Fixed blade decisions needed.

I would think hard about something like a Mora Bushcraft Orange. It's a competent knife that can see you through a lot, it's very easy to sharpen and it won't break the bank. Use it, see what you like and dislike about it and use that to inform your next purchase (make no mistake, if you stay on this forum there WILL be a next purchase.)
 
I have a Fallkniven juni so I don't have to use my volcano for finer stuff. It's a great small fixed blade. When I use as edc I run a ball chain about 16" long and just du .it thru belt loop. It hangs rite at bottom rib cage. In steeple settings I just tuck under shirt and no is any wise. It's a.beautiful blade with some of, actually the best steel going 3G. It works much bigger than it is and stays.Sharp forever I shit u not. Couple passes on the strop every nite keeps it tip top and starts slowly polishing the convex edge which is sharp as he'll already. Knives is pricey but beautiful, just beautiful IMHO. Check one out.
 
I would think hard about something like a Mora Bushcraft Orange. It's a competent knife that can see you through a lot, it's very easy to sharpen and it won't break the bank. Use it, see what you like and dislike about it and use that to inform your next purchase (make no mistake, if you stay on this forum there WILL be a next purchase.)
 

I would actually suggest the BK-16 over the 15 due to what he is planning on using it for. The drop point would work better for skinning/hunting, and would work out well for camp duties and comparatively light wood processing for hiking should the need arise. Though you can process larger wood with it, I would suggest a larger blade for heavier batoning (not that you stated you would be doing so, just covering my bases).

I would also strongly suggest a look at the Mora brand, nicely priced, relatively strong and good at taking a nice edge. Only thing is that the handles can seem a bit cheap on the Moras, but for $15-$50, some concessions would have to be made.
 
I would actually suggest the BK-16 over the 15 due to what he is planning on using it for. The drop point would work better for skinning/hunting, and would work out well for camp duties and comparatively light wood processing for hiking should the need arise.

While I agree that the drop point is generally more versitile for camp/bushcrafty stuff, I thought the trailing point profile was used more specifically for hunting and skinning applications?

In my case I am fairly a light user and knives are a fun hobby. I may well have opted for the BK-16 if I didn't already have a couple of drop points when I decided to try a Becker. All good, just different.
 
Just another opinion by someone who has preferences so take it for what its worth. My favorite blade is from 3 to 4 inches. So based on that here is my preferences:

< $100 ESEE 3
< $120 Fallkniven F1
< $160 to $200 or there close - Bark River (Several models to choose from in that range Gunny, Liten Bror, Bushcrafter, Ultra-Lite Bushcrafter and more, multitudes of different handles)
>$200 for that "its my special knife" - Bark River again, for me a nice burl wood handle with mosiac pins

ESEEs have that lifetime warranty. Bark River also has the lifetime warranty as well with a special twist ... their spa package. With the spa package send that knife in with $15 return shipping and they will make her like new again, sharpen her back up and even redo the logos. I haven't been able to find that anywhere else.

My preference is in the reverse order I listed. Nothing to inject into the decision making precess such as money or anything else:

1. Bark River (just so many options in knives and handle material, excellent CS in my experience, owner very helpful and active with answering questions)
2. Fallkniven F1 (just cuts so smooth through wood when processing)
3. ESEEs (cheaper but not a cheap knife, excellent knife with great warranty)

That's my 2 cents that's only worth about 1 cent.
 
"Perfect knives for the average user" pretty much fall into the ESSE's and KaBars/Beckers. I have a thing for the ESSE 3 MilSpec and KaBar USMC myself.

For a good, all around 'one only' knife check out the DPx HEFT line of fixed blades also.
 
Sorry I didn't explain to much. I live in Texas, the longest blade I can own and use is 5.5 inches so around that size, it wouldn't be an edc. I want a good fixed blade for hunting camping hiking etc. Sorry for the confusion I'm new to this. &#128539;


=====
KNIVES FOR BACKPACKING AND HUNTING
=====

I've been asked by several friends for recommendations on knives for backpacking and camping. Here you go.

