Creative criticism on my designs?

Joined
Feb 10, 2014
Messages
189
Hey guys. I was wondering if I could get some feedback on some knife designs I drew up. Any comments good or bad are welcome as I am looking for any feedback. Thanks guys!

1781995_10153870148350647_680231749_n.jpg


1888446_10153870148180647_1532471629_n.jpg


1661408_10153870148150647_857437663_n.jpg


I am not sure what happened to the dimensions on this one but the blade is 3 inches long and handle is 3 3/4 inches long

1662670_10153861162035647_382449119_n.jpg
 
my vote would be for number one or number two. The tapered handle on #2 looks like it might get tiresome to hold after a while. But number one looks great! What material will the handles be made of?
 
I am a big fan of walnut or a nice red wood such as padauk or bloodwood. With the first one I was thinking walnut with the brass spacers and some red fiber spacers around a brass spacer in the middle. I'll fill in some colors close to the materials and upload another picture if you'd like to get an idea of what I was thinking.
 
The first thing to think about with knife design is what you'll be using them for. Form follows function, is this a kitchen knife, EDC, chopper etc. The universal idea for all of them is that it cuts like crazy, in this regard I would recommend running your grinds almost up to the spine, this will improve your edge geometry by making the wedge shape you are pushing through material when you cut more tapered. Next up is handle design, this is the steering wheel, very important. Depending on the angle of the handle the blade will feel like an extension of your hand or not, the tip will seem too low, too high or just natural. Every contour should have a reason, palm swell and finger grooves should be making your hand land exactly where you want it to stay. If you grab the knife and then find yourself shuffling it back because it's choking up on the blade or forward because it's falling off the back it means you need to adjust the little point that should be riding between your second and third finger. Last but not least it aught to make you grin every time you see it, life's too short to carry (or make) an ugly knife. Look closely at knives that make you happy and try to find what lines you're loving and what you're hating. That's my two bits worth anyhow. Welcome to the wonderful world of knifemaking!

-HD
 
Thanks for the response. Gives me a lot to think about. With the plunge line are you saying to go with a full flat grind or to just bring it up closer to the spine?
 
Personally I prefer the flat grind because I think it cuts better. Draw the cross section of a hollow ground blade and a flat ground one and picture it passing through material and you'll see what I mean. If you do hollow grind the largest wheel you can get would be best so that your 'wedge' is as gradual as possible.
 
Because you are looking at doing hidden tang designs, you have a fair bit more flexibility with your handle shape even when going the stock removal route. The tang does not have to be in a straight line with the blade. It can have some "drop" and that allows the handle to have some drop too if you want it. Also, on a 4 inch bale, You might want to make the hand a bit longer than 4 inches.
 
Thanks! I am really used to small folders and haven't really handled knives with a 4 inch blade so I've just been kind of eye balling it to see what looks good. I love fixed blades but I never wanted to spend a ton of money on a really nice one. I honestly think that my only real experience with a fixed blade is my dads small old western cutlery hunting knife. I was thinking that there would probably be some balance or handling issues, but as I stated before I don't really have experience to know.
 
Back
Top