- Joined
- May 31, 2001
- Messages
- 4,379
Larrin said:I am the son of Devin Thomas. I know that his steel performs just fine. The only thing better about S30V than my dad's damascus is edge retention, and that is because of vanadium carbides, which also make it harder to sharpen. His AEB-L stainless damascus (stainless, ladder, and some sharkstooth and basketweeve) steel will be extremely easy to sharpen, as tough or tougher than S30V, as stain resistant as 440C (excluding the carbon damascus), and have edge retention to equal 154-CM. I know this from use, toughness and edge retention numbers, etc. The biggest knock to damascus is that some people find that the soft nickel or 302/304 in damascus can sometimes give a "toothy" edge to damascus that some people don't like. However, in my father's damascus, the amount of nickel or 302/304 is usually around 8-11%, and I have never noticed any toothiness in cutting, though I may just not cut enough things. The 440C damascus my dad makes (the exotic patterns) will perform as well as 440C. So, if you consider 440C unfit for use, than I guess it's not for you. My dad has made some double high-carbon damascus in the past that Chris Reeve has used in very limited numbers (in fact, you may not know if you have it or not) that has no soft material that doesn't have a toothy edge if you don't like it. The soft nickel or 302/304 does add toughness to a blade; however, so it can be seen as an advantage, especially if you are of the crowd that prefer a toothy edge to a polished one. You'll find that people that say damascus shouldn't be used either have never actually used it, have a bias towards it in the first place, or used some second rate damascus.
I have a TNT with your Dad's sharkstooth stainless steel. It's badass. I'm not sure about the stain resistance, because I'm not in a hurry to test that, but I will say that it takes a great edge. Kinda toothy, which I love, and cuts like a dream. Two thumbs up ...
