Finally..My Meadowlark Review

Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
165
Hey guys some of you might have known that i have been having a dilemma on which knife to choose, the flight, cara cara, or meadowlark. And for those of you
who were constantly answering my threads, i give you my deepest regards in assisting me in this..you can finally say "ahhh finally, no more asking us about our opinions between so and so and that knife".. i know its been an annoying long ride.

___________________________________________________________________
Today i was at lebaron's in canada and i picked up a meadowlark G10 plain edge for 25 dollars, and no taxes since it was their boxing day sale.

My first impressions of the knife was one word, "Wow". First things first, i dont know if im correct or not, correct me if im wrong, but i believe byrd has moved onto a new packaging rather than the old rectangular paper box.


Now onto the knife itself, this was actually my first spyderco and my first time
with a G10 handle, and at first im going to be honest, i was not amazed.
My first time with it, it just felt like checkered plastic, but when i rubbed my thumb against it even more, it felt more like what i heard it was suppose to be , grippy :)

Many of you might ahve known, before i was claiming that the blade of the knife is too small for many tasks, however i have come to conclusions that spyderco knives are one of those knives you gotta feel in the hand rather than look at a picture and say you want that knife.


The ergonomics are awesome, the finger choils seat perfectly for the perfect task, for example, i can have my index finger at the lower choil when im doing rough cutting, but i can have a pinch grip with the choil on the blade and the thumb rest when im doing delicate cutting.

IMHO, i think the midspine lockback is very easy to close knowing that the gives me a solid lockup. There is no blade play whatsoever, and to some extent i could only find two sharp points on the knife.
Im not gonna say the blade cause its designed for that, i feel that the little notch on the blade choil is kinda sharp, i actually cut my self when i was "drop releasing" the blade and when it went off my index finger. The second sharp point was on the boye dent, but it wasnt that bad, it just kinda annoying.

With factory sharpening, out of the box, it cuts 8 x 11 copy paper easily with little effort.
__________________________________________________________________
I could see myself using and edcing this knife for a very long time, and please dont flame for this, but i do i see the resemblance of the meadowlark to the delica. Matter of fact, IMHO, it seems like the meadowlark is like the twin brother of the delica, however the meadowlark just doesnt have as nice materials and construction might have not been as A class as the delica.

It seems like by covering the some of the comet hole of the meadowlark, the knife appears to be a delica.




All and all, i really enjoy this knife. Thanks Bladeforums community for helping me with my decision of this knife. :thumbup:
 
Congrats on your 'lark. Byrds get downplayed by some Spydie purists, and so be it, but my family has 3 of 'em and they are VERY good knives. The steel is nice and the 61 Rc gives it that little something extra. Also the F&F is far beyond most knives in the $20 range. Feel free to drop the angle when sharpening, as the steel can handle it just fine, and it strops well also.
 
I'm glad that you like the knife because I have the exact same model coming in the mail to me! I can't wait!
 
are the liners skeletonized? sal said a while ago that they were gonna skeletonize the liners on the byrd G-10 models but i wasn't sure if they started doing them yet.

i've been holding off on the byrd G-10's waiting for the skeletonized liners as the only "complaint" about the G-10 byrds was their weight.
 
Im going to be honest with you, the only G10 byrd you should be concerned about weight is the cara cara as it is already a big beast.

The G10 Meadowlark is very good for its weight, you wont get that feeling that makes you feel like this knife is a hunk of metal and G10, you get the kind of sturdynest and a well built kind of feeling with its weight.

The G10 Meadowlark's liners are not skeletonized, at least not on mine.
 
Thanks for sharing the review and pics, YourNoob. I have a half dozen or so Byrds and I am pleased with them all.
 
No problem man, im just trying to "recruit" more people into the Byrd scene as they are a great entry step into Spyderco for those who cant afford it (like me :D ).
I usually like to think Spyderco knives are like the Lexus of knives, high quality, nice appearance, more pricier, and a true investment. While i like to picture byrds as the Toyotas, they are appealing to most, very affordable, great bang for the buck, and growing into high end entry knife range.
 
Thanks for the response. do you by chance have a delica 4??? how does the weight compare to that (especially in the pocket)? or any other popular knife? yeah i looked up the numbers, but numbers alone don't reveal the whole story. on paper, the meadowlark G-10 is almost twice the weight of the delica...
 
Thanks for the response. do you by chance have a delica 4??? how does the weight compare to that (especially in the pocket)? or any other popular knife? yeah i looked up the numbers, but numbers alone don't reveal the whole story. on paper, the meadowlark G-10 is almost twice the weight of the delica...

No dice man, i wish i had the delica 4 :D I cannot comment on the weight, but i can picture the meadowlark being more heavier as the D4 is based on FRN handles. Me? Im not really a numbers guy when buying knives, if it fits my needs in terms of the blade length, if the handle feels good in the hand, and it is comfortable to your needs, get it.

Because before i was pretty skeptical about G10, prior to my purchase, the weight was the main problem i faced, but than i again i have large hands and it may infact aid me.

So you know, dont be concerned about the weight, the size, even the handle materials, for example SS is known for being slippery with moisture, but if u got moderate sized hands with a good grip, you'll be fine, while a smaller hand may not work well.

As i said before, Spydies/Byrdies are the kind of knives that you need to have in your hand in order to make a judgement, you gotta test drive those beasts :)
 
Back
Top