First knife for my son, which one?

shootist16

knife law moderator
Moderator
Joined
Dec 25, 1998
Messages
7,394
My son, age 9, wants a knife. He like swiss army knives, but I am not so sure about that. He has trouble opening the tools and the blade doesn't lock. I know you can get models that lock, but I think I may get him a Buck lockback.

WHich would you recommend? A 55? One of the 500 series? Something else?
 
...Wow...Thinking back to the "olden days"...I seem to remember that my very first knife was one of those "official" Boy Scout Knives issued by the local scoutmaster. It was HORRIBLE!!...The darn thing closed on my fingers much more than I care to think about today. The scales were some kind of cheap plastic that I think fell apart a few weeks after I got it. No way would I challenge a young boy with the use of one of those monsters...Now if the "55" had been available back then , it's the one I would have wished for. It may not have the screw-driver thing or the useless can-opener that the Boy Scout Knife had, but as I never had any use for those bulky attachments I don't believe any young boy would miss them. Besides...pop-tops and aluminized packaging makes them useless attachments anyway. Yep...in my humble opinion the "55" would be the way I'd go for my son. It's small enough to be very comfortable in a small hand, it's slim enough to be carried easily in a pocket of a pair of jeans, it's strong enough to take the dropping and knocking around that young fellas seem to do from time to time...and best of all ...It's a Buck...It's a great lead-in to all the other great Bucks as he matures too...Wish my dad had given me a "55" back then...
 
she would have lost it within a real short time and I would have been hard pressed not to be upset with her. I recommend a 425 MiniBuck Bucklite. It is a great little knive, cheap, rugged, a perfect size, smooth opening, and if he should loose it you can get another one and I think you will still be to the good against the cost of a 55.
 
The 55 is probably an acceptable choice. I would also suggest he use a pocket pouch to protect the brass and to make it a bit more noticeable in his pocket. The small 55 can easily slip out of the pocket without one's knowledge. The only reservation I have is in regards to the clip point blade. Boys are prone to use the knife point for digging at stuff and a clip point is more likely to break off. For that reason, a 501 or 503 (drop point blade) may be a better choice. I would still recommend the pocket pouch.
 
I was just thinking about giving my grandson my 450. They just moved to a new place with a couple acres, kind of in the wods. Figured the rubber grips might serve him better. He is 12
 
Larry Oden said:
The only reservation I have is in regards to the clip point blade. Boys are prone to use the knife point for digging at stuff and a clip point is more likely to break off. For that reason, a 501 or 503 (drop point blade) may be a better choice.

...Oh man...So now I'm remembering my "youth" a bit more clearly...yer absolutely right Larry...(The memory is the second thing to go with age ya know...LOL)
 
Me being 15, I feel i can have a pretty good input.


I know I'd want a locking Victorinox. The extra tools are a kids best friend.

My recommendation, the one-handed trailmaster.
 
I'm guessing that the boy this knife will belong to is "one of us" in that he loves the great outdoors and will spend a good deal of his time there. A well taught 9 year old is man enough to carry any pocket knife his (or his fathers) pocket will run to. If the lad is aware of those things he must not do with a knife then a clip point should be no problem. This being the case I would opt for either a 55 or a 112. If you think that the clip point will prove too vulnerable to breakage then why not a 501 as suggested by others here.
Personally I would steer clear of the Bucklite, or indeed any knife with a plastic handle. This is not because I don't think these knives are as good a quality as any other Buck, simply that there is something intrinsically pleasing to the touch about a solidly constructed knife of brass, wood and steel. A good solid knife like this FEELS better in the hand, and has a sense of lasting quality about it that will more likely inspire the lad to take care of the knife than a plastic handled version of the same thing might do. In an age of plastic this and plastic that, you simply can't beat the feeling of wood and brass in your hand when you compare it to so many plastic items that just seem to made to break.
Assuming that the knife will be carried out in the woods etc and not to school and the like, why not avoid pocket problems by making sure he has a belt pouch for the knife? This will encourage him to reach in one place and one place only when he wants the knife instead of searching through his pockets to find where he put it. It also makes a convenient, yet secure way to carry the knife.
 
I'd go with the 55 also. I agree that the Bucklite is an excellent knife as well as not a heartbreaker if you lose it. However, Longstrider's comments about the feel of the knife in your hand hit home with me. Undoubtedly, even if your son loses the knife, he will never forget the experience of having it. My wife threw in the fact that "you" won't forget the cost of this experience either!
 
I think I'm going to go out on a limb and disagree with you all. When I was that age my father gave me a Buck sheath knife for camping and fishing. I believe it was a 102 but I could be mistaken. (it's been a long time!!) It was a wonderful knife that served me very well. Whenever we went into the woods I would put it on my belt. The great thing about a sheath knife is that a young boy is not likely to go out and play with it on his belt. A folding knife on the other hand can easily be slipped into the pocket and taken out to show off to the "gang". I'm speaking from my own personal experiance here. I'd buy him one of the several basic fixed blade hunting knives that Buck has to offer. When he gets a little older, I'd reward him with a folding knife that matched his intrerests. We all know that there are many greats to choose from.
Mike
 
It may not be appropriate for a 9 year old to have a pocket knife on him all the time, what with sheeple and all, and if you make it easy for him to carry it he will. I would. Maybe a fixed blade is a better choice because it can only be warn at times when it would be appropriate. He might forget he had a folder in his pocket and, oh horror!, talk it to school. Next thing you know Michael Moore is there with a camera and you are on the 6 o’clock news.
 
The 9 year old will be 20 before you know it. A first knife could be a lifetime keepsake if he doesn't loose it. Why not let him pick it out.
 
If you want to go down the Buck route, a Knight or Prince, maybe at the biggest a Ranger. Nothing fancy, just a good old lockback.
 
Great advice guys. The lock/no lock angle is an interesting one. He really wants a SAK (I suspect because of the gadgets). Being a knifenut myself I will probably get him the SK he wants and a small Buck lockback.
 
would be a good choice for a young man. The grip is a little small for my ham hock but should fit him well. I really like the mini mentor, sort of Buck's answer to the Sharpfinger but it is out of production.

My dad has carried a SAK Soldier, the one with the aluminum scales, for a least 20 years and it is obviously a really good knife.
 
I'm with the guys who like the 102 Woodsman for a first timer. And, I'll tell you the first three things any kid will do with his first knife:

No. 1 He'll want to sharpen it (kind of)
No. 2 He'll cut himself
and
No. 3 He'll lose it!

At least that's how my son's experience was. The good news is he lost his first knife where I was able to find it, kept it in the gun cabinet for awhile and then gave it back to him.

Good luck and you've got a lucky kid! Jack ;)
 
If you are going with an SAK, I recommend the Victorinox Soldier model, as mentioned above. the Alox aluminum alloy handles will take a beating and it is generally agreed among most SAK collectors that Victorinox is the better of the two brands, as well as a consensus that the Soldier model is slightly better made than the run of the mill Victorinox knives (due to the stringent Swiss military standards imposed on them; the civilian Soldiers come off the same line as the issue Swiss military knives). I have a couple myself, and I can verify that the overall look and "feel" of the Soldier model is better than my other SAK's.
 
Back
Top