Fixed blade epiphany.

Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Messages
17,625
I'm a little slow on the uptake sometimes. Not the sharpest knife in the drawer, nor the brightest bulb in the chandelier. I make little mistakes here and there, and sometimes manage to really screw the pooch. But sometimes I get the idea.

I've always been a small pocket knife guy. maybe its that I grew up in Washington D.C. and 90% of my time was in the urban jungle. Later the suburban trip as a soccer/lacrosse/cub scouts and general dad with mini van on call. But the family did do the camping, fishing, hiking thing and I was an ultra light backpacker for many years. I did carry a fixed blade then, fishing or canoeing, and I love fixed blades for the simple fact that they are not broken in the middle. No lock to fail, easier to clean, and light weight compared to the same size folder. My go-to knife was a Buck 102 woodsman. Carried first one since 1969 to 1999, when my wife bought me a new one to retire the old worn down one.

But...it was never an EDC. Living in an east coast metro area, it just wasn't to be. Although legal, the local PD would always stop and question why did I have that on my hip. Its a sad fact that most cops don't know the law, and when told it was legal in Maryland, actually didn't believe me. It needed some time to clear it up and be on my way. Inconvenient. So, I just carried a pocket knife. Easier.

In 2015, the better half retired and we fled the People's Republik Of Maryland for the free state of Texas. Once settled in a house, we took the class and paid the fee and got our CCW. It was nice to live in our golden years in a place that lets us practice all of our rights. But...that little three letter word again, it took a few years to really get it. We'd carry our concealed handguns, and it was nice when Texas went to open carry. Easier when hiking to have the gun out where its easy to get to. But I was still in the pocket knife mentality. It took a few years for the idea to slowly percolate into my brain that I can carry a fixed blade in Texas and nobody freaks out. I saw lots of them on hips, and slowly, very slowly, I started leaving my Little Buck 102 on my belt when I was done fishing. My CCW handgun was in my right pants pocket, so the hip and belt space was open.

Now, it seems like the epiphany has taken place that a light fixed blade is a nice thing to carry. Far easier to deal with than a folder that has to be opened once its out, no hidden ares for gunk collection, no worry over a lock failure. I've seen the bloody aftermath of a Buck 110 lock fail, and it wasn't pretty. The severed index finger was laying on the floor in a bloody puddle. The quick thinking shop Forman get some ice from the cafeteria and put the finger in the ice anti was transported with the patient and actually got reattached. But it didn't quite work as well.

So now my Buck 102 is my main carry, with a Leatherman squirt for bottle opening and screw driving. The little pliers are handy for an old fart with arthritic fingers. In fact, for an old fart with the old age loss of dexterity, (AKA senior citizen fumble fingers) a small EDC fixed blade is great. For more formal occasions where my Buck may be out of place, a small knife like a Boker Gnome or the AG Russell woods walker with the kydex sheath is a good 'un-folding pocket knife' for use as an out of sight neck knife. Under Texas law, we can conceal up to a 5 inch fixed blade if I understand it right.

Now, 5 1/2 years after moving to Texas, I don't know if I could go back to a folding/pocket knife as a main slicer. I like the fixed blade.
 
Last edited:
I'm certainly glad we have another convert, re: daily fixed blade carry. The ability to pull a blade, cut what you need to, put it back quickly and keep going, is great.

I got the fixed blade bug when I was only 10 years old but obviously didn't carry them during my JR/SR high school/college/USN active duty/the corporate world years. During this time I carried paired fixed blades only when working out on the farm or when engaged in outdoor activities (hunting/fishing/etc).

Since leaving the 'business world", I've EDC'd fixed blades every day, except when prohibited by law/regulation etc - e.g., court housed and federal facilities. For forays into these dens of iniquity, I simply pull the knives out of their sheathes, hide them under the vehicle seat, leaving the sheaths on my belt.

If guards question my sporting knife sheaths, I simply ask them "When did sheaths become banned?" and then go about why I went in the building.

When I went to the court house for jury duty in 2006, I dressed according to the required standards (no logos on shirts etc). When I was challenged by the bailliff about the sheaths, I simply asked --

"Where in the regs does it say no knife sheaths?"

