Just got the Lansky a couple of days before the BK14, so it was my first try - why it turned out better, I'd guess the finer grain structure of simple carbon steel compared to stainless. The carbides in stainless steel helps with abrasion resistance, but also make the steel harder to sharpen. Compared to 440C, 1095 is easier to sharpen but doesn't hold an edge as long.
@arizonaman: Thats pretty much what I did, only the ultra-fine stone on the Lansky IS the strop. The knife comes with a 15° angle stock, I only used 17,5 because the Lansky doesn't have a 15° slot. I can use a whetstone quite ok, but the Lansky helps me keep an angle. Try the Lansky, it's not that expensive, and I've had good results with it.
After using it a couple of days, I actually put a 20° microbevel on it, helps with edge retention. Also I ordered a Kydex sheath, tbh the stock sheath sucks