EDC replacement from GEC

Pàdruig

Reap What You Sow
Platinum Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2016
Messages
11,043
So my current EDC knife is a big brick of a knife, it pretty much epitomizes the blade that the young man in jackknife's recent Thin Blade Knife stories started with. It is large, heavy, expensive, made with super steel and other premium materials and in the end, is an excellent knife.

That being said, over the years that I have carried it, it has typically proven to be far more knife than is needed for most everyday tasks and due to its steel and the slight recurve, is actually difficult to sharpen so I have been on the casual lookout for a potential replacement. I am usually not a "one knife" kind of guy and often carry multiples, whether they be in my pockets and/or in the pack that I carry with me everywhere I go. Since there is usually a stout fixed blade in my pack, having a tank-like folder in my pocket is not really necessary.

Some time ago, before I started really frequenting these forums I came across someone elsewhere who was showing off a more traditional folder. At the time, I thought it was a handsome piece and was curious who made it, soon discovering that it was a GEC, though I forget what model/pattern. Despite really liking what I was seeing, I didn't allow my curiosity to carry me much further as my interests were into other types for the most part at that time. Since arriving here and becoming a part of these forums in the last several weeks, my interest in traditionals has rekindled and I have been pouring over the abundance of "knife porn" contained within this particular sub-forum. As a result I have been giving far more serious thought to replacing my EDC user knife with something far more traditional and due to the overwhelming support and desire for GEC knives, I am looking to them in particular to provide me with the "one".

However, I am finding that such a task is easier said than done as I am a man with discriminating tastes and though all GEC knives are beautiful in their own way, not all of them "speak to me" in a manner that facilitates me emptying my wallet for just any knife. As a result, my knife collection overall is rather modest, which my wife certainly appreciates due to budgets and such, but I am always on the lookout to expand...

So I decided to reach out to you fine folks and perhaps you might honor me with a recommendation or two based on the criteria I lay out below.

  • I enjoy large knives, hence the reason I have carried my current folder for so long. I have large hands and therefore like my knives to have a feeling of substance when I handle and use them. I like them to have some heft too. Call me weird, but when something has weight to it, it lends itself in my mind to being something of substance and quality.
  • I prefer single blade folders though multiple blades is not a deal breaker. I have a very small traditional folder that I carry with me regularly. Though it is more of a keepsake/memento, I still use it to ream my pipe on occassion when I have forgotten my pipe tool.
  • The broad spear blade "speaks to me", I think GEC executes this style of blade very well.
  • In terms of handle materials, I have a fondness for dark woods and dark red jigged bone. I also really like the OD linen micarta that I see on some of the knives as well.

I really like the the shape and style of the single blade #14's that GEC currently has and I plan on getting one regardless of its small size. If they made something similar to that, but larger, I would be all over it.

I hope to be able to acquire my first GEC's after the New Year as I do not like to shop for myself around Christmas time. I am rather new to GEC and am still learning how to determine what is available or not, it seems there is almost a science to it... I appreciate any and all recommendations or input, my apologies for the long winded post.
 
The 14 is a smaller 15, the 15 is my personal favourite. At 6'3" my hands are pretty large.
The 77 is even bigger than the 15. I carry a 15 edc no matter what. Ebony is my preferred handle, but I have a 15 and a 14 with nifebrite handles. They glow in the dark!! Happy hunting, post what you decide on!
 
A #99 might suit you, if you can find one. They came out with spear, clip, and wharncliffe blades. They also lock, something of a plus for me personally.
Thanks, Neal
 
Pàdruig;16753796 said:
I really like the the shape and style of the single blade #14's that GEC currently has and I plan on getting one regardless of its small size. If they made something similar to that, but larger, I would be all over it.

Based on these two sentences, it's definitely the GEC #15 Boy's Knife that you're looking for. I don't consider it a big knife but it's the same basic frame as the #14 only bigger. Not sure when the single Spear blade models were made.
 
