I asume you are using high speed steel, probally 1/8 or 1/4". Invest in a few 4-flute square end CARBIDE endmills. Find a local dealer, you can usually get 1/4" standard length carbide endmills for under $10. If you're cutting with a 1/4" endmill, try taking off no more than .025" at a time. If all else fails, rotate your work 90 degrees and try again, this will tell you if it is your mill.