Faulty new BK7 - Mr. Becker can you please help us with RMA?

Soft steel. Simple as that. No adequately hardened steel would bend and distort in that way, it would chip out a large chunk and probably cause hairline cracks up the blade.

To argue misuse is pointless, that knife is faulty, despite what the owner did with it! If the manufacturer does not reimburse fully, I would be pretty damn pissed off.



(Too many fan boys bumming Beckers to accept they aren't as tough as they are said to be. Usually through their overly skeletonised handles snapping off or coin sized chipped breaking out the edge)
 
It really looks like a bullet impact on the last photo, but it would be pure insanity for the owner to shoot at it. The price here is something like 400-500 USD for you I am guessing. The real price from the bill is 119 USD but for us here it is really expensive knife, the standart paycheck here is 500 USD max per month. Would you shoot 500 USD knife for the entertaiment? Also I am sport pistol shooter and I am shooting steel plates and other stuff very often. Hardened blade will chip after hard fast bullet impact. Not bend like this.
 
Samon, you will keep it about the knife in question, please.
 
Like I've said on other threads any manufacturer that mass produces knives will have there share of defects make it into the hands of consumers. It's what the company does to make it right is the way I judge a company. Out of the thousands of different Beckers out there you only occasionally hear of one breaking, and it's normally replaced.

I've gotten defects from buck, Gerber, tops, schrade, and a few other companies in my 18 years of buying, selling and trading knives. And for the most part the problems were resolved. It can happen to the best of em.
 
Last edited:
Bastille definitely looks soft and I'm sure there's an issue with the knife, & I highly doubt anyone would shoot it, that's just what it looks like to me.

And as to ththe fan boy remark, beckers are everybody as strong and as capable as advertised, that don't mean there's not a bad batch every now and then, every company has them, the true mark is the fact that the company is willing to help when a bad batch does arrive. If they weren't as good as they are there wouldn't be so many people who you call becker fan. Oys
 
The knife in question may have slipped through QC cracks. If that's the case, I have every confidence that Ka-Bar will take care of the owner.

knife chop, I've seen you post your photo collection elsewhere for dramatic effect without any context about each set of conditions or the user choices involved.
You seem eager to chime in on Becker breakages. This subforum will not be the best audience for intended effect, however.
 
Samon, you will keep it about the knife in question, please.

Thought I already was, mate. Said knife is faulty, like many others by the same brand.

But stating so is not in keeping with the thread and forum rules? Me pointing out to the BK fans that this is not abuse but a simple case of bad knife isn't allowed?
 
Seriously? Please do not insult my intelligence, mate.

Display a significant degree of intelligence and maybe I won't..? :thumbup:

Clearly you are a fan of the BK line. And ok, I get it, choice of words on this side of the planet often stings the soft and doughy skin of colonials but when people are saying the blade has been shot? abused and what not is just denial. This is a REPEATED case of faulty knife.
 
Soft steel. Simple as that. No adequately hardened steel would bend and distort in that way, it would chip out a large chunk and probably cause hairline cracks up the blade.

To argue misuse is pointless, that knife is faulty, despite what the owner did with it! If the manufacturer does not reimburse fully, I would be pretty damn pissed off.



(Too many fan boys bumming Beckers to accept they aren't as tough as they are said to be. Usually through their overly skeletonised handles snapping off or coin sized chipped breaking out the edge)
You should probably tell my bk2 this, it didn't seem to get the memo it was suppose to be delicate and faulty.

I've put my bk2 and my bk7 when I had it still through extreme hard use, harder use than I'd ever consider doing with most of my other knives. Guess what not only did they not break, but they got the job done quickly and with lil effort. I wouldn't describe a Beckerhead as a fanboy but more of an enthusiast, fanboys tend to be dedicated to one particular brand. While from what I've gathered from these forums that as much as they love there Beckers they still buy and use other knives from various manufacturers.

I love my Becker and want to add several more to the lineup, but I still own a variety of other manufacturers and have many non Beckers on my to buy list.
 
Just a friendly warning to the wise follows below. Samon, you have just been formally warned.

The mods are not here to lock a thread down because of a legitimate quality concern.
But if you feel compelled by name calling or a desire to besmirch the brand, you are better off taking your comments elsewhere.
The Becker subforum isn't your best bet.

