Do it all bushcraft/camp knife

You won't regret the Fallknive S1, I have poseted about it here many times. Great all round woods knife. They call it the Forest Knife, and I think that fits.

Another slab of solid VG-10 worth Considering is the Spyderco Temperance iI. I have found it to be an excellent all round woods/camp blade.
IMG_4808-XL.jpg



It'll break wood down, and slice it up,
IMG_4803-XL.jpg



It does a fantastic job as a camp cook too. As a one knife camp option, it's pretty cool. And I do really like the S-1, but the Temp 2 is more slicy.

Do your homework.
If you are going to be prepping a lot of food, making tent/tarp pegs, tripods, feather sticks, and curls, batoning some, and just general woods/camp related tasks. You may love the Temperance II.

If your hopes and dreams are closer to John Rambo, there may be better options.

It is also a very interesting knife to just sit and stare at.
IMG_4805-XL.jpg



I find it to be a great all around blade. And nice looking too.
IMG_4811-XL.jpg


For the record, out of the 3 on your original list. I'd go with the 6HM, strip it and use it.

That's a beautiful blade. I've never given it much look, until I saw these pics! Are the micarta handles factory from Spyderco?
 
If your hopes and dreams are closer to John Rambo, there may be better options.
That's a good one :D

Thanks for pointing out the Spyderco. Actually quite close to mark, on the slicey end.

I hope this will thread will serve also others who have similar needs so keep them coming, even after I make my choise. Very good discussion so far.
 
The Temperance it came with Micarta scales and it is a nice knife but I believe they were discontinued ... I might be wrong ...
 
Found the photos I was searching for, so more Temp 2 Love. I much handier in the woods than I am on the computer.

It breaks wood down just fine, as long as you don't lose your mind,
i-FTH64Vs-XL.jpg



Pencil, pencil lead, shavings, no issues,
i-cBZSQnK-XL.jpg



We have built many fires together,
i-Mng4Gwr-XL.jpg



It handles all that fine. But it also excels on the food side of camp. It even sees use in my kitchen.

Yes, that is Spam, don't judge me.
i-44RXshX-XL.jpg


A Spam Western is quite satisfying at home or in Camp. The Temp 2 can butter toast well also. You'd be surprised how many knives suck at this.
i-gJmHDqf-XL.jpg



If doing things like this is what you are seeking,
i-nrgFJ8M-XL.jpg



If I'm not on snowshoes, I'm cooking over a wood fire. And even sometimes on shoes. But I'm usually alone then. The bride has her limits.
i-QwMgBgH-XL.jpg



The bride is crazy too. She likes raw spinach on her burgers. The Temp batons right through that too.
i-P2N7bT6-XL.jpg



Campcraft/Bushcraft means different things to different people. But I find I build a shelter once a week, a deer or two per season, partridge, or a rabbit, sure, hiking stick ocasionally, a chair every now and then, a fire every day. But I cook three times a day.

I think amlot of folks are disappointed in their blades. Not because the blades are bad, or somehow lacking. But because they made their choices poorly. Big choppers are easy to like. Fighting knives are cool too. But one of my first testing criteria for a new knife, is will it feed me well?

The Temperance does that in spades,
i-zgBpSX7-XL.jpg


Being VG-10, it rinses well too.
i-ntDhD2G-XL.jpg


No matter which knife you buy. Be it the 6HM which I have to believe is a wonderful knife. I own the RB-3 and really like those handles. Or the Fallknive S-1 Forest Knife, or even the Spyderco Temperance 2.

Think about what percentages you will use your knife for. If batoning is 90% you will be happy with a big pry bar of a knife 90% of the time.
Kf fine carving is 90% you will be happy with a fine carver 90%of the time. You most likely won't be in love with the big chopper doing fine carving, but that isn't the knife's fault.

I think the 6HM, or maybe even the ESEE PR-4 or the S-1 or the T2 fall in the General purpose category. Jack of all, master of none type thing.
If all you usage is split between 10% here, and 15% there, with 20% doing something else. One of these type knives may very well make you happy over the long term. I say long term, because any knife will make you happy for a few days. Jt over time you will lose interest if you chose poorly.

Just to muddy the waters a bit more. ESEE just anounced/released a Nessmuk style Camp knife at Blade this week. I think it will come in somewhere around $100.00, and should fit your size requirements. It may be worth a look too. But it and the PR-4 are 1095 and coated in Black Oxide.

Hope this helps.
LV,
 
Bummer, didn't know they were discontinued until I finished typing.

But I'm sure there are some floating around. They can be had for middle one fifties.

Hopefully everything else I said will make sense and help ya.
 
Why don't you check out the Becker knives. They are affordable, tough and can do everything that you are wanting it to do!

1JiH2eQ.jpg

PVUZlUE.jpg

uJY0FRP.jpg


I agree on the Beckers too. I was actually going to recommend the BK-15, but that is discontinued as well.

The 16 is cool too. The 15 is big and slicy. PEESONALLY
I think the 9 is rather large for food tasks. Not saying it can't be done. Just wouldn't be my first choice.

I own or at one point owned almost all the Beckers. Nard to beat the t and 15 for food prep. The 16 is a great all rond bushcraft/camp general carry blade. A d even witn the added micarta handles it should be well withing budget.

Onnce they're stripped of course,
IMG_2258-XL.jpg
 
You won't regret the Fallknive S1, I have poseted about it here many times. Great all round woods knife. They call it the Forest Knife, and I think that fits.

Another slab of solid VG-10 worth Considering is the Spyderco Temperance iI. I have found it to be an excellent all round woods/camp blade.


It'll break wood down, and slice it up,



It does a fantastic job as a camp cook too. As a one knife camp option, it's pretty cool. And I do really like the S-1, but the Temp 2 is more slicy.

Do your homework.
If you are going to be prepping a lot of food, making tent/tarp pegs, tripods, feather sticks, and curls, batoning some, and just general woods/camp related tasks. You may love the Temperance II.

If your hopes and dreams are closer to John Rambo, there may be better options.

It is also a very interesting knife to just sit and stare at.



I find it to be a great all around blade. And nice looking too.


For the record, out of the 3 on your original list. I'd go with the 6HM, strip it and use it.

God damn I could look at that knife all day long. Sypderco makes some beautiful fixies. HOWEVER over 250$ seems REALLLLY high for a vg10 blade thats not a custom.
 
Back
Top