-----
Knowledge
-----
Knives are fun and they're useful. But knowledge is more useful. For backpacking, I recommend books by Chris Townsend. For general camping, I recommend books by Cliff Jacobsen. Before spending money on a knife, I highly recommend getting a book as your first investment.

-----
Stoves
-----
Knives are used primarily for 2 things: food preparation and starting fires. There are other uses, but these are the big ones. Before relying on a knife for starting fires, first learn how to use a camp stove. Canister stoves are the easiest to use but require that you monitor the amount of fuel left in the canister. White gas stove burn hottest and on long trips are lightest since the fuel burns so hot. Alcohol stoves are light and simple and for short trips are very light.

The most important aspect of any stove is your experience with the stove. Regardless of what stove you get, my recommendation is that you use it to boil water with it every day for 2 weeks straight and regardless of the weather. After this you will have confidence that you can operate the stove in any conditions and knowing all of the quirks of your stove.

My opinion is that if you are 100% confident in your ability to use your stove, you will be more confident in what knife you choose.

-----
Light Backpacking
-----
For light and ultra-light backpacking, I recommend the Leatherman PS4 Squirt.

When backpacking light, food preparation needs are reduced to opening packages. There is no need to build fires. Safety and warmth is provided by the clothing and shelter that you carry. Cutting needs are generally reduced to cutting thread and cordage. The scissors are useful for cutting bandages and material for equipment repairs. The pliers are useful for driving a sewing needle through heavy webbing. The screwdriver and pliers are useful for equipment repairs. People routinely through-hike the AT and PCT with nothing more than a tool like the Squirt.

----
Normal Backpacking
----
For normal backpacking, I recommend a small tool like the Leatherman PS4 Squirt combined with a small folding knife.

When backpacking with more than an ultra-light load, food preparation will likely increase to include cutting meat and cheese and perhaps vegetables. If you fish, it may also include the cleaning of the fish. When backpacking, again there is no need to make a camp fire.

Many people prefer to carry a multi-function knife like a Swiss Army Knife. Personally, I find most of the tools on SAKs to be less than useful for backpacking. I recommend choosing a model with folding scissors and also carrying a small set of pliers to drive a needle and thread.

-----
Car Camping
-----
For car camping, I recommend a hatchet, a full sized multi-tool and a folding knife like an Opinel #8 or #9.

When car camping, food preparation will be more like food preparation at home. You will need a can opener provided on a multi-tool and a knife blade suited for both slicing food and spreading. If you prefer to have a fixed blade knife, I would recommend getting one that has a drop point and a thin flat ground blade.

Nearly all car camping locations have established fire rings which make fires possible. However, many car camping locations prohibit foraging for wood because hundreds of visitors a year will quickly denude the area. Typically precut local firewood is available at or nearby the campground. This wood is typically cut to length and split for use in a fireplace. To start a fire at a campground fire ring, you will need to further split the firewood to get kindling sized wood. A hatchet or axe is an excellent way to split firewood and, if you make a mistake, go to an emergency room for stitches. A safe way to split firewood with a hatchet is to place the blade on the end of the wood and baton the hatchet with another piece of wood.

-----
Backpacking with Wood Stoves
-----
If you want to backpack and you want to have a fire, I recommend purchasing a small folding wood stove, such s the Bush Cooker or Emberlit. These stoves run on finger sized wood and minimize and simplify the wood harvesting needs. Often they can be run successfully entirely on wood gathered and broken by hand with no knife needed. They also minimize ash production, making it possible to have a fire without causing undue impact.

For camping with folding wood stove, I recommend carrying a small folding saw and a fixed blade knife with a blade in the 4" to 5" range. I further recommend that the knife not be hollow ground. The Silky Boy saw and Mora Companion are solid choices.

I find a small saw to be a very efficient way to cut wood to length. A knife with a blade in the 4" to 5" range will split wood in the 2" to 3" range to get dry wood for starting a fire. The knife can also be used to make shavings to start the stove more easily.
 
