The purchase is already made, and I'm not going to buy another knife for quite some time, but nonetheless I am interested in hearing critique and feedback from forum members regarding my purchase:
What: Blackhawk Gideon Drop Point Knife, 5" blade, AUS8A stainless steel, partial blade on the back edge, Black Ti-Nitride coating.
How much: Bought it for ~ $100
Reason: Believe it or not, I wasn't too concerned about the "tacti-cool" factor. I've served my time, got to use some decent gear. But I've always viewed gear as expendable, meaning that I'll buy decent stuff, take good care of it, but at the end of the day its a tool and a means to an end. The tool might break, get lost, wear out, ect. so I refuse to spend an arm and a leg on getting the best, most expensive, most sought-after piece of kit. If the tool works and has decent reliability, then that's all I need. At $100, the Gideon drop point seemed like a good deal compared to many other bushcraft and survival knives. It's AUS8A stainless steel seemed relevant, given that I use this knife almost exclusively when I am outdoors (hunting, camping, exploring); I really like having a blade material that will resist corrosion since nearly everything metal is inclined to rust in the northeast where I live. I will and currently do use this knife for a variety of camping chores: cutting rope; trimming branches; gathering wood shavings/kindling; carving; batoning small branches and small-sized logs. At a bit over 10" (blade and handle combined) it is probably a bit on the long side for the hunting and fishing I do, but I could see this knife's utility in such situations especially for bigger game. The tactical design on this knife also isn't lost on me...the contoured grip and drop point demonstrates that there was a martial intent behind the design of this knife. To be perfectly honest, I'll be more than happy if I can go about my life without ever having to use this knife in such an application, but it's good to know that I have another tool at my disposal should I ever find myself in a bad situation. Right now this is the only blade of note that I carry when out in the woods, with the exception of maybe a small, cheap folding knife. My wood processing needs are minimal; I mostly gather deadfall and branches off the ground for camp fires. If I ever need a tool for more substantial wood working and processing, I could see the value of having a more dedicated survival knife or even a full on chopper, but I'm more inclined to use a small hatchet or survival axe for such tasks. I'm definitely limited as to what size logs I can process with the Gideon (mostly due to blade size and the relatively small flat spine on the back edge), but given my style of camping it has worked well enough thus far.
So what are your thoughts?
Will the AUS8A stainless steel hold up to my intended uses (especially the wood batoning)?
Was the purchase for $100 a good buy, compared to the other options out there?
Am I trying to make a square peg fit in a round hole by using a "tactical" fixed blade as a outdoor/hunting knife?
Does blackhawk have a reputation for reliability and quality?
This was my first serious knife purchase. I've had swiss army knives, small cheap folding knives, but nothing this expensive....lol...I know, $100 isn't a whole lot in the knife world considering what's out there, but for me it was a big step up from what I had previously been working with.
Edit: some photos posted for context:
What: Blackhawk Gideon Drop Point Knife, 5" blade, AUS8A stainless steel, partial blade on the back edge, Black Ti-Nitride coating.
How much: Bought it for ~ $100
Reason: Believe it or not, I wasn't too concerned about the "tacti-cool" factor. I've served my time, got to use some decent gear. But I've always viewed gear as expendable, meaning that I'll buy decent stuff, take good care of it, but at the end of the day its a tool and a means to an end. The tool might break, get lost, wear out, ect. so I refuse to spend an arm and a leg on getting the best, most expensive, most sought-after piece of kit. If the tool works and has decent reliability, then that's all I need. At $100, the Gideon drop point seemed like a good deal compared to many other bushcraft and survival knives. It's AUS8A stainless steel seemed relevant, given that I use this knife almost exclusively when I am outdoors (hunting, camping, exploring); I really like having a blade material that will resist corrosion since nearly everything metal is inclined to rust in the northeast where I live. I will and currently do use this knife for a variety of camping chores: cutting rope; trimming branches; gathering wood shavings/kindling; carving; batoning small branches and small-sized logs. At a bit over 10" (blade and handle combined) it is probably a bit on the long side for the hunting and fishing I do, but I could see this knife's utility in such situations especially for bigger game. The tactical design on this knife also isn't lost on me...the contoured grip and drop point demonstrates that there was a martial intent behind the design of this knife. To be perfectly honest, I'll be more than happy if I can go about my life without ever having to use this knife in such an application, but it's good to know that I have another tool at my disposal should I ever find myself in a bad situation. Right now this is the only blade of note that I carry when out in the woods, with the exception of maybe a small, cheap folding knife. My wood processing needs are minimal; I mostly gather deadfall and branches off the ground for camp fires. If I ever need a tool for more substantial wood working and processing, I could see the value of having a more dedicated survival knife or even a full on chopper, but I'm more inclined to use a small hatchet or survival axe for such tasks. I'm definitely limited as to what size logs I can process with the Gideon (mostly due to blade size and the relatively small flat spine on the back edge), but given my style of camping it has worked well enough thus far.
So what are your thoughts?
Will the AUS8A stainless steel hold up to my intended uses (especially the wood batoning)?
Was the purchase for $100 a good buy, compared to the other options out there?
Am I trying to make a square peg fit in a round hole by using a "tactical" fixed blade as a outdoor/hunting knife?
Does blackhawk have a reputation for reliability and quality?
This was my first serious knife purchase. I've had swiss army knives, small cheap folding knives, but nothing this expensive....lol...I know, $100 isn't a whole lot in the knife world considering what's out there, but for me it was a big step up from what I had previously been working with.
Edit: some photos posted for context:
Last edited: