Ebook Reading Devices

Joined
Nov 28, 2008
Messages
2,165
Thanks to a suggestion by markksr, I am now thinking about buying an ebook reading device.

I am not very tech orientated and find my mind wondering going through the specifications of the various models available.

Therefore, any BF members who have experience, good and bad, your comments and suggestions would be most appreciated please?
 
I live in an area where English language books are extremely expensive and quite limited in availability. I put up with it for years before switching to e-books, and since I made the switch I haven't looked back once!

I've been nothing but happy with my Sony 505 reader. It's comfortable to hold for long periods of time, either hand, easy and fast to turn pages, and clear typeface. I'd say it was as easy or perhaps even easier to read than paper books. I chose the older 505 over the newer 700 as I didn't want the touch screen and the loss of contrast that went with it. I've noticed that several people who upgraded to the 700 have returned to the 505. I chose the Sony over Amazon's Kindle because I had no need for the keyboard, and living abroad I didn't want to spend an extra $200 for Kindle's wireless downloads if I couldn't use them. Having already built up a collection of several thousand e-books that I want to read, I had no need to connect to Amazon.

The battery for the Sony is long lasting, and I can read for about 10 days or longer on a single charge. (7,000 page turns) It takes about 3-4 hours with the wall charger to re-charge the reader, or about 6-8 hours if I want to charge it via the USB cable to my computer.

As for book formats, the Sony has its own, plus it can read several others. When combined with the free software, "Calibre" available at the MobilRead forum, you can convert LIT, MOBI, EPUB, HTML, PRC, RTF, TXT, PDF formats so all of these books are readable in the Sony. There are quite literally thousands of free e-books legally available all over the Net, (Project Guttenberg US, Project Guttenberg Canada, and Project Guttenberg Australia have over 500,000 alone!) and hundreds of thousands available from the Darkside (free torrent downloads.) So far, I have found every author and book that I've wanted without difficulty. Amazon.com, Sony Bookstore, and half a dozen other on-line book sellers offer everything you'd want. Many larger city public libraries offer free e-book borrowing.

Right now I have about 150 books loaded inside my reader, and usually read 3-4 at the same time. The bookmark function of the e-book reader makes this very easy to do, opening each book at the precise page were I left off. I also have about 1,000 mp3 files of music and learning programs. Sony has two separate spaces for memory cards in addition to its own internal memory. I can, if I want, listen to music while I read, choosing any song from the menu, or just listen without reading if that's my wish. Listening to music drains that battery faster than reading, so if I listen every time I'm reading, I have to re-charge after about 4-5 days.

Although there is a lot of e-book software available today, most of it free, the Sony comes with it's own e-book manager which is very good, especially when combined with 'Calibre.' I use Calibre to change meta-data and convert formats, then use Sony's software to catalog, manage, and upload to my reader. Very easy to use.

One quick tip for you; if you do get the Sony reader, don't order the Sony AC wall charger. It's waaaay too expensive! About $30 USD. Instead, get a generic PSP AC wall charger for $9.95. Works just as well.

Overall, I'm happy as a clam with this new device. I can put it into a ziplock bag and read in the pool or hot tub, or to protect it at the beach. (A waterproof map case works even better.) It's perfect for travel as I don't have to carry 4-5 books with me for a two week trip. It's as small as a paperback and usually thinner than most of them, and rugged enough to last.

If you have other questions, feel free to msg me.

Stitchawl
 
This is getting interesting.

I wasn't impressed with Kindle or Kindle 2 for the money, especially since a couple of reviewers brought up problems I wouldn't want to deal with.
 
Great review there stitchawl. I'm going to look for one of those.

I agree with gajinoz 110% about the review of the Sony ...top flight info both regarding the Sony and also I appreciate the tips re the charger and the availability of free books from 'proper' sources.:thumbup:
 
There are plenty of legal books available from dozens of different sources. And there are plenty of free legal books, even new best sellers. The Sony bookstore is always offering half a dozen new books in various genres for free. Plus, if they are still doing it, Sony gives 100 free books with the purchase of its reader.

Besides the classics (which are ALL free from Project Gutenberg,) I read mysteries, sci-fi, thrillers, poetry, science, and philosophy. I have had absolutely no difficulties finding any and all books that I've wanted. Opps... I just remembered... I couldn't find some Elmore Leonard that I wanted, or Stephen Leather. Too bad. They are both very good authors! (I did find several Elmore Leonard books, just not the particular one I wanted... for free.) Other than those, though, I've gotten everything I've wanted.

Buying e-books is cheaper than buying paper. Getting books from the libraries is free but often you have to be on a waiting list for the new releases. As I don't live in New York, I have to pay $100 for a N.Y. Public Library card, but this gives me access to every new book that comes out as well as thousands of older ones. The fact that I live 10,000 miles away from the library doesn't enter into the equation. I can get the books faster than if I lived in Harlem and took the A-train downtown!

Take a quick look at Project Gutenberg, and do so for all three countries. Half a million books there, all free, all download-able, and all in Sony's native format. If you are a chronic newspaper reader, you can have most major newspapers delivered to your computer daily, and read them on your e-book reader. That is one of Kindle's attractions: you can have the papers delivered right to your reader... if it's working correctly.

Here is another caveat; if your need is to read and annotate pdf files, do NOT get the Sony reader. While it will read pdf files, it doesn't annotate. And unless the pdf file is text, it might be too small to read on the Sony unless you re-format it. There are better choices for reading technical pdf with lots of graphic embedded in them. But for books and magazines, in my opinion, the Sony 505 is hard to beat. (Now if someone would be so kind as to tell Sony that I'm doing such a good job advertising for them and they should give me some free books.... :D )

Stitchawl
 
As I mentioned in the other thread, I have the eBookwise-1150 and have been nothing but pleased with it. (click the link to read more about it)
 
Interesting stuff. I'm not surprised about Sony. I don't have that many brand loyalties, but they are my go-to guys for mass market consumer grade electronics other than computers. I currently have all Sony TV's and one of their SACD players. I may have to check out one of these devices:thumbup:
 
I actually really like my Kindle. Amazon has ALOT of content, and so far, I've been very pleased with the wireless service, which is included in the price of the book. I'm a little tired of classic literature, but the Project Gutenberg material is available for the Kindle as well. What I love about the Kindle, is the ability to buy a new book, on the spot without connecting to my computer. Battery life is excellent, since I've only rechaged it 4-5 times since I received it for Christmas and have read at least a dozen books on it since then. I read at least 1 1/2 hrs. a day, so I'm pleased. My only complaint is it's not backlit, but that is the price you pay for longer battery life. Since, I finished Neal Stephenson's Quicksilver on one charge, I'd say battery life is very impressive. Those of you familiar with his work will understand!;)
 
I've been reading ebooks on a Palm hand held device for years. First a Palm PDA and more recently I'm on my second Palm smart phone. I love them and have several hundred ebooks on my hard drive at home.

Sure it does not have the screen area of the dedicated readers, but I don't really find that an issue, unless the book has illustrations. You can adjust the size of the type face on the screen so it is just as readable as the larger, dedicated readers. You just scroll through each screen faster. There are readers for just about all the popular ebook formats available for Palm OS or Windows Mobile smartphones so there is pleny of material available. Since the phone has internet access, I can buy and download books from several ebook retailers on-line from anywhere (admittedly, not from Amazon, but there are lots of other retailers selling ebooks besides them like Mobipiocket, Fictionwise, etc.).

In addition, it has the advantage of combining all my electronic devices (PDA, phone, MP3 player and ebook reader) into one handy unit that I always have with me. So, I can read a few pages of the latest book while waiting in line at the grocery store, while eating lunch, or whenever else I have a few minutes to spare.
 
Until recently, I never realized how popular e-book reading was. In fact, prior to about 6 months ago when I got a notice from Amazon about the new Kindle2 I didn't even know that readers existed! :o I thought you had to read them on your computer. I've known about Project Gutenberg for about 10 years and had even downloaded a couple of documents from there for some work I was doing, but I don't enjoy reading a book on my computer screen. I thought this idea of the Kindle sounded pretty good, IF it was all they said it was. Unfortunately, I know I couldn't use a lot of Kindle's features while living abroad.

