Hello,
Doing the exact same thing currently...
re; practical short term emergency food supply.
We wanted replaced a bunch of Y2K vintage stores of dehydrated stuff, and MRE's. I spent way too much on it then, and would not do either again for the price compared to what you get. After eating a bunch of both, I think there are way better choices...the only thing they have going for them is lighter weight.
I also am planning for 2, and last month we tried one of pretty much everything available at local stores, to replace the dehydrated stuff and MRE's. We spent about $100 on samples of anything that looked practical, and was available locally. Not going to list everything we tried, lol...just the highs and lows.
Our only critera was...
no cooking/no water for prep required/no tools required.
The bad first...waste of $$ for us.
We found all canned fish/sea food pretty disgusting...even the good tuna.
All canned beef found was from Brazil...we decided to pass on that.
Tried many canned soups and beans...ok, but not great...would have been better heated no doubt, but we tried everything cold, and most of these required a can opener.
The good...
Spam has gotten a whole lot better over the years...
Spam...was very surprised...very much improved from years past. Regular spam now comes in small "half can's" that are a very practical size. We tried all the available flavors, but liked the regular best of these.
Turkey Spam...both my girl and myself like this better than regular, but could not find it in the more practical half can size.
Cliff bars...tried every food bar we could find...Cliff bars were better packaged and better taste by far than any other tried.
Of the cliff bars, we liked Choc Chip the best.
Canned nut's.
Of about 50 products tried, these were the clear winners, (for us).
We will no doubt keep an eye out for other stuff to try, but for us;
Full size cans of Turkey Spam
Half can size of regular Spam
Cliff bars
Gatorade drink powder
One a Day multi vitamins
Canned nut's
...are now our emergency stapels, and I think way better than what we had before. (way cheaper too).
We tried this combo on a 7 day river camping trip, and found the Cliff bars/ Spam (regular-small cans), and good quality canned nut's go well together, were not too heavy to pack, and no upset stomach/loss of energy, (unlike MRE's). We did not feel deprived or unhappy because of food issues, and had plenty of energy...no ill effects at all.
On water filters..the Katadyn Pocket filter model is worth the extra $$. When you consider the cost of spare replacement elements for the lesser filters, it comes out about the same, and the Pocket filter is a much better built unit, with thousands of gallons more filtering life in a single unit. For us, we found it made more $$ sense to just buy another complete unit than just a spare filter element, but the Pocket Filter model was way cheaper when we got ours than they are now...well worth it though, a no regret item.
Best of luck,
Chris.
............................
Partial list of good trades I've had here since 1999...Thanks!
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=124818