I think, and I don't think you will have a hard time finding many others to agree with me, that D2 is among the best of steels for using/working knifes.
It is not as popular as some, such as ATS-34 and others, but that is just the nature of guys, and guy stuff. What is popular today, will eventually fade, and something else will be the newest latest and greatest. And it will probably be some old standby (like D2) that takes over the spot light.
I have heard that D2 is prone to staining, and will not polish out as pretty as some of the more popular steels. I have also heard that it requires someone who knows how to heat treat it properly to make it preform. It has been said many times in this forum, that Bob Dosier is as good as they come at heat treating D2.
As far as the staining is concerened, I have never had mine take a stain, or get rust. I do take care of it, but at the same time, I do store it in it's sheath, and that is supposed to be a no-no. I do put it away clean, and in a clean sheath.
As far as the polish goes, who cares! Do you want a working tool, or something shiney? (mine is from Melvin Dunn and has a very nice finish).
If you can't tell by now, I think you have a skinning knife that is second to none! Mine has proven itself for about ten years now, to out preform anything else I have come accross yet.
And by the way---there are many more members in this forum that deserve the title "expert" than me!
[This message has been edited by knzn (edited 25 December 1999).]