I have been receiving shipments of knives from US and Japan during the last few months, from both individuals and companies. The value declared were ranging from US$80 to US$350. All of the packages were shipped via the Post office, either USPS or Japanese Post. So far, only one (declared value of US$ 350) out of six shipments were charged GST and a CAD$10 'brokers fees' (by the Canada Post). All of the parcels were clearly indicated with a description of 'KNIFE'. All of my knife packages were cleared of Canada Border Service without any incidence or the package was opened for inspection. Due to the huge volume of packages going through the Canadian border, I am not sure how many or the percentage of the packages were X-rayed or opened for inspection. I suspect/speculate the Canada Border Service agents may focus their resources on packages from certain countries.
Yes, I agreed with Rick Marchand's remarks almost 100%. Only use USPS to ship to Canada. Don't have to go fancy on description, and just stated clearly it is a 'FIXED BLADE' knife (assuming it really is a fixed blade). It is always costs more to ship INTERNATIONALLY. Being a Canadian buyer, I am always ready to pay for the extra shipping charges. The only part I am not sure is about the insurance. I have been shopping from US for photographic equipment that costs thousands of US$, and none of them insured. I understand (may be I am wrong) that the limit of coverage is less than $1000. Even shipping within Canada, I was advised by the companies just ship with the Canada Post uninsured. Over the last 10 years, none of the packages were lost or stolen. So, unless you are shipping something your really think it is worth insurance and the extra costs (i.e. US$35 insured up to a $1,000 or $16 uninsured), shipped uninsured as long as the buyer is aware of the potential problem. I always advised the shipping party do NOT insured. One last thing, being the Canadian buyer, I always provide my phone number to my seller for cross border shipping.
NEVER, never use UPS, Purolator or FedEx as their so called 'broker's fees' can be huge compared the $10, charged by the Canada Post. Also, for smaller packages with value up to $200, the chance of being charged GST and broker's fees is quite small. There is always a chance of delay at the border, especially during the holiday seasons around Christmas when the volume of shipments are usually much much higher. The cross border shopping experience has been improved over the years. Once, luckily long long time ago, I have had a $4,000 shipping from US delayed at the Canada border (waiting for customs clearance) for over 3 months!!!! But, those incidence are mush less and far in between now.