When he started to sputter BS, I simply told him "You can either let me go in or you can go tell the judge I showed up and was refused entry while being legal and then give mean a signed, dated note indicating that you refused me entry."

He relented as he knew he didn't have a leg to stand on. I went on in, got selected to be on the jury, selected to be foreman. We found the piece trash guilty and sent him off for 20 years.

The good news? Since that run-in with the bailiff, I have not received a jury summonds. Maybe they put me on a "do not summon" list.

I admit I carry "broken knives", but sometimes they are the appropriate tool for the job. :D
 
I'd love to carry a fixed blade, but comcealed carry illegal in my state :(. I carried a 4 inch puukko when backpacking or hiking in the woods. My EDC is a 30+ year old SAK Tinker.
Rich
 
Jackknife

I am happy you have found your way my friend

I have always preferred fixed blades and it is the odd day that I carry a folder

you know my preference these days mostly 3ish inch wharnies worn horizontal on my belt in front of my left hip right side crossdraw Philipino grip or left hand ice pick grip







this one is the one that gets carried the most

 
I don't EDC a fixed blade (wouldn't really be practical in my life and location) but if I did, the Buck 102 would probably be in heavy rotation. I got mine in the late 80s, if I recall correctly. This was my first good knife. And I still like it a lot.

It's been fun to follow your evolution as a knife user, jackknife. Thanks for posting your journey and your reasoning about it over the last few years.

-Tyson
 
I'm a little slow on the uptake sometimes. Not the sharpest knife in the drawer, nor the brightest bulb in the chandelier. I make little mistakes here and there, and sometimes manage to really screw the pooch. But sometimes I get the idea.

I've always been a small pocket knife guy. maybe its that I grew up in Washington D.C. and 90% of my time was in the urban jungle. Later the suburban trip as a soccer/lacrosse/cub scouts and general dad with mini van on call. But the family did do the camping, fishing, hiking thing and I was an ultra light backpacker for many years. I did carry a fixed blade then, fishing or canoeing, and I love fixed blades for the simple fact that they are not broken in the middle. No lock to fail, easier to clean, and light weight compared to the same size folder. My go-to knife was a Buck 102 woodsman. Carried first one since 1969 to 1999, when my wife bought me a new one to retire the old worn down one.

But...it was never an EDC. Living in an east coast metro area, it just wasn't to be. Although legal, the local PD would always stop and question why did I have that on my hip. Its a sad fact that most cops don't know the law, and when told it was legal in Maryland, actually didn't believe me. It needed some time to clear it up and be on my way. Inconvenient. So, I just carried a pocket knife. Easier.

In 2015, the better half retired and we fled the People's Republik Of Maryland for the free state of Texas. Once settled in a house, we took the class and paid the fee and got our CCW. It was nice to live in our golden years in a place that lets us practice all of our rights. But...that little three letter word again, it took a few years to really get it. We'd carry our concealed handguns, and it was nice when Texas went to open carry. Easier when hiking to have the gun out where its easy to get to. But I was still in the pocket knife mentality. It took a few years for the idea to slowly percolate into my brain that I can carry a fixed blade in Texas and nobody freaks out. I saw lots of them on hips, and slowly, very slowly, I started leaving my Little Buck 102 on my belt when I was done fishing. My CCW handgun was in my right pants pocket, so the hip and belt space was open.

Now, it seems like the epiphany has taken place that a light fixed blade is a nice thing to carry. Far easier to deal with than a folder that has to be opened once its out, no hidden ares for gunk collection, no worry over a lock failure. I've seen the bloody aftermath of a Buck 110 lock fail, and it wasn't pretty. The severed index finger was laying on the floor in a bloody puddle. The quick thinking shop Forman get some ice from the cafeteria and put the finger in the ice anti was transported with the patient and actually got reattached. But it didn't quite work as well.

So now my Buck 102 is my main carry, with a Leatherman squirt for bottle opening and screw driving. The little pliers are handy for an old fart with arthritic fingers. In fact, for an old fart with the old age loss of dexterity, (AKA senior citizen fumble fingers) a small EDC fixed blade is great. For more formal occasions where my Buck may be out of place, a small knife like a Boker Gnome or the AG Russell woods walker with the index sheath is a good 'un-folding pocket knife' for use as an out of sight neck knife. Under Texas law, we can conceal up to a 5 inch fixed blade if I understand it right.

