CPM S35VN vs CPM S30V

cziv

cziv

Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
10,038
I have two identical knives in front of me and have a question for you steel snobs out there. Looking at them both the knife with CPM S35VN steel looks brighter, or maybe cleaner than the one with CPM S30V steel. They are both the same heat treatment.

Is this just my imagination or is it true? If true what would that mean to me as a user of the knives? :confused:

I looked up the steels and they just talk about steel chemistry - lots of elements and stuff. To my eyes the CPM S35VN looks much brighter and finer but I know that's just an opinion at this point.

Anyone? :)
 
Isn't part of the purpose of S35vn to make it more machinable, meaning it should get shinier easier? Maybe that makes it look brighter?
 
I have 3 knives from Bark River in CPMS35VN. Cannot tell in this pic, but there are minor differences in the steel of each knife. The tiger striped custom Highland Special has been polished more than the other two.
The black TUSK and Custom Highland Special, have less shine and more "lines" from the grinding.
So, there will always be some differences, at least from the factory. Strop them and look at the edges, then you will get past the "factory" finish.
100_0964.jpg
 
Thanks, maybe there's something to my observation. :)

I have a new Sebenza S35VN next to a couple month old S30V (neither one ever used) and the only way I can compare the blade colors is like placing an older silver coin that has started to get more dull and gray next to a new or almost new one. The S35VN blade has a less grainy texture in the stonewash and a more brilliant shine to it.
 
You're seeing correctly. I was noticing the same thing comparing a CRK polished S35VN blade to a polished S30V blade.

cziv said:
I have two identical knives in front of me and have a question for you steel snobs out there. Looking at them both the knife with CPM S35VN steel looks brighter, or maybe cleaner than the one with CPM S30V steel. They are both the same heat treatment.

Is this just my imagination or is it true? If true what would that mean to me as a user of the knives? :confused:

I looked up the steels and they just talk about steel chemistry - lots of elements and stuff. To my eyes the CPM S35VN looks much brighter and finer but I know that's just an opinion at this point.

Anyone? :)
Click to expand...
 
how do they compare other than appearances? like "performance"? i'm eye f@#$%ing a tanto large seb in s30v but wish it was s35vn just cuz its a little different haha
 
S35VN is supposed to be a little tougher than S30V. Smaller carbides or some such thing. Dunno if that helps with the polished finish. Many knifemakers have stated in the past that S30V is a beeyotch to finish.
 
I too seem to be able to sharpen my Sebenza with S35VN in less time than my S30V version.
 
I noticed that with my Native 5 too- shinier and a smoother finish - I haven't had to sharpen it yet
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top