. It doesn't take much time to rough grind a new blade and heat treat it right. Phil
 
Danbo and all, I did some more work on the 4 hr blade. I surface ground off about .020 on one side and did another hardness test. hardness is 55. The first tests were done on the original ground surface and they were 5 points higher. somehow with the very long soak the surface got harder than the center part. Anyhow the blade is confirmed junk now. PHIL
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top