Fist GEC, impressions.

Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Messages
17,618
So, like I said in another post, in the course of a great meet and eat, Dan, (Silenthunterstudios) gifted me the first GEC knife I have ever owned. I have to admit I never saw the why in it, I always was a Case man for that kind of knife. Case peanut, Case sodbuster, whatever. I didn't see the why of paying GEC prices for what they offered, and a lot of their blocky style didn't bake my cookie.

But...

After using the #15 for a couple of weeks now, I have to say I was wrong. My impressions of GEC from this particular specimen is very high up there. The looks speak of old time ago. Classic styling, simple but elegant lines, and great fit and finish of the ebony scales and bolsters. Spring tension is not the dreaded GEC bear trap of what I felt at a knife show some years ago. Even for this old fart with some arthritis issues, I can open the knife easy. The half stop is familiar from my long association with Peanuts, and the old TL-29's from my army days.

The ebony looked a little dull, so I took a soft rag and some lemon oil and gave it a good hour long buffing, and now the scales have a deep smooth sheen to them. Kind of deep chocolate tone. The 1095 blade took a keen edge off the stone very much like the Opinel. GEC did a fine job of taking the grind down to the edge, with almost a flat grind, just the tiniest of bevels where the edge is. No problem getting scary sharp. A little gun oil in the joint and it's smooth as silk to pull open.

With my Sardinian Resolza and Opinel being stainless, I got a little sloppy with care. Karen and I were out in the woods, and I cut a sub sandwich in half and used the 15 to spread some more mustard out of a little plastic package, then laid the knife aside while we ate. Lo and behold, mustard stains on the carbon blade. In the old days I would have wiped off the blade immediately, but I've got sloppy after carrying a stainless knife for a while. On the other hand, it's gonna patina anyways, so I let it be.

My impression so far is of a very well made and executed knife in design and workmanship. My old loyalty to Case may be tested by this. But I know that I am too much a blade floozie to be one knife man like my dad, but I now find myself carrying the #15 in one pocket, and the Resolza in another. My inability to choose has resulted in my being a two knife man all the time. I guess I shouldn't worry about it, as I told Karen it's just male pocket jewelry.

In short, I like it!!

Carl, Grand High Muckba Of the Cult Of Little Slicers.

The 15 with my emergency sharpener kept in my wallet.
9099349501_b41307c385_c.jpg


9099543239_5d31a3f2bb_c.jpg
 
Last edited:
Looking good, Carl! I love my 15. I just realized that I don't have a single knife with a ebony scales. After looking at yours, I think that needs to change.

-Dan
 
Very much like your #15, my close cousin TC Barlow has won me over big time. The main reasons are the sophistication of the blade material, and its geometry, as you have discovered, Carl.

Thanks for sharing your experience with us Mr. Muckba!!
 
That's great, Carl! I though Bastid had put an 85 forum knife into your hands?

I must be getting myself confused.

Kevin
 
That's great, Carl! I though Bastid had put an 85 forum knife into your hands?

I must be getting myself confused.

Kevin

I think Carl subsequently gifted it to one of our younger members a few months back if I'm not mistaken.

The #15 is a lovely knife, great classic lines :)
 
Carl--
Do you think you'd like the pattern as much in the 2 blade configuration?

No, I don't think So. In spite of my life long love of multi blade knives, Ithink adding a second blade to the 15 would push it over what I like for edc in weight and thickness. I think the 15 as it is with one blade, is at the upper edge of what I like to carry. The small Resolza and the Opinel number 7 are my personal benchmarks of light weight efficiency of cutting tools. Much heavier, and I start to wonder why I'm carrying it. Like my old friend Frankie, he's a very long time lover of the Gerber LST. Loves the ugly thing. But won't carry anything more because it does what he wants and is totally un noticed in the pocket. I know what he means. If I can feel it bum,ping aorund while wearing loose fitting Dockers, then it's too heavy.

Carl.
 
I too really like the gec 15. It's just big enough to get all the tasks done but also small and comfortable to carry. I am actually carrying the same knife in my pocket today and really enjoy the knife. I find I carry it and my Scagel fruitport the most these days.

I've never had a chance to handle a case and will one day remedy this, but I want to check them out in person :)
 
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Carl. What's the breakfast club think of it?

- Christian
 
Thanks Jack! Someone got lucky there!

So this would be the first GEC that gained EDC status??? :)

Kevin

I think Carl subsequently gifted it to one of our younger members a few months back if I'm not mistaken.

The #15 is a lovely knife, great classic lines :)
 
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Carl. What's the breakfast club think of it?