Now, 5 1/2 years after moving to Texas, I don't know if I could go back to a folding/pocket knife as a main slicer. I like the fixed blade.

Under Texas law, you can carry ANY knife. No blade length limit, concealed or open carry. Fixed blades, autos, dirks, daggers, hell a claymore if you want to.

It used to be no autos, dirks, daggers, or bowies, and a blade length limit of 5 1/2”, but not anymore.
 
Yep, a folder is broken by definition, so I carry a BK14 for many years now and that "little" blade is actually so amazing, I don't need anything else.
However, I also have a small SAK with me to pry away staples and if someone "needs a knife for a second"

IMG_20210322_110834_compress0.jpg
 
I don't EDC a fixed blade (wouldn't really be practical in my life and location) but if I did, the Buck 102 would probably be in heavy rotation. I got mine in the late 80s, if I recall correctly. This was my first good knife. And I still like it a lot.

It's been fun to follow your evolution as a knife user, jackknife. Thanks for posting your journey and your reasoning about it over the last few years.

-Tyson

You're very welcome, sir.

What has been enlightening to me is, how my attitudes and likes have changed as I aged. My 30's were different than my 40's, and my 50's saw the bigger change as I edged toward my 60's. Things that were soooo important to me that I thought I'd never change, faded and were replaced by something else. There seemed to be a creeping pragmatic attitude as I aged, lived more, and gained most life experience with different things along the way. It also took place with the guns, vehicles and many other things in life.
 
Wow you had a coworker chop off his index finger on a lock failure?? That is nuts.

You should have heard the scream echoing up the hall from the sheet metal shop! The kid was freaked out. He almost took off the middle finger, but the blade got stuck in the bone. I guess it just happened to hit the index finger joint square on when the lock gave away. Took it right off.

A few years after that, I had a minor operation on my left thumb for trigger finger condition in the base joint of the thumb. When I went back to the hand clinic to get my stitches out, I was sitting in the waiting room, and across from me was a young guy, maybe 20 or so, and his right hand and mostly index finger was cocooned in gauge. Ends up, he was waiting to get stitches out from an operation to restore use of his finger from a knife accident. It came out in conversation that he was "messing around" as he put it, with his new tactical knife, and it closed up on him. The liner lock gave out.

I didn't ask what he was doing, none of my business. But I've never trusted locks, and the bast advise I ever got was from our scout master when I was 12 years old. We have this retired marine guy, Mr. Van, and he Told us if we wanted to have a knife that we knew would never fold over on us, Just use a sheath knife. They were called that back then, not fixed blades since they didn't need fixing as nothing was broken on them.

I guess thats why my whole life I just carried small slip joints like peanut and small SAK's. If I need more knife, then its time to use a real knife. One that doesn't fold and depend on a lock devise to keep it open.
 
I'd love to carry a fixed blade, but comcealed carry illegal in my state :(.
Where I live, the restrictions are a little ambiguous. The law reads that it is illegal to carry a "bowie knife" concealed. Case law, however, indicates that any large fixed blade could be considered a "bowie knife". I've carried a couple of pocket-sized fixed blade (2-3 inches) but I never tried anything larger except while camping.
 
Where I live, the restrictions are a little ambiguous. The law reads that it is illegal to carry a "bowie knife" concealed. Case law, however, indicates that any large fixed blade could be considered a "bowie knife". I've carried a couple of pocket-sized fixed blade (2-3 inches) but I never tried anything larger except while camping.

Thats why had to move to Texas to carry a fixed blade. After almost getting arrested in Maryland over a tiny Buck Hartsook, I forsook the whole unfolding pocket knife idea. But now in Texas, its way more relaxed. I love the convenience of takeout knife, cut, put knife back. A small sheath knife like the Boker Gnome makes a very good unfolding pocket knife. The whole thing slips down in the pocket and the knife pulls right out of the index sheath that is secured by a black lanyard to the belt loop by the pocket.

