Forged in Fire

Joined
Jun 18, 2016
Messages
150
Just saw a commercial and thought of the many talented people here.

Has anyone here been on that show before? :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Weird this hasn't been answered yet. I really can't tell you names but if I'm pretty sure some BF makers have been on the show. I just saw a knife made by the master bladesmith judge for sale on the exchange.
 
Salem Straub, Craig Camerer, Travis Weurtz that I know of. Sure there are others though
 
There was a thread goin' on parallel with the shows where the guys who were members here would discuss the show's episode after it aired. I don't recall where it was but a general search on BFC for forged in fire should bring it right up.
 
I'll go on a search for it. I find the show pretty interesting although the closest I've come to making a knife was whittling a point on a stick lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
There's been like three master bladesmiths on there. Murray Carter was on there and lost. The Burt Foster episode was good. I forget the name of the black dude but his real life work is freaking superb. A couple other really good guys have been on there.

The show is a crapshoot and is as much a gamble as it is a showcase of talent.
 
I think the 'dude' you are talking about is JD Smith, an excellent bladesmith, got to meet him a few times at the Ashokan Seminar;

From the 2010 Ashokan Seminar he gave a lecture;

IMG_1331.jpg~original


IMG_1234.jpg~original


I don't have cable so I can't view past episodes of Forged in Fire :( seems you have to sign in with which ever provider for your cable you have, wish I could have seen that episode there as well as the one with Burt Foster, also an excellent bladesmith!

G2

edited to add, the Ashokan Seminar this year focuses on Swords! see more about it at this thread here
 
From the few episodes I am able to view off of the History website, I think the show AND the Bladesmiths would both be better served if EACH stage of the first two stages were made as an 8 hour day and not crammed into those very short time confines. It just isn't the right time frame, to break the first two stages down into a day each would seem far more reasonable and the bladesmiths would be able to give the time and thought needed, and even at a day that is a lot to do, but I bet we would see far better offerings from the contestants. They can still film it for an hour time slot, they would just need to be selective in their cuts, but it would provide them ALSO a LOT more opportunity to film what the bladesmiths are doing and some thought process behind their choices, not just a mad dash to throw something onto the table, it is a poor way to represent the many many hours with hammer and steel that they have spent years perfecting their craft, into what they are forced to do.

Just my thoughts, but, I think the Show, Contestants and the Public would all be better served if they allowed just a little more time on the first two stages of the competition.

G2
 
Last edited:
I have to agree, the first part of the show is rushed and when the contestants are given the time in their shop to compete in the finals it gets far more interesting as they can go into greater detail about their work.
 
Back
Top