disappointed in case peanut!!!

I actually suggested that earlier in this thread. I am thinking of some kind of give-a-way on these forums maybe. Or, just waiting for someone to come along that doesn't have a nice knife to call their own. They might just have a nice little peanut to accompany them.

@Jackknife, Thank you for posting your thoughts and that wonderful information. I guess your right when some people don't look at knives like we do, some say they are tools and others are more priceless than the Mona Lisa. My uncle has had the same case trapper for 22 years, skinned many dear and uses it as his main working utensil. I'll buy my dad a knife and in 3-4 months time, it needs to be replaced. I learned the hard way to not buy him a nice, expensive pocket knife. He uses them just like you explained and he's not really a knife knut, but someone that just looks for a good deal when he comes by one.

I have a couple of knives in my collection that are priceless and will just sit in the case, but then I have other knives that are disposable tools. And, I think deep down inside I bought the peanut because it was revered on these forums as a great thing. Maybe I just wanted to test how far it would really go? When I think about it, you're right, there is not going to be a knife that will stand up to that kind of use and me expect it to be as sharp as it was the first time I sharpened it that day. This peanut is a solider in a never ending war. Hopefully it will be passed along to someone that needs a good knife just as much as the next guy.

And, as far as the Stanley Utility knife goes. I have one and a husky lockback that gets used fairly often, but I am generally away from my tool bag, or need something a tad bit sharper or a little bit longer and it never quite does the trick.
 
Last edited:
Good deal Nokia & don't feel so bad.I've actually owned custom knives,that did dot really ever get too sharp,no matter who tried to sharpen them.
-Vince
 
Figured out I am gonna start a give a way for the peanut. But I dont know how I am gonna go about doing it. I don't have any family members or anyone close that needs it or is deserving of it. Any suggestions?
 
Would make a great knife for a kid ;).. I know it was one of my favorite knives when I was 10.
 
I hate you've had this experience. I will say that you should be able to get a better edge than you have, but as for snap with opening and closing I've experience the same with many of my newer case knives. Seems like the best snap I have in a Case is in a knife from the 70's. Unfortunate, but I think that good solid lock up is hard to find in their knives now. Still love them though.
 
Sure thing Sunnyd, but I can already tell you I retired the peanut for my 10OT in CV. The carbon stands up to everything so much better. And I love the natural pantina the cv blades get.

Yes, I am familiar with an array of different types of carbon steels. I've been using it since the 1960's. I just thought many others would likely benefit from the review. You don't have to do it. It was just an idea.

As far as the the peanut give-a-way; I like what Randy W said why not give the knife to a kid? In fact, why not give it away via this forum to a child of one of the forumite's sons or daughter. Nothing like the feeling that comes from passing on a traditional pocket knife to the next generation of slipjoint users.
 
Well, I got to thinking on that and it would be a great idea and there will eventually be a give-a-way. In the mean time, I am going to think of a decent idea for the give-a-way and I'll get back to you guys.

As far as the reviews go, I'll give a small descriptive paragraph on how the fair against each other and how I like the knives.
 
I know this is the traditional forum, but how about the Spyderco Native? $39.95, S30V steel and built to take this kinda use for a while
 
(sorry traditional forum)

Just about any knife you buy is going to be used up like this. I just chose an outstanding knife when I decided to use it in the line of work. S30V is a good working steel as far as I am concerned and the Spyderco Native is an excellent choice of a working knife. That knife can take a nice beating and then still has room to talk. But, just remember that in that type of environment, a knife is a tool so it is going to get used and its probably going to be used a lot more aggressively then someone who just carries it around to open boxes.
 
I really do not understand why folk carry an expensive super steel knife with one handed opening for construction.

Having work for many years as an electrician and a carpenter,
the best work knife was and still is a Stanley 99 utility knife for $6 and 100 blades for $10
or for live electrical work a good quality plastic snap off blade knife with a lock for $6 and $6 for 10 blades (7 snap offs = 70 new points for work).
You can adjust the length of the blade showing. Very safe.

And if one of these knives would not cut, then it was the wrong tool for the job!
Reach in to your tool pouch for side cutter, tin snips, a chisel, or use a saw.

I also carried on my pouch, a Colonial Electrician's knife in carbon with a locking reamer.
 
The Queen went out this morning...you should have it in a couple of days.
 
The Queen went out this morning...you should have it in a couple of days.

nokia,

That's one helluva nice Queen your getting. I have the Gunstock in D-2 myself and it reminds me of the old Timex watches, "takes a lick'n & keeps on tick'n"..

Good Old American made cutlery steeped in such rich history is hard to beat! :D Good Luck to you..

000_1980.jpg
 
nokia,

That's one helluva nice Queen your getting. I have the Gunstock in D-2 myself and it reminds me of the old Timex watches, "takes a lick'n & keeps on tick'n"..

Good Old American made cutlery steeped in such rich history is hard to beat! :D Good Luck to you..

000_1980.jpg

Hey, that looks vaguely familiar!;) I've been enjoying the Wharnie trapper; it is my first Wharncliffe, and I find it a very handy blade-type.
 
Both are great pocket knives that have that little something called American ingenuity!.:D

Thanks for your comments,

Anthony
 
Thanks for everything guys.

Now, if we can only get some Rough Riders made in the good ol' U S of A.
 
I bought the peanut because it was revered on these forums as a great thing. Maybe I just wanted to test how far it would really go?

Seems to me your beef is with the performance of the stainless steel on your peanut. Why not try a CV model instead? The yellow handled ones come mighty cheap.
 
Yeah, I think I am just going to retire this peanut for good and give it off to someone. I would love to keep it, but it would be better in someone's hands that will actually use the knife. I might try a yellow handle peanut with CV blades one day, but not anytime soon. Thanks for the suggestion.
 
Both of my new knives came in today from two great members here at Bladeforums. I don't have to to post on them or put up pictures, but I'll do that later tonight or tomorrow and I'll give credit were credit is due. In the mean time, thanks!!! *(you know who you are)
 
Both of my new knives came in today from two great members here at Bladeforums. I don't have to to post on them or put up pictures, but I'll do that later tonight or tomorrow and I'll give credit were credit is due. In the mean time, thanks!!! *(you know who you are)

Glad to hear they arrived. I know I'm interested in your initial impressions. How do you think they will stand up to the work you're going to throw at them?
 
Back
Top