Fight of the Steels: S30V or 3V for a Bushcraft knife.

[cybrok]

Hi all.

I was wondering wich steel would be the best for a 4.5" bladed bushcraft knife.

I know Dan Koster uses both (see knives for sale now).

What do you think would be the major differences from a user point of view?

Thanks
Marco

 

[Gerberblades]

3v, better edge retention and strength.

 

[BarberFobic1992]

+1 to the3v

 

[mapper66]

Marco, here is a link to a sticky at Dan's subforum, this is his take on it:

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=500049

Personally, I love Dan's 3V; strong as heck, easy to sharpen (at least in a scandi grind), and I've not had any problems with edge rolling or chips. Seems to be pretty rust resistant as well, at least I haven't noticed any yet. One of my favorite steels.

 

[sodak]

3V, no comparison. When properly heat treated, it is far superior in edge retention and toughness, from the tests that I've done. I also live in a dry climate where rust is a non-issue.

 

[cybrok]

Marco, here is a link to a sticky at Dan's subforum, this is his take on it:

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=500049

Yeah I saw it. But I wanted more details.

Thanks for your help guys.

 

[Big Mike]

Yeah I saw it. But I wanted more details.

Thanks for your help guys.

3V
Very tough steel - a true super-steel. At hardened thicknesses over 3/16" it is nearly indestrucible (in knife sizes). Great edge-holding too. Trade-off? Expensive!


S30V
Excellent stainless steel. Med-sized carbides. High carbon. Moderate-high in price. Difficult for some to sharpen - need diamond hones.
Best performing stainless for edge-holding.

"Best performing stainless for edge-holding", for me, that says it all. :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:

 

[cybrok]

I ask because I'm working with Justin Gingrich to get a custom bushcraft knife
Something like this (knapperbill's custom Ranger):

I only have to deicide on the steel :s

 

[Elen]

3V any day. Much tougher, and holds a better edge. Unless you're planning to dive, stainless or no isn't a big deal, and if you are diving, then S30V isn't going to cut it, in my humble opinion.

 

[Fiddleback]

"Best performing stainless for edge-holding", for me, that says it all. :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:

All that says to me is that it doesn't hold an edge as well as carbons.:yawn:

 

[gazaati]

S30V

I am sorry but I cant stand it. I had 2 (folders) chip in that steel. I cant imagain it in a bushcraft knife. VG 10 is another story

Thats just me.

 

[Eager]

I've had S30V blades chip significantly as well, and would not use it as a first choice for a fixed blade Bushcaft blade.

 

[cybrok]

I think the answer is pretty clear

I promise to show pics once I have the knife

 

[The Moose]

Well if your gonna take good care of it, 1095 would be great.