"Fighting Knives" an eBay pet peeve

My collection is focused on USN Deck knives. They are literally meant for working on a boat. Yet I see them listed as combat knives.

I’m glad my collection is complete, I just don’t see quality or the realistic prices anymore.
Things can get pretty heated onboard when there's only one jelly doughnut left in the galley...

It's the same as EDC or any other way they categorize knives. Results may vary and it's just market speak to get the attention of their intended audience as fast as possible, so they can harvest their cash before someone else does.

Technically the Bark River Bravo 1 is a combat knife, because it was designed as a military field knife in consultation with US soldiers. Is it a tactical knife or a bushcraft knife or a fixed blade combat knife with a bushy flavour?
 
Things can get pretty heated onboard when there's only one jelly doughnut left in the galley...

It's the same as EDC or any other way they categorize knives. Results may vary and it's just market speak to get the attention of their intended audience as fast as possible, so they can harvest their cash before someone else does.

Technically the Bark River Bravo 1 is a combat knife, because it was designed as a military field knife in consultation with US soldiers. Is it a tactical knife or a bushcraft knife or a fixed blade combat knife with a bushy flavour?
You sound like another old squid. MM3 here. I would like to see a complete collection.
 
Very much infantry, but I've been shipped as cargo on a navy supply ship and had a lot of serving and retired navy friends over the years, from living in the vicinity of a navy base.
My brother was infantry, (a Captain during Desert Storm) but I liked to sleep inside and eat well. Besides, when it was my turn I had a choice of Army and Viet Nam or Navy and the Caribbean, and coming from a long line of cowardly survivors, I took the Navy.
 
You sound like another old squid. MM3 here. I would like to see a complete collection.
BM2 here. Most of Deck Depth used a Buck 110. I bought a Gerber Folding Hunter to be different. We didn't get too many doughnuts, but coffee was a 24/7 necessity. Never clean the chief's mug.
 
This got me thinking (never a good thing, I don't recommend it) about my grandfather's M1 carbine I inherited at age 17.

Grandpa never talked about the war, until he was dying, and he only told me. I remember finding the carbine in his basement, wrapped plastic and a cardboard box. Not a speck of rust. I brought it upstairs and showed him what I found. He told me about always having to use his knife to disassemble it, tools were at a premium. The wear on that screw shows.

He fought with the 63rd infantry division at the Siegfried line.

Someday I'll buy a bayonet for this.
20220713_183200.jpg
 
I think any knife is a fighting knife if it came to that as the utmost last resort.

It's just keywords, making sure to cover any term someone might use to find a knife.

Just like tactical soap. I'm serious..theres a tactical soap.
 
To every blade seller on eBay, any knife that may have been of the period of WWII, is a "fighting knife." As a student of history, that really gripes my soul. If a WWII soldier had to result to fighting with a knife, that meant that his primary weapon had become useless or lost, his squad, company and battalion had failed in their mission and the poor trooper was probably about to earn the purple heart or the order of the white cross.

Anyone living in a tent, or in a sleeping bag or foxhole needed a knife. There were toenails to clip, tent pegs to make, cans to open, firewood to prepare, ropes to cut, and any one of a thousand mundane tasks that knives are invaluable to comfort and survival. Regardless of the hype, that is the jobs these knives excelled at. Now, I know, before the push-back starts, that you can find stories of Marines on some God-forsaken Pacific atoll, saving his life with his Ka-Bar, but that is the exception to the rule. Perhaps someone in a Marine Raider Battalion would depend on a knife to silence an unwary guard, but again, the exception, not the rule. A more honest description of the knives would be "fixed-blade camp knives," but that wouldn't sell to war gamers.

I am a big fan of the blades of WWII and I don't need to think that "this blade cut a Nazi throat" Ok, my rant is over, I just needed to get it off my chest.....;)
Love your knife display, simple, easy access and shows everything off well
 
C Cattaraugus225 Welcome to blade forums ! Members tend to developing a thickening to the skin in time.

eBay, flea bay, fee bay .. whatever you want to call it - I don’t think the majority of sellers are concerned with accuracy or period correct terminology within item description.

You’ll find plenty of amazing resources here though.

PLEASE POST SOME PICS !! That collection of yours looks great.

Have fun.
 
I'd bet all my knives that the common kitchen knife has seen more fighting than any other knife made.
Kitchen knives are terrifying! I haven’t really been much of a knife enthusiast these last 25yrs, but I’ve always maintained our Wusthof kitchen knives religiously.
 
Kitchen knives don't bother me as much as chainsaws...
 
Back
Top