Fixed Blade Poll

Joined
Oct 8, 2002
Messages
124
I need information / opinions from you fine folks....

A) What overall length is your EDC Fixed Blade?

B) What size do you PREFER for EDC FB carry?

C) What size do you feel is to long for EDC FB carry?

Your answers have a direct impact on my next knife purchase.

Thanks,

Brian
 
My EDC fixed blade is an Allen Blade MEUK. The blade is 4" long, I don't know what it is OAL. I love 4" for carry foxed and folders. With my fixed blade I "tuck" the tip of the sheath in my pocket (with my belt through the loop too.) This makes is a more discreet carry. For EDC fixes (read urbanite), I probably wouldn't go over a 5" blade, but that is just my guess. I am sure happy with this 4" fixed blade.
 
Brian,

Picking a EDC is more of a personal preferance than a poll. I work in a office, so I carry a slip joint folder. I use to carry a 4 inch lockback but a few customers raised thier eyebrows when I whipped it out. So now I am a little more politically correct. ( god I hate that ) Now at my home when I am working on the back acreage I usually had a 5 to 6 inch fix blade edc... MY current knife is a Recon by cold steel. I also have a large generic kukri I use it to chop up sagebrush and what ever else gets in my way. The darn thing scares the hell out of me when I get to a-swinging. I used it once to wack off some legs on a chicken and it acutally cut my plastic cutting board in half. My family got a good laugh out of that.
I use to carry a kukri in the truck behind the seat, I dont carry it anymore. I hear that the friendly blues can get me for a concealed weapon if I get stopped and searched.
So, look around and shop hard, figure out what you can use and how you use it and then make your own decision.
Good Luck
Jack
 
A) blade length is 5.5" (will check OAL later)
B) blade length 10" (can't wait till my Panther arrives :) )
C) over 12"

My responses are based on "across the back" or spinal carry...clearly they would change if I had to consider IWB, shoulder holster or other options...

RL
 
My everyday fixed blade carry knives are either a Helle Nying or a Helle Polar. These Norwegian knives are razor sharp and hold a good edge. The triple laminated blades are right under 3 inches in length and do not look like weapons. Most people don't give them a second look, but when I do get comments, they're always "nice knife."

nying.jpg
polar.jpg
 
I have 2 Busse's in the car and I carry a 6" blade into the forest.
During the day, I'll have a neckknife with a 2" blade or a knife on my ankle with a 4" blade.
 
Any 4"-5" fixed blade is perfect size for concealability and defense, anything over is just too big and bulky. I carried my Cold Steel Kobun for many years, it comes with great kydex sheath and its very, very sharp. You can also look into the "Bandicoot" at www.swampratknifeworks.com both are great knives at a great price.
 
Bladeswinger
Do you carry a 4-5" fix blade knife to work every day ? Do you have it concealed or is it on a sheath on your hip ? I see in your profile you work at a bank. If you carry a fix blade, what is thier opinion on it ?
Jack
 
FB EDC for me is a Spyderco Perrin PE

This is my only FB of quality so, it's the only one I carry.

I like EDC FB to be 4 - 5 inches long. Anything more than that seems too big and is uncomfortable.

I wear it in the facotory sheath with the TEC-LOCK. I don't tuck in my shirt so, it always stays hidden yet accesable.
 
When I carry a fixed blade it is one of my SOG Tridents (6&1/4 inch blade), carried IWB, in an "On/Scene Tactical" sheath.
 
I tend to run on the small side. I don't carry a fixed blade of more than 3 1/4" in public. I like to carry my fixed blades in sheaths that sit in my front pocket.
 
My experience with fixed blades is even more modest than that with folders ( I carry a special interest for folder as they seem more carry-able to me, but I also think that a fixed blade is stronger an can withstand more hostile influences, but what is the use of all that if you can't enjoy it because your fixed blades ages quietly on some shelve...