There is a science to buying GEC knives, or perhaps it's a "dark art." I am relatively new at it, so this may be some help, but others will be more expert. First, go to GEC's website and find the list of dealers. Then go to dealer websites to see the different patterns, most of which will be out of stock, but you will see the options. Then decide if one of the current patterns, that are now available, suits you. The 71 Bullnose is coming soon, and might fit your criteria.
 
GEC 15 is a bigger version of the 14. 77 is a bigger version of the 15. 66 and 68 are the same size as the 15 but with slightly different frame shapes. 48 is slightly longer and slimmer than the 77s.

You have to wait until a pattern you want is being produced, and then work with your choice of dealer(s) to purchase one.

They occasionally update their production schedule. http://greateasterncutlery.net/blog/production-schedule/ Some knives are produced as special factory orders, and you have to contact whoever placed the SFO to see how to buy from them. Sometimes the full contact info is on the production schedule page, sometimes you have to do a little research.
 
I like the 77 size frame but I like the 72 , 73 , and 74 size frames even better . If you prefer larger knives , then I feel that you need to go larger than the 15 frame .
The 15 frame has a lot of options for you , and they are well made , but that are not large . They are just bigger than the 14's and other smaller knives..
I personally prefer the 73 with a drop point blade , but that is just my opinion.
Good luck on your quest my friend .

Harry
 
72 spear point in ebony has the fattest spear blade ever.
Might be difficult to find but worth a look.
 
As someone who also usually carries a big modern folder, but find that it is often more than I need for day to day things, I have been carrying a traditional in my watch pocket for a few years now. Since you are specifically asking for GEC options, I won't suggest others, however, I would suggest maybe considering other blade shapes than spear. The #15 pattern is a good one, as has been mentioned, and if you can tolerate a sheepfoot blade (I think you will find it quite handy for stuff like opening boxes and such) and a caplifter, then you have a good chance of finding an OD green micarta Huckleberry Boy's knife right now that might do the job for you. I have a maroon micarta Beer Scout that I am absolutely in love with.

Another option if you want a GEC spear blade is the 2016 forum knife, you can find them here http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...2016-forum-knife-ordering-thread-Only-12-left!! Which is nice considering how byzantine it can be trying to find the GEC you want.

Also, there was a recent run if the Lick Creek Boy's knife with single blade in OD Green Micarta on the #15 pattern, so you still might find one of those around if you look, and it would probably meet all your stated requirements.
 
+1 with abbydaddy suggestion, get the 2016 forum knife while you can, otherwise listen to Old Engineer, the 72,73,74 are readily available at the dealers and are wonderful knives. Another run of 74's are coming out soon also, a couple being sfo's.
 
I sent you a PM with my feelings on a Bull Buster for a large traditional... they come up from time to time on the forum. Part of the fun of traditionals and GEC IMHO is the hunt...
 
I know you said GEC, but the #14 is a simple straight jack. Don't limit yourself. Lots of makers have made this pattern through the years with a spear main. This one, at 3 3/4" closed, was made by Queen a few years ago. They can still be found with some looking.

12727862465_f650a2a7c8_c.jpg
 
To piggyback on kamagong (i.e. if you do consider something outside of GEC), you can find New Old Stock Camillus TL-29s for $20-30, which you can then send off to someone like Glennbad to be made into a 3 3/4" single spear straight Jack with (almost) whatever handle material you desire. You would have to wait a bit to get your final product, but it would be a high quality, brand new, one of a kind, large, single blade traditional. The thread "Glennbad is a baaaad man" will show you many examples of modified TL-29s. http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/1184347-Glennbad-is-a-baaaad-man?highlight=glennbad
 
The #15 comes highly recommended as mentioned by several others. My first GEC love was the #77 and I'm still partial to that pattern but after adding a few 15's to the rotation I certainly understand their appeal. If you decide on the knife you like, a post in the Wanting To Buy section may help you land what you are looking for instead of waiting for a new run. The vast majority of my purchases here have come via that route.

Kamagong that is a gorgeous Queen, smooth handles and shields are very classy!
 
