Fixed Blade Knives

Joined
Nov 28, 2012
Messages
11
I haven't posted much in these forums, so sorry if this is a common question.

I have a good number of folding knives, but I have never purchased a fixed blade. What are some of the recommendations you guys have for a fixed blade? Manufacturer, grind and edge type, blade and handle material? All of that good stuff. I was looking at Emerson Knives, but most of their fixed blades are out of stock at the moment.
 
What do want to do with it?
How much are you willing to spend?

Right now, I'm not sure if you are looking for a X-Acto knife or a machete. :)
 
Ah... good questions... wish I had thought of them! Budget is around 200-300 (hopefully that covers a mid-range fixed blade). It is for pretty basic use. Cutting rope and wood and small chores. Nothing too extreme, but I still like to have a versatile blade. For size, anything in the 4-7 inch range is pretty much good for me.
 
Well...before the Becker and ESEE folks get here, I'll suggest a Fallkniven. Well made knife, easy to maintain convex grind, range of sizes and costs...

F1 @ about 4 inches and ~150 US
S1 @ about 5 inches and ~175 US
A1 @ about 6 inches and ~220 US

Also I am very partial to anything in the Ontario Ranger line. Bombproof stuff if you are looking to have a great time bashing the bejeebus outta stuff.
 
If I had 2-3 hundred for a fixed blade, I'd go with a ka bar bk16 or 17. Get some custom scales made out of whatever you want, quality kydex or leather sheath, and you'd still be under $200. For sheath I'd recommend Azwelke, I had bk11 sheath made and after 6 months its still going strong. Why not just a more expensive knive with a good sheath and fancy handles? Customization, you can get any style of sheath in any color you want and any material. Same goes for handles. The blade is 4 3/8" long and 1095 crovan. Hope this helps.
 
Swamp Rat Ratmandu is a good one. I think Busse might have one for sale in that price range as well. You can also go custom at that price point.
 
Thanks for all of the advice! Now I have a good starting point for some research. That Swamp Rat is looking pretty nice right now.
 
For 2-300 bucks I would look at customs. Many fine makers here on the forum.
 
You can get useful fixed blades from $35 up. At the low end are interesting designs like the Gerber Epic - a 3 1/2" wharncliff with a bottle opener in the handle, the sheath has a pocket clip for front carry.

Next up would be deer hunting and utility knife patterns up to $125, plus military. From there to the $250 level you can find all sorts of interesting, useful, and certainly outrageous stuff. More than that is spending money to get small incremental improvements, hand finishing, a name Brand, exotic steels. High alloy steels are much harder to work and finish in large knives, the labor goes up exponentially. In a large field knife, it's arguably more money that might be needed in a knife.

An expensive knife is just that, nearly heirloom, but you only get one for the money. It could buy half a dozen other knives that are serviceable, and over the course of years, someone could find exactly what features they prefer and would like to have in one. There's nothing wrong with knives under $100 - the money saved could be spent for other gear.

As time has gone by, my fixed blades have become smaller, less exotic, and plainer. Fashion and fads have come and gone, a fixed blade boils down to a handle that is comfortable to hold, well rounded, and reversible for other grips. Blades have gone from heavy tactical swedge grinds to simple flat grinds, maybe with a finger choil to choke up with, and a bit more width than older ones. Grips have gone from stag, wood, leather, rubber compounds, and now plain canvas micarta or G10. The sheath has become a much more important item, and the steel in a 4-6 inch knife a lot less so. Bigger knives don't require a better steel to get good performance, their grind and edge bevel is more important.

Because of that I've gone from using Gerber Mk II's or Randall #14's to the Benchmade Nimravus, and now looking at the ESEE Laser Strike. A fixed blade is just that - not a folding one, and the added inch or two of edge isn't all that important. What is important is that it can take a lot more leverage for hard chores, and even do some light chopping when a hawk or axe isn't in hand. It can be a sharpened pry bar with a lot less probability of snapping off the tip.

But, no everyone buys a fixed blade for the same reasons, which is why there are so many designs, and why we ask, What will you do with it? Like any tool, it has a different shape for a different purpose. What has to be disregarded on the internet are all the responses where someone promotes his favorite design when you don't really even know if you need it - like having someone recommend a drilldriver with phillips bit when the job really needs a star socket on a ratchet. One is for installing sheet rock, the other for taking off brake calipers. Both jobs are all about turning a fastener, but they aren't the same at all. Neither are knives.

It's not just about cutting, but what and where you do it.
 
For 2-300 bucks I would look at customs. Many fine makers here on the forum.

This :thumbup: look on the exchange for fixed blade by maker.

The knives range from heavy duty workers made out of 3V to classy gent knives with burl wood handles, and about everything in between. Most of which will fall in your price range.
 
Once I go over a 200 dollar price point on a fixed blade its a custom. Under that I stick to Swamp Rat and ESEE, however if I wanted a stainless Falkniven would be my choice.
 
For $200 you can buy a really nice knife made by one of the makers on BF. I have quite a few and I have never paid $200 including shipping to Canada. You can even buy higher end steel like 3v or 52-100 for that price.
 
Well...before the Becker and ESEE folks get here,
Hahaha. We come by the dozens!
The Esee 4 is a boss of a knife. Extremely versatile and well in your price range. The knife that I use the most though is the Izula 2. But the whole Esee line is solid. Look into the BUSSE kin. Ive heard nothing but good things!
 
Well...before the Becker and ESEE folks get here, I'll suggest a Fallkniven. Well made knife, easy to maintain convex grind, range of sizes and costs...

F1 @ about 4 inches and ~150 US
S1 @ about 5 inches and ~175 US
A1 @ about 6 inches and ~220 US

+1 :) I have both the F1 and A1; they're excellent, and will take care of just about anything I need a knife to do between them. You could easily get both within the budget mentioned.
 
If I had 2-3 hundred for a fixed blade, I'd go with a ka bar bk16 or 17. Get some custom scales made out of whatever you want, quality kydex or leather sheath, and you'd still be under $200. For sheath I'd recommend Azwelke, I had bk11 sheath made and after 6 months its still going strong. Why not just a more expensive knive with a good sheath and fancy handles? Customization, you can get any style of sheath in any color you want and any material. Same goes for handles. The blade is 4 3/8" long and 1095 crovan. Hope this helps.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^This!
 
A well rounded start to a fixed blade collection would be a Mora, a Becker BK2, and a Tramontina Machete. You can pick up all three for about $100 shipped, and you'll love em all. The trio will do just about anything.

From there you can start to figure out what you really like in a fixed blade, and you can add on to it with your remaining $200 + whatever else you decide to invest, selecting stuff like Esee, Busse, Bark River, Survive! Knives, etc. for some fun high end toys.
 
That's a pretty big budget for what seems to be (based off your description of how you plan to use it) a light to medium duty knife.

Why not start with a Mora? Yes they're super cheap, no they aren't heavy duty, but my philosophy is start cheap and if you're not satisfied then increase your price range.
 
I like at least 6 inches for bushcraft and full flat grind. I prefer 3 to 4 inches for EDC with ffg or hollow ground. FFG is preferred usually.
 
Back
Top