Edge angle for skinner in M4?

...I do not strop...
Interesting. The factory making your razors does, THEY recommend what I have indicated above. YOU are just using the spine to edge measurement I mentioned in the post above your reply. It would be interesting to see the level of apex refinement you are actually achieving without the strop and also what it looks like after a couple of passes through facial hair. That spine to edge geometry is not what is actually recommended for use. If it works for you, :thumbsup:

Yes, I am well aware of trigonometric functions. :)
 
My point remains. 12 - 14 degrees inclusive. That is half of what you say straight razors are shipped at, and all 3 of mine were in that range, both now, and from the factory. I couldn't care less what is recommended for stropping, it works for me and I shave just fine with it. And have for the last 5 years. To assert that all cutting angles are ground at 15 dps is not true at all. There are many makers who come in both more and less than that. There is no magical angle that works for all cutting.
 
My point remains. 12 - 14 degrees inclusive. That is half of what you say straight razors are shipped at, and all 3 of mine were in that range, both now, and from the factory. I couldn't care less what is recommended for stropping, it works for me and I shave just fine with it. And have for the last 5 years. To assert that all cutting angles are ground at 15 dps is not true at all. There are many makers who come in both more and less than that. There is no magical angle that works for all cutting.
No, I did not type that razors "are shipped at" 15-dps, you are welcome to review, and no one here has asserted that all cutting angles are ground at 15 -dps, so i must assume that since your post is populated with made-up nonsense then nothing you type should be taken seriously. For the third time, what i posted:
Even a straight razor, after stropping the edge, ends up ~15-dps.
No where did I type anything about a "magical angle". It is great that you have been grinding your blades and shaving with them for 5 years :thumbsup: You also clearly have no idea what level of refinement you have achieved nor what the working angle is on your blades, how much burr you have, nor the level of damage induced after a swipe or two. And that's OK if it is working for you. You keep doing you. But please don't make stuff up about what I've typed, leave me out of your fantasies.

I posted SEM images taken by ToddS of straight razors ground and stropped, I posted Gillette's own patent info on the ideal apex angle of a razor, I could post more such information and even what the various manufacturers recommend for their blades, but I somehow don't think more information would be useful to you. Gillette's patent describes the last 40 microns of the edge, and ToddS' images reveal that last 2-3 microns, that is not something any of us can see without sophisticated magnifying equipment. You don't have to care about the reality so long as it works for you. 15-dps being recommended angle for everything from chainsaws to straight-razors (Murdock of London actually suggests more) doesn't mean that you CAN'T grind a blade thinner for your use. Heck, most utility razors seem to be ground thinner though some companies take the edge to soft "burr removal" process that alters the geometry slightly in the final part of the apex. *shrug*

But if you mean that 15-dps DOES NOT "work" for everything from chainsaws to straight razors, THAT is utter nonsense. Edges wider than 20-dps can whittle hair and they work quite suitably for chainsaws as well.

Here is a video showing DOVO's manufacturing process - if you skip to ~4:00, you'll observe the final honing prior to shipping. The worker, after grinding the edge at the spine-set angle, lifts the spine slightly to apply a larger honing angle and makes several passes, then dries the blade, and finally strops the edge. This edge is probably 12 - 20 dps (in the tiny microbevel supporting the apex) prior to shipping, and is keen enough to whittle hair. So perhaps companies DO ship their razors with such angles afterall ;)

 
The only "utter nonsense" that I see here is what you are posting. Clearly, you really don't understand what you are talking about. I have done years of testing on knives, razors, and cutting efficiency. All cutting edges do not gravitate to 15 dps. To say that they do is utter nonsense on your part. What I'm seeing are phrases from you such as "seems to be" and "is probably"....

"But if you mean that 15-dps DOES NOT "work" for everything from chainsaws to straight razors, THAT is utter nonsense." Well there you go putting words in my mouth. Try reading comprehension for a change.

Welcome to my ignore list.
 
The only "utter nonsense" that I see here is what you are posting. Clearly, you really don't understand what you are talking about. I have done years of testing on knives, razors, and cutting efficiency. All cutting edges do not gravitate to 15 dps. To say that they do is utter nonsense on your part. What I'm seeing are phrases from you such as "seems to be" and "is probably"....

"But if you mean that 15-dps DOES NOT "work" for everything from chainsaws to straight razors, THAT is utter nonsense." Well there you go putting words in my mouth. Try reading comprehension for a change.

Welcome to my ignore list.
Well, since I never posted that "all cutting edges... gravitate to 15 dps", that counts once more as something you have made up out of thin air. :rolleyes: You are having a really hard time with this, aren't you? That makes how many made-up assertions that you claim were mine? And then you think that I am failing to comprehend? SEM images are not "seem" and "probably", nor are the manufacturer recommendations, nor is the video showing that the manufacturer is honing and stropping the final apex of their product to an angle much larger than you are pretending.
You IMAGINE the edge angle of you blades without any evidence but claim you have "years of testing"... uh huh. Yeah, "ignore" is probably the best place for someone calling you out on such BS.

For everyone else, you can see the images, you can watch the video, and you can read the posts :thumbsup: It is fascinating that 15-dps ends up being the angle used from everything from chainsaws to straight razors, but that is the reality. *shrug* But that is just the apex angle. As I mentioned before, FAR more important is the thickness of the steel BEHIND that edge, the material that is supporting it. On a razor blade, that thickness may be only a few microns, on a chainsaw it may be a millimeter - 1000X thicker. The keeness of the apex does the cutting, the thickness behind that apex provides the support to wedge the cut material apart and keep the apex from bending aside. A razor doesn't require much support, hence the thin edge. And back to the OP, a skinner usually doesn't require much support either - maybe more than a razor, but less than a chainsaw splitting off chips of wood.
 
Back
Top