I have small hands but not all small knives suit me, width of handle is important. But I find the GEC 73 to be an excellent frame for all hand sizes, not too big or small, with weight but not weighed down. Many variants have appeared so you should have no difficulty in finding Bone, Wood or Stag to your taste. They also come in liner lock versions too which are tab liners in addition to the backspring on a conventional slipjoint, offers extra security at times. The only thing is that a 73 is Drop-Point (my favourite) but you wanted Spear. The 85 has a nice bulbous Spear blade but you can also consider Queen Cutlery's No.6 Teardrop liner lock which has a pointier Zulu style Spear

73

IMG_1532.jpg


85 top with 33

IMG_4212.jpg


Queen Cutlery Teardrop with Bark River

IMG_3718.jpg


Queen Cutlery Heritage in Coco

IMG_2769.jpg


Regards, Will
 
Last edited:
For a bit larger traditional with a spear blade, you might consider checking out teardrop jacks. There are companies that make them similar to the GEC 85 but a bit larger. I think Queen has some as part of their regular lineup. Schatt & Morgan does as well. I like the GEC 85 easy open, but it might be just a touch small for your hands. The GEC 92 is one that has a little longer handle than some of the others. Mine is a two-blade with a spear main and a coping secondary, but I think there were some with a single spear blade. I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong. Another knife that is a bit bigger, although I don't think GEC has made a version yet, is the Grand Daddy Barlow. They tend to be single blade knives. I haven't seen a lot of them with a spear blade, but there are some out there. The English Jack is another larger knife that often has a spear main blade.
 
I am just starting to make the switch. This is literally my third day carrying my 72 Cody Scout after many years of modern only carry. I can't say why I decided to make the leap except that my tastes have changed a great deal since joining the forum.
In terms of patterns, I knew I wanted a single blade in a medium to large size, and I knew I wanted a lock. After that, I just checked out the exchange and dealers until I saw something I really liked.
This will be my carry for the foreseeable future.
e630072676629b13dba3bc11a391ee3b.jpg

I couldn't be happier with the move, though I still need to get over my concerns about rust on the 1095 and dropping the knife in my pocket with loose change. Gotta get past that new knife feeling!
Anyway, good luck with your search. I found a GEC I love for edc and I'm sure you will too.
 
Very decent Stag on that Cody jd! But, key, coins and knives in one pocket? Not I :eek:

Regards, Will
 
I like larger single blades as well. Don't forget the 71 Bullnose. It's the ultimate factory rendition of the sodbuster pattern. The micarta models have slimmer handles than the Delrin knives, and older runs were in O1 tool steel. Mine is a beefy, simple workhorse in OD linen micarta, and I have a black micarta in 1095 as well.

I keep dropping hints in threads that the market would gobble up a single blade series on the moose frame, but no public movement there yet!

I don't think the 15 frame fits the bill here - they're not a large knife by any means.

The 42 is a larger lockback - like a Buck 110 but slimmer. Another great option.
 
I am just starting to make the switch. This is literally my third day carrying my 72 Cody Scout after many years of modern only carry. I can't say why I decided to make the leap except that my tastes have changed a great deal since joining the forum.
In terms of patterns, I knew I wanted a single blade in a medium to large size, and I knew I wanted a lock. After that, I just checked out the exchange and dealers until I saw something I really liked.
This will be my carry for the foreseeable future.
e630072676629b13dba3bc11a391ee3b.jpg

I couldn't be happier with the move, though I still need to get over my concerns about rust on the 1095 and dropping the knife in my pocket with loose change. Gotta get past that new knife feeling!
Anyway, good luck with your search. I found a GEC I love for edc and I'm sure you will too.

I always carry my 73 Stag in one of the Slips that CK sells . Keeps it scratch free and reduces the amount of moisture that could bringing on VERDIGRIS . You really do not want that to get into your very nice Stag . It will also reduce the Rust risk that you are worried about.

Harry
 
Back
Top