Diversity and different knives for different tasks

Joined
Apr 1, 2022
Messages
840
Out of all knives I have, they all have some key differences.
If they have similar size blade and shape, they at least have significantly different steel (like carbon vs stainless).

Yet, I see people owning 4-5 same knives, just with handles being in different colors.
Or a guy I know that has VG10 San Mai SRK and has got Fallkniven A1 in that same steel... and then CoS Fallkniven too.

Is it just for collection purposes or addiction or what is the cause?
 
Collection and Variety: Some knife collectors appreciate the diversity offered by different versions or variations of a knife. Owning multiple variations allows them to showcase various materials, colors, or finishes, and to appreciate the unique characteristics of each knife.

Personal Preference:
Some individuals may have a strong affinity for a specific model or brand of knife. Owning multiple versions of the same knife allows them to have backup options or variations to suit different purposes or preferences. They may also appreciate the aesthetics of different handle colors or finishes.

Functional Considerations: Owning knives with different materials or steels can serve functional purposes. Different steels offer varying levels of hardness, corrosion resistance, or edge retention, which can be advantageous for specific tasks or environments. Having multiple knives with different steel types allows users to select the most appropriate one for a particular use case.

Curiosity and Exploration: Some knife enthusiasts enjoy exploring and experimenting with different knives and materials. They may acquire multiple variations of the same knife to compare and contrast their performance, durability, or other characteristics. This curiosity-driven approach helps them gain a deeper understanding of knives and their specific attributes.

Ultimately, the reasons for owning multiple versions of the same knife can be attributed to collecting for variety, personal preference, functional considerations, and the desire to explore and learn more about knives. Individual motivations may vary, and it's up to each person to decide what appeals to them in their knife collection.
 
☝️ spot on. I'm firmly in the latter two categories, although I have bought a few duplicates to keep backups on hand in case an especially favored model is lost/broken/discontinued. I imagine most BF members share traits amongst several, if not all categories.

It's worth mentioning that my decision making is driven by the desire for the "perfect" knife. That goal is simply not attainable, but the search is fun and I'm fortunate in having many knives that, to me, are perfect. Well, they were perfct for a little while at least until I discover the next perfect knife.
 
Collection and Variety: Some knife collectors appreciate the diversity offered by different versions or variations of a knife. Owning multiple variations allows them to showcase various materials, colors, or finishes, and to appreciate the unique characteristics of each knife.

Personal Preference: Some individuals may have a strong affinity for a specific model or brand of knife. Owning multiple versions of the same knife allows them to have backup options or variations to suit different purposes or preferences. They may also appreciate the aesthetics of different handle colors or finishes.

Functional Considerations: Owning knives with different materials or steels can serve functional purposes. Different steels offer varying levels of hardness, corrosion resistance, or edge retention, which can be advantageous for specific tasks or environments. Having multiple knives with different steel types allows users to select the most appropriate one for a particular use case.

Curiosity and Exploration: Some knife enthusiasts enjoy exploring and experimenting with different knives and materials. They may acquire multiple variations of the same knife to compare and contrast their performance, durability, or other characteristics. This curiosity-driven approach helps them gain a deeper understanding of knives and their specific attributes.

Ultimately, the reasons for owning multiple versions of the same knife can be attributed to collecting for variety, personal preference, functional considerations, and the desire to explore and learn more about knives. Individual motivations may vary, and it's up to each person to decide what appeals to them in their knife collection.

I like these distinctions... Very well thought out! :)
 
Collection and Variety: Some knife collectors appreciate the diversity offered by different versions or variations of a knife. Owning multiple variations allows them to showcase various materials, colors, or finishes, and to appreciate the unique characteristics of each knife.

Personal Preference: Some individuals may have a strong affinity for a specific model or brand of knife. Owning multiple versions of the same knife allows them to have backup options or variations to suit different purposes or preferences. They may also appreciate the aesthetics of different handle colors or finishes.

Functional Considerations: Owning knives with different materials or steels can serve functional purposes. Different steels offer varying levels of hardness, corrosion resistance, or edge retention, which can be advantageous for specific tasks or environments. Having multiple knives with different steel types allows users to select the most appropriate one for a particular use case.

Curiosity and Exploration: Some knife enthusiasts enjoy exploring and experimenting with different knives and materials. They may acquire multiple variations of the same knife to compare and contrast their performance, durability, or other characteristics. This curiosity-driven approach helps them gain a deeper understanding of knives and their specific attributes.

Ultimately, the reasons for owning multiple versions of the same knife can be attributed to collecting for variety, personal preference, functional considerations, and the desire to explore and learn more about knives. Individual motivations may vary, and it's up to each person to decide what appeals to them in their knife collection.
My individual knife purchases preferably cover two or more of these points each. The one I just bought covers all four.
 