Count me as one more for a Mora — many models available, both "original" (wood handle) or "modern" (plastic/rubber). They're cheap (under $20 w/shipping), so you can try it out, and if you don't like it, you can sell it, give it away, or stash the thing in your vehicle for emergencies.

Available in both carbon steel (blade needs a minimum of easy maintainence to prevent rust) and stainless.
 
I carried a tops street scalpel in an urban environment for years and never raised an eyebrow. It's a brute, but so small and simple it doesn't draw attention. It IS a little "sharpened prybar" though...

I'd recommend an Izula. Or if you don't mind a little thicky thickness, the street scalpel.
 
search

Arno Bernard Meerkat . Great edc/BBQ/backup knife. Love mine, paid under 120 including shipping. Vg10 equivalent steel and very classy looking. Doesn't scare sheeple.
5fc22aa384e7c11752db331dcd4bd6d7.jpg
 
I've been I need of a fixed blade for a long time... But in my area I live downtown, and don't go hiking or camping enough to worry about needing anything other than a simple folding knife.

But I would really like to have a knife that I can use and not worry about breaking it. I've watched many videos of different companies knives being tested. Cold steel, Ontario, Esee, Sog, Etc.

But I'm interested in a knife that truly is perfect for the average user. It doesn't have to be a pry bar but I don't want a fillet knife. Any suggestions?

I'll let the knife speak for itself.
9Zc08Aq.jpg
 
It seems like you've said you need nothing more than a simple folding knife, but also want a fixed blade for woodsy stuff. The advice for you to look at a simple 3" fixed blade is good advice, I believe. There are countless good ones in this length, certainly for less than $100. If you need further advice, please clarify.
 
Bark River Gunny is nice but about any Bark River is I got a few, Scrapyard knives 411 is another 1 I recommend, Busse AMS or B4 are good choices too, Spartan knives may have 1 or 2 models you maybe interested in. It really comes down to how much you want to spend and what you want to use it for. The knives I listed I own or have had experience with so I'm not saying there aren't other options out there that will work better for you, I'm just trying to give ya more options.
 
DFBABK.jpg

DFBABK Dewey Bush Knife
DFB ABK Dewey Bush Knife
All prices in Australian Dollars
DFBABK Dewey Bush Knife - ABK $279.00
5 1/2" 14cm D2 tool steel, 4.5mm thick blade, full tang, Australian timber handles
DFB090 Army $162.00
4 3/4" 12cm D2 tool steel, 4.5mm thick blade, Australian timber handles
DFB090A Army - antler handle $195.00
12cm D2 tool steel, 4.5mm thick blade, Antler handles
Sheaths for ABK and Army $56.00
http://www.deweyknives.com.au/index.html

Svord_677BB_Lge2.jpg

Svord Curved Skinner 5 3/4&#8221; Blade

SVOFKnw.jpg

Svord Farmers Knife 5" Blade
L6 tool steel differentially heat treated
http://www.svord.com/index.php
 
First you don't do much camping then you want if for camping and hiking....

Buy an Esse 3 or a comparable size Bark River or Arno Bernard, depending on your budget, and go from there with experience.
 
I will echo many of these selections, and I also own, and use these so they have worked personally for me.

ESEE- 3 or 4 (I prefer the 3 for camp use)
Bark River Gunny
Fallkniven F1

If you want stainless, and a good tough blade, Fallkniven is the choice, or a stainless Mora as others have suggested, plus you can buy several of them.
 
I would buy an Esee Izula. You can get it in your favorite color, OD Green, Venom (Zombie) green, orange, purple, flat earth, gray, black, red, silver, etc. Most are carbon steel, but coated, but they do make a stainless. I edc one of these in my front pocket and I can snap off the very secure sheath with a push of my thumb. Since it was designed for abuse, you will not break it. Best of all? Esee is in ALABAMA!
 
Your not asking for trouble as long as you make sure your legal and socially appropriate. I have never had anyone even ask me what i'm carrying and I am in the liberal mecca of NY. Upstate but still . With a t shirt I doubt anyone will notice anyhow.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top