Fixed blade for an edc versipack

thedukeoftank

thedukeoftank

Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
109
Hey guys,

I am looking for a medium size fixed blade to mount to my EDC versipack.

While at my parents house over memorial day weekend, there were a few instances where I really wished that I had a fixed blade. Such as clearing small brush/branches, battoning wood for a campfire, making shims to level a picnic table, etc. Now, I could have used my large backup folder for the the day (ZT 0200) but I really didn't want to thump on that beauty.

Here is where I need your help. I was doing a little research and I have found 2 blades (Becker BK11 & ESEE 4) that might work, but I would appreciate more suggestions.

The desired specs:
3" to 5.5"
Carbon Steel
Flat grind
Kydex sheath
Thinner profile
Handle scales included/separately purchased
$100 Max (Preferably less)

I really like the BK11 but I am concerned that the blade might not be long enough for battoning. On the flip side, the ESEE 4 looks close to perfect but it is quite pricy.

Edit: req. update
 
Last edited:
Along the same lines, maybe check out the BK14. I have the BK11 and really like it, but some say the handle on the 14 is more comfortable.
 
as for batoning with a 11 it all deends on wood size, as long as the blade is longer than the wood you are good to go. I batoned with my 13 which is smaller han the 11.

But IA is right check out the 14 it has a longer blade but is still has a small profile.

remoratest002.jpg
 
Anyone mount a fixed blade to their edc pack and do you have pictures?

I do love the look/function of the ESEE 4 but I can't justify the $$$ for what small use it will likely see. I just wish that the BK11/BK14 had a bit longer blades.

Also, can the BK14 use the izula micarta scales?
 
If you're lucky enough to have a brick & morter store near you that sells ESEE knives, go handle an ESEE-4 and you might change your opinion of the 4.
 
thedukeoftank said:
The desired specs:
3" to 5.5"
Carbon Steel
Flat grind
Kydex sheath
Thinner profile
Handle scales included/separately purchased
$100 Max (Preferably less)
Click to expand...

Thats a really restrictive set of requirements considering you also want to batton, since so few knives meet the entire criteria it best you just go with ESEE and pay the cash.

If your looking for other options you might need to lower your expectations or increase your budget.

Best of luck!
 
I have a Maxped Proteus Versipack that stays in my car with some "arrive alive" gear in it. I also use it on day hikes. I keep an Izula 2 molle'd to the webbing on the back side. That's enough for me. I'll have a larger FB on my belt if I'm actually taking a planned trip and anything of an emergency nature that comes up while driving should be easily dealt with by the Izzy.

That system works well when wearing the pack as intended also. The knife is small and light enough to be comfortable and accessible even when the pack is being worn pretty securely. If you really want a longer blade, you might look at the ESSEE 3. The sheath is different from the Izula, but it might still work the way I have mine set up.
 
Another question, how do the Ontario Rats stack up against the ESEEs? From what I can see, it looks like the Ontario Rats have much thicker handles.
 
The ESEE 4 is a great knife except for the handles which can be replaced my TKC drop in G10 replacements but htey are over $50, bringing the knife up into Bravo-1 territory. I'd go with a BRKT Bravo-1 or the ESEE 4 if the handle fits you. I have large hands with long, thin fingers, and prefer the Bravo's handle and scales. The ESEE is a great iknife though and it may be fine out of the wrap for you. Try one out!

Another great choice is Fallkniven F1. Its stainless VG-10 and priced between the ESEE 4 and Bravo-1.
 
I'm a pretty big fan of the bk11 but that's probably because I use it way more often for opening a beer than chopping through wood
 
Ontario's are good but the ESEE's have a little longer handle for better purchase. Spend the money and get the ESEE, for small task IZULA or ESEE 3, for medium task the 4, it's worth it. For most task the 3 is perfect plus it doesn't freak people out that are not used to "knife guys".
 
Another vote for the ESEE 4. I have the 3 and love it, but the 4 has the kydex you're looking for. The 3 has a molded plastic sheath that (in my opinion) is even better than kydex, though.
 
my jumbo clone has a pocket behind the pouch - i can drop an ESEE 4, Izula, or BK14 in that pocket with no problem.
While I really like my BK14, the 4 meets your stated requirements better.
As to your other question - the Izula scales can be made to fit on the BK14 with minimal trimming of the internal spacer -- or you can email SH@RP (he's a knife parts/services supplier here on BF) about his custom scales.
attachment.php

I think The-Knife-Connection also sells custom izula scales, but I have no idea how much hassle it would be to adapt them to an Eskabar/BK14.
 
+1 for the ESEE 3
I think it's probably the knife that best fits ur needs. The ESEE 4 wouldn't really add any advantage, just more weight. Instead, u could consider going smaller and getting an Izula II.
If u plan to process a lot of wood, get a folding saw and u will be ok. Anyway, I can assure u that the ESEE 3 will be strong enough for ur needs, even for battoning.
A good cheaper alternative would be the Ontario RAT 3.
As others said, ur specifications are really tight so I guess there's not many knives that fit ur requirements.
:cool:
 
I agree that you'll love the ESEE 4. If your not planning on batoning daily, the ESEE 3 might be better for you. The 3 is thinner than the 4, only an inch shorter, and 2 oz lighter. You'll be happy with either and it you break it, they will replace it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top