- Christian

Well, what's left of the Moran Breakfast club thought it was a very nice knife. Unfortunately, this past winter was not good one. We had three of our number pass away. Hoppy, Jimmy, and Tom are gone now, all between November and February. There's 4 of us left.

Carl.
 
Thanks Jack! Someone got lucky there!

They certainly did Kevin :)

Well, what's left of the Moran Breakfast club thought it was a very nice knife. Unfortunately, this past winter was not good one. We had three of our number pass away. Hoppy, Jimmy, and Tom are gone now, all between November and February. There's 4 of us left.

Carl.

Sorry to hear that Carl.

Jack
 
That's great, Carl! I though Bastid had put an 85 forum knife into your hands?

I must be getting myself confused.

Kevin

Yes, Gus did very graciously gift me one. I carried it bit, tried it out, and it was a great pocket knife, but bigger and heavier than I found comfortable to carry. Plus, if conditions were less than perfect, Ihad some trouble opening the screw driver/bottle opener blade. With some hesitation I passed it on to a younger member who would maybe get more use out of it. I can only hope Gus forgives me.

Carl.
 
Sorry to hear that Carl.

Jack

Thank you. One of the penalties of reaching a certain age is, you start to see too many old friends one last time at the viewing. Tom had battled skin cancer for several years, but after it gets into the lymph system, it's just a delaying game. Hoppy was fine up until last summer, when he started getting extremely tired, and found he had terminal leukemia. He was gone by November. Jimmy had been fighting lung cancer for 10 years that he got from asbestos exposure in the Navy many years ago.

On the bright side, I had the great fortune to number these men as my best friends for many years. My old man told me that you can measure your wealth by the people that are your friends. By that reckoning, combining the friends I have, both that I have met, and those like on this forum that Ihave never met, I'm going to die a very rich man. :thumbup:

Carl.
 
I didn't want to kick any peanuts or opinels out of your pockets, but I am glad you like the 15 and have gotten some use out of it. Nothing wrong with carrying more than one single blade :D.

You'll have to cajole your breakfast buddies along to the Traditional MD get together/crab feast. I'm going to post something about that.

Might shock the heck out of everyone using a Case Tribal Spear to pick crabs!
 
I didn't want to kick any peanuts or opinels out of your pockets, but I am glad you like the 15 and have gotten some use out of it. Nothing wrong with carrying more than one single blade :D.

You'll have to cajole your breakfast buddies along to the Traditional MD get together/crab feast. I'm going to post something about that.

Might shock the heck out of everyone using a Case Tribal Spear to pick crabs!

Wait till ya see me pickin' with a damascus peanut!:eek:
 
Yes, Gus did very graciously gift me one. I carried it bit, tried it out, and it was a great pocket knife, but bigger and heavier than I found comfortable to carry. Plus, if conditions were less than perfect, Ihad some trouble opening the screw driver/bottle opener blade. With some hesitation I passed it on to a younger member who would maybe get more use out of it. I can only hope Gus forgives me.

Carl.
I doubt that'll be a problem. ;)
 
Understood, sir. I don't see how Gus could be upset about you passing a gesture along :)

I was just confused is all :)

I just thought I remembered you telling your initial impressions of how nice it was, but it had been a while.

Waiting to hear how the 15 makes out with the country sausage on a fork test. So sorry to hear of the awful last year :(

Yes, Gus did very graciously gift me one. I carried it bit, tried it out, and it was a great pocket knife, but bigger and heavier than I found comfortable to carry. Plus, if conditions were less than perfect, Ihad some trouble opening the screw driver/bottle opener blade. With some hesitation I passed it on to a younger member who would maybe get more use out of it. I can only hope Gus forgives me.

Carl.
 
Thank you. One of the penalties of reaching a certain age is, you start to see too many old friends one last time at the viewing. Tom had battled skin cancer for several years, but after it gets into the lymph system, it's just a delaying game. Hoppy was fine up until last summer, when he started getting extremely tired, and found he had terminal leukemia. He was gone by November. Jimmy had been fighting lung cancer for 10 years that he got from asbestos exposure in the Navy many years ago.

On the bright side, I had the great fortune to number these men as my best friends for many years. My old man told me that you can measure your wealth by the people that are your friends. By that reckoning, combining the friends I have, both that I have met, and those like on this forum that Ihave never met, I'm going to die a very rich man. :thumbup:

Carl.

Yes, it's a sad part of ageing Carl, and it sounds as if the Breakfast Club has been hit hard in recent times. You reflect on it very well though my friend :)

Jack
 
Back
Top