Nevertheless, my favorite fixed one is the Cold Steel Black Bear Classic in AUS-8A and with the extremely nice subhilt for added control. I realize that AUS-8A really isn't that much of a fine steel type, but this blade is meant for fighting purposes and after a few seconds you have plenty of time to restore its condition if deemed necessary. Another important note is that the out-of-the-box sharpness is unacceptable, especially when Cold Steel promissed you quite the opposite. But with some effort, you obtain a double edged fighter that demands respect and is capable to be very lethal (that knife can really penetrate if you want it to, it is real easy to damage some vital bodypart. The balance lies somewhat on the handle, but is very light and can be used to maximise control. The hilts are really solid and should prevent to hurt your own fingers, they seem also up to safeguarding your knifehand from damage of a fierce counterattack with an edged object (yeah, sure it is not a match for a heavy battle axe but what it lacks in brute force, it makes up in maniability and possibility to make the blade do exactly what you want). The blade steel really is not that superb but still it takes a good edge to really tear apart your opponent *grin* after that you can take your time "sanitizing" the blade. A few good cuts is all it takes to make a good fighter, control is very important, the AUS-8A is rather cheap and still has all it takes, this benefits the affordability. The conclude I am not at all happy, because Cold Steel downright lied to me, the bastards violated my trust by not delivering a hair shaving sharp blade right out of the box, in all that is not that big a deal, the potential of the knife is not affected, but a manufacturer who defies my trust in a manner that obvious will fail me only once, although the BlackBear Classic really holds everything what I expected (it really is a fighter and a force to be reckoned with) I nevertheless feel cheated by Cold Steel. The factory edge might seem a detail that is easily fixed, for me they took my good trust and spat on it, there's no way of knowing how far they will go in cheating an honest customer. All and all I'm very satisfied with the black bear (beuatifull and up for it's actual purpose, that is damaging enemy tissue in a way the user wants it (if I need to answer agression in this way, it is rather likely I will aim to kill and the Black Bear sure seems up to that grim task. A manufacturer can only once violate my trust and that's why I'm through with Cold Steel, they won't ever cheat me again although in truth they delivered a fine knife that holds a large potential.

Hell hath no fury as a knife-lover scorned, Cold Steel, you can kiss my cash goodbye, this mistake of your side can be set right quite easily but there is no way of telling how they will cheat me next time. In the mean time, I cherish my BlackBear Classic, an awesome fixed blade I keep very close whenever I hear strange noises at home (my plan is to fake that I am deep asleep, so the burglar does not see me as a threat and does not prepare himself for counteraction. But if he has the audicity to come close enough and I sense deep hostile intententions then I will try to surprize him and aim to bury the entire lenght of my fighter in his thorax, I think that this would discourage him to undertake further hostile action *grin*. If you want a big, substantial fighter don't forget to investigate the Cold Steel Black Bear Classic, it DOES hold particular benefits and is more than capabale to take down anything human. The sheer sight of this knife will intimidate almost everyone :-) this is a welcome asset as I want to avoid forcefull use of my knife and I do not really have the urge to kill or injure anybody, but it good to know that you could actually perform this horrible task. I want to keep breathing, no matter what... However unlikely and even undesirabale that a fighter will once serve it's actual purpose, they often are really nice just to look at, this along with the notion that you can say you never needed it is more then enough I expect from a fighter. If you ever actually need it, there no reason at all to rejoice (but if you did not have the fighter things would really look bleak, I suppose, however awfull the results of implementing this weapon can be, I would praise myself fortunate if the fighter would safeguard my priceless physical integrity. Just imagine the value a lifesaver like that would gain, no amount of cash could release the profound emotions of the knife in question. However unlikely that a fighter will ever serve it's purpose (if an attacker menaces you with something like a shotgun, you'd better do anything he wants you to do and leave your fighter where it is... Maybe later fit conditions to use the knife, when the opponent really believes you pose no threat at all; will arise. One thing is for sure, if you do not have a fighter handy you are more vulnerable. A concealed knife won't provoke anybody but is right there if ever the opportunity AND the urgent need to use the fighter in a harsh way. One will have a hard time in trying to convince me that a fighter is useless. Off course, one should keep in mind that the only knife that is any good to you is the one you have direct acces to, sitting on a shelf at home it won't help you in any way, one should form the habit of keeping his blade, he prefers, handy for action. A lanyard can improve the availability of the knife, just fix the other side to your belt and even in the most awkward of situations you will be able to allow the knife serve it's purpose (that purpose does not always implies bleeding an adversary dry, there are plenty of other ways to make good use of a fine blade.

