This predicament is exactly what made me shift heavily into practicing sharpening.
First Off I wanted to say thanks for everyone's responses. I totally agree with pretty much all you've said and find the "making a knife your own" hits home at what's interesting and personal about the hobby. Working on knives as projects shifts it from being a "where out there is the knife I need" to "how can I make something really useful and personal to me." Does anyone else have the simultaneous excitement and disappointment when buying a new knife? Like your excited to get something new but you're also sort of sad that it might make you appreciate the knives you have less. For instance I like the idea of a minimal and practical EDC pairing but now I have too many options. Well the back right pocket is perfect for a doukdouk squirrel, the watch pocket fits my 108Ot stockman perfectly, I have to carry my alox pioneer and Leatherman Micra in Right front pocket with change because they wont get scratched like wood or bone, I love soddies so I'll have one in my left pocket with my phone, my dinner knife Opinel 6 goes in my right shirt pocket... and of course I need a tiny opi for sharpening my pencil. lol. Oh and its cold out so I'll wear a coat! More Pockets! more knives! There's just so much redundancy. Its ridiculous.
I'd like to get down to 3 EDCs and rotate them out. Probably somethign like this 1. Small stockman, peanut, or pen knife (watch pocket), 2. Midsize utility slipjoint (sodbuster, SAK alox, TL-29 etc), and 3. Slim large backpocket knife (doukdouk, mercator, case BP).
I like the idea of less is more and may decide to wait a few months and possibly invest in something nicer like a GEC #15, but my only fear is if I jump into the higher price rung and things get out of control again... the consequences will be greater. lol. I definitely will sell off what I dont use starting with the ones I dont even like. I buy knives for their history, aesthetics and usefulness. If a particular pattern or collection appeals to me I might try to pick up a series of them, but they're not shelf sitters or safe queens. I have a Boker Tree Brand Congress that commemorates the 8 hour work day which I just like to carry to remember the struggles of workers from the past. lol.
So for now (with three unnecessary knives in the post enroute to me) I'll get back to some of those projects I've been meaning to work on and use what I got. and I'll be checking in to let y'all know how things are going. Thanks again guys, y'all are swell.