My first look at the OP's post was on my phone, and my initial reaction was user error. On a second look on the computer, I'm not as sure.
The only blade that has wavered like that for me was a machete edge that I'd thinned too much.
Like I said, if it got through the QC cracks, the concern will be properly addressed by Ka-Bar.
 
Shots fired!!!
IBTL!

and just to clarify, I didn't say he did shoot it, just looks kinda like he did. Merely an observation
 
All manufactures have a bad one slip out every once in a while. The true measure is how they take care of the customer after the sale. I haven't had to deal with Kabar's customer service yet and I hope I don't find the need. From what I've read they seem to do a pretty good job. Hopefully if it's a defect and they take care of your friend. I've had some companies in the past that have went way beyond what I expected and in return I've done more business with them because of it. Please let us know the outcome.
 
Last edited:
Display a significant degree of intelligence and maybe I won't..? :thumbup:

Clearly you are a fan of the BK line. And ok, I get it, choice of words on this side of the planet often stings the soft and doughy skin of colonials but when people are saying the blade has been shot? abused and what not is just denial. This is a REPEATED case of faulty knife.

Guyon is not just a fan, he's a mod of this forum. As am I. Please take note.

The user has an issue. It's Sunday evening in the States. Business are closed. KaBar is closed. Ethan Becker is on walk-about. Lots of people have opinions. Very few have facts. Addiing a knee-jerk naming-calling insulting spin is not tolerated.

Let's be SUPER clear. We have a rule over-all on Bladeforums: when the mods ask you to play nice, they aren't actually asking, and if you sass them back, you can be infracted, in a serious fashion. Please, hoose your words more carefully and with intelligence. Please review the rules if you are not clear on this official policy.

My opinions later :D
 
He tried to chop some small thin branches from a dead tree. It was a soft wood (spruce) and inside the branches it wasn't anything metallic - nail or something like that, he checked it multiple times. Not even a knag.

knag? knot?

because my standard saying is "fir trees are soft woods *as a rule*, dried ones are not, fir tree knots are typically silicated (rocks)"...

usually when a harder steel hits a silicated knot, or a proper round bit of steel (rebar), we see some cool fractal like shockwaves - chonchoidal fractures like in flint

knife chop there, who likes to post on "other forums", and is known to have an extensive collection of shattered blades has a few pictures of this phenomenon. it's kinda cool, but to me, indicates: the steel might have been a weeeeee hard. the object hit was VERY VERY VERY HARD (rock, knots, etc). a frozen Christmas tree is the worst thing ever. you can throw sparks from those things, esp when dry. when moist and fresh? good time.

IMHO, this knife looks like a classic issue of "a bit soft".

if it were ME, i'd photograph and document, and tell the maker. who, honestly, should be given 2-3 business days to ponder. not a reaming on a Sunday evening their time. they're closed. they'll open Monday, and i'm pretty sure, they will see this VERY quickly.

now, if i were them, i'll want to see this blade, so, ideally, don't do anything to the blade, or attempt to fix it; it should get shipped to them. probably without handles, flat, packed bullet proof, and zoom. this seems like a good warranty issue.

otherwise, i've had knives do this. in the apocalypse, i'd use a hammer and some good surface, like an anvil, and i'd gently work that out, and then i would sharpen the too soft edge out, and see what happens. it would take a few go around to determine goodness.

i'll try to call Mr Becker *right now*, just so he is aware, plus please note that KaBar handles the warranties as rule, but he will be involved.

can't ask for much more than that 10PM on a Sunday East Coast USA Stateside
 
Guyon is not just a fan, he's a mod of this forum. As am I. Please take note.

The user has an issue. It's Sunday evening in the States. Business are closed. KaBar is closed. Ethan Becker is on walk-about. Lots of people have opinions. Very few have facts. Addiing a knee-jerk naming-calling insulting spin is not tolerated.

Let's be SUPER clear. We have a rule over-all on Bladeforums: when the mods ask you to play nice, they aren't actually asking, and if you sass them back, you can be infracted, in a serious fashion. Please, hoose your words more carefully and with intelligence. Please review the rules if you are not clear on this official policy.

My opinions later :D

Oh hell. When Bladite capitalizes words, he means business. It's like your mother or your father using your middle name.
 
Back
Top