The cost of English language books in Japan is really prohibitive, and I have to travel a minimum of 45 minutes to get to a store that sells them, 90 minutes to get to another. Combine the cost and the hassle and I was very interested to learn more about this new technology. What I found was eye-opening. And very pleasant! :thumbup:

I started with a net search of readers. There are a heck of a lot of them out there. Then I did a search for e-book reader forums and read what everyone was saying, especially the software writers as I figured they would be the ones with the latest information. A lot of the 'reading public' had their tried-and-true device and were holding on to them despite changes and advances in the technologies, while the software writers were working towards improving the best of those machines. That led me to three devices; the Kindle, the Sony, and iRex. Although getting great reviews, the iRex was just waaaay too expensive and seemed more advantageous for technical reading than what I needed in a book reader, leaving me with the Kindle and the Sony.

Riding the rush hour trains in Japan is a lesson in itself in e-book reading. Most of the commuters have their eyes glued to their mobile phones and PDA's, using them for reading newspapers, reading the internet, and reading books. (Some are just watching TV on them,) but these days I don't see so many people with paper books, especially the large 'manga' (telephone book sized comics) that were so popular 10 years ago. In fact, the stores selling the manga have all reduced their stock to half of what it used to be! That is quite telling in and of itself.

Searching for e-books turned out to be the biggest delight. No only are there numerous on-line vendors carrying all the latest books for sale and immediate download, but there are many, many free archives with untold numbers of older books in every genre. (Including, I might add, knife related, bushcraft related, gun related, etc.) E-book forums have their own archives of free e-books, as well as free software for managing and converting e-book formats to the one you need for your reader. I'm not technically oriented and can't write code, but these programs are GUI and so it's just a push of the button and I have another book to read.

When all was said and done, and I had decided that this wasn't just a passing fad, I decided what my needs were for an e-book reader, chose one and ordered it from the States. Like digital cameras replacing film for 95% of the people, the e-book will slowly replace the paper market. It's just much more convenient, cheaper to produce, more ecologically sound, takes up less storage space, and works just as well. True, an e-book doesn't have the warm, cozy feel of a cherished leather-bound volume so the bibliophile might not want it. But for an avid reader it's a joy!

Stitchawl
 
When all was said and done, and I had decided that this wasn't just a passing fad...

... But for an avid reader it's a joy!

Stitchawl

Thanks for your detailed posts and to me your words above sum up why I will be buying an ebook reader in the near future.:thumbup:

And thank you markksr for getting me thinking about ebooks and ebook readers in the first place.:)
 
Last edited:
You're very welcome. :)


P.S. Another good site for free ebooks is http://manybooks.net/.

Great site! Thanks for the URL! I hadn't seen this one before, and I picked up 25 books immediately. I like the way the site is laid out. I went looking for 'series' books and found plenty of them quickly. I only stopped because I wanted to write this note. I'll go back. This site seems to be one of the nicer ones as it will download your book in virtually any reader format that you need! I don't have to bother converting it to a more compatible format (although that really isn't difficult and only takes 2-3 minutes.)


Stitchawl
 
I've been using a little Palm Zire 31 as an ebook reader for years. They are very inexpensive, but handy. The screen is small, but for travel it's very useful.

Andy
 
Just to toss it out there, Sony PSP or Nintendo DS handheld gaming systems can also be used as ebook readers if one knows what to do.
 
I read all my books on my IPhone! It is the best book reader ever. If you have a phone you won't get rid of you could get the Ipod Touch. Same as the Iphone with-out the phone.
 
I was interested in the kindle when they first came out - e-mailed my former partner in the security business asking him what he thought ( he's a super geek) - his e-mail back was short and sweet "Have you read the EULA?"
End User Licensing Agreement - don't just click yes I agree - read it!
 
Back
Top