I use Tru Oil on walnut. Here's what works for me. Birchwood Casey, the makers of Tru Oil also make Sealer and Filler. This is available wherever you got your Tru Oil. After final sanding of your handle use a foam brush to apply the Sealer and Filler. This will fill in the grain. After its dry buff with steel wool, (0000) to even out any drips etc. Sometimes it will take 2 coats to get the walnut completely filled. Once you have it filled and buffed with the steel wool apply the Tru Oil. I apply with a small piece of 4,000 grit polishing paper. I apply with the grain and continue to use the polishing paper moving to a fresh piece as the finish begins to dry. You will get the finish almost dry and very smooth (you will see it change appearance as you polish). Once you have it this way all over the handle let it dry. It will be dry in a couple of hours. Put another coat of Tru Oil on the same way. Let the second coat cure for a day or two. Then buff off a couple of coats of carnuba car wax and you are good to go. Good hard finish, lots of dept, not plastic looking and pretty simple. I also use the Sealer and Filler on some other woods even, if I don't use Tru Oil on them like Mesquite and some Rosewoods.