And if it gets gunked up with food stuff, just rinse off under the faucet or creek. No hidden area in joint. And it legal here. I'm still happy about being out of The Peoples Republik Of Maryland where ANY concealed fixed blade is illegal. No matter if its a 1 3/4 inch teeny thing.
 
Last edited:
Sorry for OT, but this can be interesting for everyone coming to our little country:)

Well, here in Germany we got very interesting* knife laws:
I am generally allowed to (open or concealed) carry a fixed blade with up to a 4.72" (12cm) blade.
I am generally allowed to (open or concealed) carry a slip joint or a two handed opening locking knife with no length restrictions.

I am generally not allowed to carry a one hand opening locking knife whatever the length (Also Multitools with one hand opening and locking)
I am generally not allowed to carry a bigger fixed blade knife than 4,72"

However, with an "approved purpose" I can also carry bigger knives - and one handed knives. (So for camping, the preservation of cultural folklore - Thank you Bavaria!- and professional purposes it is allowed.)
When you walk or drive to your "approved purpose" the knife must be secured in a "closed and locked container" (meaning your backpack or knife sheath itself MUST have a padlock, but not having it in your glove box in your car... )

*read confusing and open to interpretation by authorities

So again, with my BK14, I am very much on the safe side and with it's nimble looks, it won't cause trouble.
 
This was my introduction to the fixed blade EDC stuff :
9RCO9Mw.jpg

And then of course, there was this :
LHFGfCN.jpg

And today, I revel in this, this, and this :
3VfS9HY.jpg


wucYFnK.jpg


3CtyVta.jpg

But mostly, I like this, day in and day out on me. It does everything I want !
2qJiNQQ.jpg
 
I've seen the bloody aftermath of a Buck 110 lock fail, and it wasn't pretty. The severed index finger was laying on the floor in a bloody puddle.

I can't help but suspect user error here. There's a certain direction in which force should be applied to a knife, and that is generally, at least in my opinion, edge toward cutting medium. Sounds like this guy was trying it the other way around.
 
At first step, I wouldn't hold that against any folding knife. Besides, a lot of people injure themselves with fixed blades... Check out machete or axe injuries. OOOf ... There's no cure for stupid and it shouldn't be blamed on the design or the folder. This said, there are certainly some questionable locks out there (by design or by finish). Personal experience ? My backlocks have been from the tightest to the wiggling ones (not many). Liner locks have all been consistently reliable. The external backspring like the traditional Navaja or the Okapi is also very reliable. So... A lock is cool but you don't trust your fingers to it. When you grab a blade you shouldn't do stupid, right ?
 
Last edited:
I can't help but suspect user error here. There's a certain direction in which force should be applied to a knife, and that is generally, at least in my opinion, edge toward cutting medium. Sounds like this guy was trying it the other way around.

The job in question was modifying some plastic parts. It needed a slot cut into it, and rather than put the large parts in the machine and use the right tool, he was using the Buck 110 by pushing/pounding the butt to force the point through the material, and then levering down on the handle to cut through the plastic. He was pushing the edge toward the medium being cut. It didn't matter, he exceeded the pounds force the locking bar put on the blade tang. The shop Forman told him to knock off that crap and use the right tool. Young smart a$$ said "Its a Buck knife, It'll take it!" Well it didn't, and he needed some real intricate surgery at the Johns-Hopkins hand clinic in Baltimore. He got fired by the way for violating shop safety protocols and failure to follow shop Forman orders for job procedures.

You can't fix or regulate stupid. What we had there was a young guy who had the attitude of 'It has a lock on the blade, so I can lean on it a bit." He grew up in the age of lock blades and never learned proper knife use. He lost a finger as a result. Last I heard was, there was a question of it ever working again or it being lost eventually if it didn't "take".

If he'd had a fixed blade, maybe the blade would snap, but he'd have his fingers intact. Mechanisms fail. One solid piece of steel won't unless you exceed the pounds of force to actually break it. With a quality fixed blade that may be beyond what you can do without a cheater pipe. Even a mediocre fixed blade will take far more abuse than a very good folder.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top