No... really... do I sound like a schoolteacher or not... If you are questioning my subjective views then please be so kind as to tell me why... I would be very gratefull, sooner or later everyone makes mistakes. And if you bring my history of screwing up into account it is plain and clear that I require fresh and origanal viewpoints and I really would profit of others experience. Yeah, however hard I try, I always seem to find a way to screw things up. my knife hobby is all about getting as near to perfection as I can, so any mistake does cost me too much. Please be my guide in the complicated, puzzling knife-universe :-)yout points of view would be highly appreciated. Thanks a lot, fellow knife lover.
 
I just recently picked up my first fixed blade with the intention of it being a edc, in certain situations. What I got was a 4" blade with an overall length of 8.5". This knife rides in a horizontal belt sheath, although I have given thought to getting the maker to make me a shoulder strap carry sheath. The knife has a long false edge(unsharpened), integral double hilt, and black micarta over a full tang handle. It is made by Bob Dozier and is his Tactical 6 model. I really like it so far.
 
I find that a fixed blade in the 5 inch range is the best for everyday normal cutting activities. In a standard belt sheath, it doesn't hike my pants up or suspend my right butt check above a seat in a chair. A 7 inch blade is the max but, it hangs lower, weighs more, and in general gets in the way more versus the 5 inch models which seem to disappear when not in use.

For what its worth, in years past, I sold a lot of 5 1/2 CRK One Piece knives to folks in the military who really loved them. Small enough to put in a boot but, big enough to get the job done. Sure, everyone would rather have a monster bowie but, the knife left at home does you no good in the Bush ;)

Blades that come to mind from my own use include a Newt Livesay Air Assualt, an AllenBlade forged 5 inch knife, and a Trace Rinaldi TTKK which has served extremely well. Sure I have bigger knives, more expensive knives, fancier knives but, the one I have with me in the field is the only one that really counts.
 
I'm a knifemaker and my EDC is one of my own. It has to be practical so I'll keep carrying it and it has to be nice because its the one I always have on me when people ask, "So can you show me what you make ?"

I like blades of between 3 and 4inches with a full-sized but slender handle of 4-1/2inches. My own is a mini-bowie styled straightback of 3-1/2inches, flat ground full height and fileworked across the spine. Differential heat treat of the O-1 carbon steel blade. The double guard is brass with a canvas micarta spacer and handle of Red Deer stag antler.

The sheath is a high ride scabbard with pythonskin overlay and a snap. I use a combination of leather and Kydex in a Hybrid construction. For quick on-off function I hand mould a Kydex paddle that slips over the belt and trousers to lock into place. The scabbard is designed to hold the knife securely even if the snap is released. The retention loop is actually nylon cord rather than a leather strap as with repeated use, the leather is the first thing to break. The Kydex keeps that sheath very flat and rigid. No Kydex actually touches the knife itself.

I think anything larger than 4inches starts getting a little large. It will also tend to dig into the chair when sitting down and can require contortionists skill to draw from a strong side rig. I am in the process of designing a shoulder rig system similar to the JSP styles for full sized bowies.

I used to carry one of my 8inch Bowie's but it became far too cumbersome to carry consistently. A smaller knife is less intimidating and does more jobs more easily, and is more comfortable to carry longer.
 
Living in the city very much limits my FB carry. I only carry them during the winter when accessing a folding knife with gloved hand is difficult. I'll carry a neck knife in my coat pocket, so the blade tends to be 3-1/2" or less. It also must be able to unsheath with a thumb push.
 
Folks, this is really great. I can't thank you enough. The answers you are providing are very insightful.

To be honest: I still can't believe the amount of 7 - 8 inch overall lengths being carried!

For myself, comfort is a must. I fail to see how a knife of this size can be carried comfortably.

I made a 6 inch dummy out of wood, using a shim, app. to the dimensions of the knife I want to have built.

Using Belt & Ankle carry: I'm having comfort problems.

I've thought about going to a neck knife......

But they tend to be very very small....

Brian
 
the naked truth seems to be that if you chose you lose and if you don't choose you lose ven more. What a cruel world this is and why keep being confronted with my own limitations (maybe what I am really looking for is not the ultimate knife but a real nice girlfriend that won't mock if I share my considderations *evil grin* A knife is easier to obtain and certainly lesser maintenance the a live girlfriend, so for the time being, huray to knives. *lol* Maybe I will manage to fill up the gaping void in my heart if I only put in enough steel *grin*
 
Back
Top