Ebony & Ivory (#15 Boys Knives)

AFAustin

Gold Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
2,505


There has been plenty written about GEC’s #15 Boys Knives, and with good reason as they are excellent knives and have been a big hit around here. I enjoyed reading the most recent thread by RevDevil regarding his pretty single blade clip in antique yellow jigged bone. At the risk of #15 overkill, I thought I’d add my own two cents.

I started out with a single blade spear in ebony. I liked it quite a bit, and though my limited knife budget doesn’t usually allow for 2 of the same model, when I saw the single blade clip in the smooth ivory bone, I succumbed to temptation and doubled my pleasure.

100_6343_zps3c63ea70.jpg


100_6346_zps525e6854.jpg


One of the hallmarks of the #15s, and it has been much commented on, is their simplicity. No need to worry about polishing out the blade etchings, since there are none! Likewise, no need to fret over a shield that sits a little proud, ‘cause there are none of those, either. The ebony and ivory scales on my two are simple and straightforward as well, and very attractive to my eye.

The fit and finish on both is excellent. Both have well centered blades, the pins are all flush with the scales, and the scales match up well. Any gaps are miniscule, and the tang and spring are either flush or very close in all positions. The pull suits me fine---about a 6 on the clip and 7 on the spear. .

I know there are differences of opinion on GEC’s sharp corners on the tang and swedges, but I am in the “anti” camp on this. With these knives, as with practically all GECs I’ve intended to keep for a while, I started out by spending a chunk of time smoothing out both the tang and the swedges with diamond files and Micromesh pads. They are now very comfortable in hand and in the pocket.

One of the very best things about these knives, IMHO, is the size. They are slim enough to be imminently pocketable, but just wide enough to afford a good grip. The 3 ½” length, while compact, is enough to allow for a 4-finger grip. I have owned and enjoyed several #25s, and while each has been a sturdy and attractive knife, the 3” length just won’t allow a 4th finger to squeeze in there. This is a semi-big deal to me because there is such an improvement in control and comfort when I can use a 4-finger grip.

100_6352_zps6efd0e72.jpg


100_6358_zps937cdb29.jpg


100_6360_zpsc468041e.jpg


100_6354_zpsa940cb03.jpg


100_6356_zps89b65343.jpg



Finally, on the subject of size, I am impressed how much blade GEC packs into these 3 ½” frames. There is a longer blade on these than with most knives I have with slightly greater overall lengths. (The dark red bone Case mini-trapper is listed at 3 ½” itself, but side-by-side with the #15s it is a bit longer). Well done, GEC!


100_6365_zps4d097c9d.jpg


100_6367_zps64819da1.jpg


Saving the best for last---performance. The comfortable 4-finger grip, the generous blade size, and the firm spring make for great little slicers. I put a nice edge on my first #15, the ebony spear, and was really enjoying it. Then when my ivory clip arrived, I put an OK edge on it but it wasn’t cutting like the spear. So, a couple of days ago I re-did the clip. I thinned out the bevel on my Worksharp, and took it through a good belt progression. Then I gave it just a bit of a microbevel on the Sharpmaker and finished with a few passes on a strop. It now cuts like a champ and the ebony spear is getting a little jealous!

100_6376_zpsecce7d37.jpg



Thanks for reading and looking, and I hope everyone has a great Fourth weekend.
smilie_flagge13.gif
And now on to the fajitas!


Andrew

100_6398_zps770939d0.jpg
 
Last edited:
You're making it very hard to resist these. I'm slowly falling in love with that single bladed ivory bone.

Great write up.

Must resist.....:cool:

John
 
Last edited:
You're making it very hard to resist these. I'm slowly falling in love with that single bladed ivory bone.

Great write up.

Must resist.....:cool:

John

Hope this helps....
devilsmiley.gif


s63e.jpg


And great write-up, Andrew. The #15, in its various incarnations, really hits it out of the park (and then there are the Charlows...).
beerchuge.gif
 
Excellent writeup! I've carried an ebony boys knife almost every day of 2013 and I love it
 
They are just fine knives! Plain and simple, and eminently usable.
I predict when you are an old Codger like me, one of those knives will be in your pocket!!
The blade will be half as wide as it is now from sharpening, and it will have a rich, lustrous patina. The wood will be a bit darkened from oiling it when you oil the joints every week or so, and the snap will still be there -
in your step for owning such a knife, and in the knife for owning such a knife!!:D
 
Great review, and great photos! It's good to have comparison shots too.
D'you know, I'm not sold. I don't know if its because they're trendy right now or what, but they just don't do it for me. I want to like them, but I always see so many others that I'd like more. Maybe if I had the disposable cash to buy one and try one out, it might grow on me, but I can't see it happening.
Such a strange thing.