I have a Damascus fetish. Whew, I feel much better confessing that kink. Well, I should add for the record that I also have a Mokume Gane fetish.
 
Then there's yet another consideration which I employ.

There are things that I would do absent much regard with my <$75 knives that I think twice before doing with my $150 knives that I wouldn't dare consider with my expensive knives.

For much of my dirty work (potentially damaging to the knife) AUS-8 or 10 in folders (Cold Steel Voyagers) or 1095 in fixed blades (Becker Knives) is absolutely fine with me; very fine, in fact. But when I want 3V - say on a remote big game hunt or other extended outing, well, I want 3V!

For those of you who want what you want, I get it and agree with you. OTOH, even though I am not a fan of MicroTech, I do agree with their honesty in disclosing that the type of steel may vary from time to time.
 
Last edited:
I have recently limited my knife purchases to knives that have one or more features that I currently do not have with any knife in my stable. For example, I bought a Civivi Chevalier because it had three features that I lacked: damascus, wood scales, and a button lock. I purchased a Kershaw Launch 11 because of the aluminum handle and automatic deployment, each of which I do not currently own. OTF may be my next purchase, thinking it over for now.
 
I have different models and versions because I can, for variety and addiction. From a practical standpoint I can have a few different knives so I have a spare in case I lose one, or one gets dull for some reason. In reality I have about twice that many. But as for different uses, I have some knives that I like for work knives and a couple that I like for EDC, and I recently bought another knife to use strictly for hiking/camping/backpacking.
 
Normally I rock around 4-5 set of knives all at 3.5'. I don't like to mix and match locking systems anymore because I learned that muscle memory can screw you up, so I try to be consistent as much as I can. Due to this, I mainly focus on one brand when it comes to folders that are actually going to be used. I still indulge in other brands but these are just display pieces now.
 
Out of all knives I have, they all have some key differences.
If they have similar size blade and shape, they at least have significantly different steel (like carbon vs stainless).

Yet, I see people owning 4-5 same knives, just with handles being in different colors.
Or a guy I know that has VG10 San Mai SRK and has got Fallkniven A1 in that same steel... and then CoS Fallkniven too.

Is it just for collection purposes or addiction or what is the cause?
Long winded reply ahead!

As someone with entirely too many knives in my collection (many of which have a similar blade shape), it's simple. Variety is the spice of life. The days when a mountain man had a single knife on his belt that carried him through his whole life, and which was used to prepare food, skin/quarter an animal, do wood-processing tasks, dig, pry, defend himself from a wild animal, trim materials or plants, and on and on, those days are long gone for a majority of people. The hardest "use" most peoples' knives these days will see are things like opening Amazon packages, opening that clamshell packaged toy for your child, cutting your lunch sandwich in half (and then the apple you packed with it), nipping a thread off a shirt, and so on. And all of those tasks could be handled by virtually any blade shape, with any grind, in almost any steel. That fact isn't really in dispute, and we all know it.

Now, as to your questions: some folks just like variety, even when that variety makes a selection of things identical in any actual use aspect. Me? Hell, here's an example. I have the Spyderco Delica in almost every steel they come in (still missing a few early day oddballs like AUS-6*), and different handle scale colors. A Spyderco Delica, as you might have surmised, in say, ZDP-189 cuts an apple into slices in exactly the same way that one in M4 or even VG-10 does it. I know that, everyone knows that. I just like collecting 'em. 🤷

Others will gravitate towards a collction of knives in a steel that they have found works for them, and there's also nothing wrong with that either. Maybe it's the perfect blend of edge holding and sharpenability, or they're an outdoorsman, or Tradesman, and need all day toughness. There's a steel out there for everyone, really. My own Father, I have given the guy thousands of dollars in knives over the years, but know what he likes to carry? A small no-name folder that has a personal inscription on it that another family member gave him from that place in the mall that does graduation/celebration gifts and you can have the gifts personalized. The blade is made from a "steel" is probably 100% comprised of an un-heat-treated sliver stamped from the back bumper of a '73 Super Beetle, but he keeps that thing SHARP, and it does everything he needs.

As for whether it's collecting or an addiction, well...I mean, it's a very fine, blurred line and we ARE on a knife forum which is a safe space for people with that particular affliction....LOL





* Folks, feel free to inbox me if you can help me out!
 
Many of my knives have one or more identical ones. I'm not talking about different colors or different steel, it's exactly the same knife. Because sometimes I buy one to put in a collection and one to use. Sometimes I see one for a very good price and I can buy two or three of them instead of paying the price I can afford to pay for one. It's nice to use a knife I like as I please and to have a spare. This way I can abuse some of my knives the way I want to.
 
"Diversity and different knives"
Is this about my Pride Knife?
Pride Knife.png
 

Attachments

  • Pride Knife.png
    Pride Knife.png
    25.7 KB · Views: 0
Back
Top