CRKT M16 - just bought one, checked it out, and returned it

Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
2,232
I just went to WalMart with my son, and on a whim, bought the CRKT M16. When I opened it (in the store) I found the blade to be loose and the locking mechanizm to seem flimsey. Promptly returned it (with no problems - except a long wait). Did I get a lemon, or is this typical of CRKT?

Probably should have picked up the Kershaw Vapor (also about $20) or the Storm ($30) but I was ready to go by that point.

Not impressed. Any thoughts?
 
I just went to WalMart with my son, and on a whim, bought the CRKT M16. When I opened it (in the store) I found the blade to be loose and the locking mechanizm to seem flimsey. Promptly returned it (with no problems - except a long wait). Did I get a lemon, or is this typical of CRKT?

Probably should have picked up the Kershaw Vapor (also about $20) or the Storm ($30) but I was ready to go by that point.

Not impressed. Any thoughts?

Depends on which model of M16 you got.

I have read a fair number of complaints on the plastic handled ones. Thes usually have AUS6 or AUS4 blades.

I have read very positive feedback on the aluminum handled M16's that have AUS8 blades.
 
No, They need to be tighten alittle bit after opening. I actually like the the auto lawks on the knives. Its not a lemon. its the m1603 04?
 
I've had 2 CRKT M-16s. The M-16Z was not very charp but the AUS6 from CRKT is very easy to sharpen, though it doens't hold the edge well. The M-1614 was in AUS8 and was a good knife. The main problem these knives had was the pointless bead blasting, which made them rust faster than carbon steel. Neither had problems with loose blades or locking, but both were purchased in 2001, so a lot could have changed in 7 years.
 
I'm not sure what model it was, but it had a black metal (aluminum?) handle and black blade. Made in China.
 
Last edited:
its funny you posted that today. i just got in my M16-14M knife today in the mail. it has the tanto point and aluminum scales. lock up is strong and there's no blade play at all. i bought it as a backup to my .38 snub. i always have a Delica or Vic Farmer in my pocket as my utility knife. the M16 will be for SD backup only.

i'm not a fan of liner locks.....but i sure do like the flipper :D
 
As mentioned above, there are a number of CRKT M16 versions. As for CRKT quality, they don't use much fancy bits but most hold up well and get the job done.

My CRKT M1-13D (Lightfoot, desert color) is one of tightest folders I've ever owned. There is no blade play when locked open nor can you move the blade laterally in the closed position.

It has a nice big flipper on it and is a great size for EDC.
 
The problem was that you got the one from Wal Mart. They are made in China. All others that I know of are made in Taiwan, and are much better quality. I have two of the M16-02's with aluminum handles, one M16-13Z, and one M16-14LE. All of these are great. I also have the M16-14T, which I think is Awesome! (Titaniun Handles). They are all AUS-8, except for the 13Z, which is AUS-6. Just stay away from the ones made in China, and you will be fine.
 
i too bought the m16-10kz from walmart. after reading about bad things on the aus 4 blade i returned it the next day and bought the m16-10k online which had the aus 8 blade and aluminum handle instead of the zytel. i like the knife because its small and thin and fits in the pocket easy. the 1 hand opening with the flipper is the best part
 
A friend of mine who works at Big 5 has several aluminum handled CRKT's and loves them. The plastic handled ones that Big 5 sells - he hates, and says a lot of them get returned.

thx - cpr
 
weird. I've always thought of CRKT as the highest of the low-end manufacturers. For their price, the design is fairly good but the materials are substandard IMHO.
 
I will carry an S2 or Apache models on ocassion. Very well made knives with very good heat treat and blade steel(ats34). The big Apache is stellar and wicked. keepem sharp
 
It's very strange, but my M16-13Z, which has an AUS6 blade, can be sharpened and stays sharpened better than many of CRKT's AUS8 knives. I don't know why, but my Cold Steel knives with AUS8 blades also come sharp and stay sharp (to the point one can easily cut himself if he doesn't watch it). I will say that I have a special affinity for my titanium CRKTs. They're exceptionally beautiful, but like their lower cost brothers, they seem to only want to hold a "working" edge. This isn't bad because the knife will cut almost anything a knife can, but if you want one of these knives you can shave your arm with, forget the CRKT AUS8. I can sharpen my AUS6 blades to razor sharpness, and this is truly puzzling, but they will lose their edge after substantial cutting.

Another thing that's odd is that CRKT's knife Slidesharp doesn't seem to have the correct angle for sharpening CRKT's chisel grind knives. I say it's odd because so many of CRKT's knives have the chisel grind edge. The serrated parts of the blade also are a minus, as they're bumpy and don't cut well. I can take my Cold Steel Voyager with serrations and cut cleanly through a sheet of paper. With the bumpy types of serrations on many blades, you'll just tear the paper rather than cut it.

Having said all this, I've never had a loose CRKT knife. I didn't know that some knives are made in China while others are not, but I would have thought that one model was as good as another. Still, I have one Smith & Wesson HRT Magnesium knife that's obviously well made and fully functional (a first run) and about four others that are made in China and are just garbage. You can see the differences in materials and workmanship and you can feel it when opening and closing them. So who knows?
 
Are you sure you got the original one?there are many M16 counterfeits out there.u can even see a warning about them on the CRKT website.
 
If you bought it from Wal-Mart, it's most likely not a copy.


My M16 pivot screw came loose, blade shot out and the screw was lost. Sent it to CRKT, they sent me a new knife. Good warranty service there. :thumbup:
 
Frankly, I've handled maybe a dozen different CKRTs and they all seemed like junk to me. Strangely enough when I was at work and chatting with another guy about a new Benchmade I had picked up another fella had to jump in with his two cents: "Aw, don't buy a Benchmade. Get a CKRT M16! Much better!" :rolleyes:
Maybe I've only seen duds, but in the same relative price range you could be picking up some nice Kershaws. Hell, the 20 dollar Byyrd CaraCara knives I've used have been better fitted then any of the M16's I've seen.

FAL
 
I heard all the great things about the M16 also. As soon as it came out of the box it went back in. The mechanics and geometry just weren't right.
This was my third and probably last CRKT.
 
Try the M21. Mine has no play in the blade at all, AUS-8, aluminum anodized handles. My first M16 had a little bit of play on the blade, was the AUS-4 steel, but so far it has been fine. Play with the flipper a LOT and nothing has come loose so far. CRKT has a G-10 handle model coming out very soon.
DSC03138.jpg
 
Back
Top