Paul
 
Hope this helps....
devilsmiley.gif


s63e.jpg


And great write-up, Andrew. The #15, in its various incarnations, really hits it out of the park (and then there are the Charlows...).
beerchuge.gif


This was great timing. I found the ivory versions earlier this morning. The dealers pics weren't the best, but yours really showed how they look.
Now I know I will be ordering one this afternoon... :D

Now comes the big decision. Single blade, or two bladed version ? From what I have seen on here, it seems most prefer the single bladed versions.
 
Great review, and great photos! It's good to have comparison shots too.
D'you know, I'm not sold. I don't know if its because they're trendy right now or what, but they just don't do it for me. I want to like them, but I always see so many others that I'd like more. Maybe if I had the disposable cash to buy one and try one out, it might grow on me, but I can't see it happening.
Such a strange thing.

Paul

If I have to put effort into liking something, it's not the one for me, no matter how popular something is.

I went through the same thing with the Case SBJ's when they first came out. People were raving about the pattern, and how great the workmanship was, but they just didn't grab me. I wanted to like them, mostly because they did a nice job on the Chestnut bone, and they had CV blades. It wasn't enough for me..

Even if a person doesn't like a particular pattern, there is no shortage of others to chose from.
 
This was great timing. I found the ivory versions earlier this morning. The dealers pics weren't the best, but yours really showed how they look.
Now I know I will be ordering one this afternoon... :D

Now comes the big decision. Single blade, or two bladed version ? From what I have seen on here, it seems most prefer the single bladed versions.
I have a two bladed spear point Charlow from Charlie(waynorth), which is similar in size and I absolutely love. With that said.....
For these boys knives I like the slimmer single blade version. There's something about the single blade on this frame, whether it be the boys knife or Charlow, that screams "Use me!". I have been using the heck out of my two bladed #15, but I am also making sure to consciously use both blades so that the patina forms on both. It is very humid here, and my sweat seems to have double the normal amount of salt. Rust is a very real concern.

With the single blade, I wouldn't have this worry about making sure to use both blades.
My recommendation is for the single blade version, unless you have a need for the secondary pen blade.
Or just get both. ;)

John
 
Thanks for this thread and pictures, Andrew. :thumbup:

If I have to put effort into liking something, it's not the one for me, no matter how popular something is.

Well-said. :)

There's something about the single blade on this frame, whether it be the boys knife or Charlow, that screams "Use me!".

With this, I agree. I prefer two-bladed jacks as a default, but my single-bladed barlow on this frame has proved irresistible from the start.

That said, I wanted-- and went for-- the twofer in the ivory bone:
IMG_0175.jpg~original


Which, in conjunction with the barlow, translates into, er, "both." :D

~ P.
 
The #15 barehead w/ the single clip blade is my favorite GEC pattern. Perfect size for carry.

I'm looking forward to the sheepsfoot EZ open.
 
Last edited:
Fantastic write up with great pictures to back up your points, well done sir:thumbup:
 
Thanks for this thread and pictures, Andrew. :thumbup:



Well-said. :)



With this, I agree. I prefer two-bladed jacks as a default, but my single-bladed barlow on this frame has proved irresistible from the start.

That said, I wanted-- and went for-- the twofer in the ivory bone:
IMG_0175.jpg~original


Which, in conjunction with the barlow, translates into, er, "both." :D

~ P.

Very cool Sarah.

Anyone know if the Ivory bone versions were produced in smaller numbers ? The reason I ask is, of all the dealers that stock other versions of the 15, only a couple have the Ivory bone versions.
 
Thanks for the kind words, everyone.

One of these days I'm going to learn to take pics like Boggs and pertinux and 338375!

Andrew
 
Whoa, I just saw this while browsing. Great write up, I enjoyed reading it and the photos tied it together pretty well. Thanks for sharing Andy. :thumbup:
 
Anyone know if the Ivory bone versions were produced in smaller numbers ? The reason I ask is, of all the dealers that stock other versions of the 15, only a couple have the Ivory bone versions.

I can't say for certain, but that does seem to be the case. Though they don't appear to have been an SFO, either.
 
Back
Top