Getting a dog Doberman vs. Boxer. Advice?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ironman -

I commend you for reading and evaluating before buying a dog :thumbup: I did so myself, before finally getting my Newfoundland. I took 3.5 years to find the dog I wanted, but he was well worth it. Of course, it may not take that long for you :o

Here is an interesting dichotomy that I've found in different dog breeds: the large dog breeds, such as Boxers, Dobermans, Golden Retrievers, and German Shepherds, are high energy animals who need exercise and room to roam (a typical suburban yard is fine, with walks and outings). The giant dog breeds, though, have less energy and, in fact, don't need as much yard to be happy. They do need exercise, of course, but they aren't as wound-up as the large dogs. By giant breeds, I mean dogs like Bull Mastiffs, English Mastiffs, French Mastiffs, Newfoundlands, St. Bernards, etc. Basically, any breed whose males average 130 pounds +.

I don't know exactly what qualities you are looking for, but another dog to consider is a Great Pyrenees. They are wonderful with kids, very protective without being unduly aggressive, and beautiful to boot. They aren't terribly playful, though; their modus operandi is to wander with their "pack", laying at a distance and guarding from all predators. From what I've seen and read, Pyrs have great discernment concerning children. Pyrs can tell that kids is kids, whether part of the family or not, and can distinguish between youth and adult.

Here's a good dog breed selector that will give you good info on numerous breeds as well as open your eyes to options you may not have considered:
http://animal.discovery.com/breedselector/dogselector.do
Their info is decently reliable, too, from what I've seen.
 
Well, Sunday afternoon the family decided to drop by the local Castaway Animal Rescue Effort (CARE) place and "just look" at the dogs. There were many different kinds. There was even a Boxer, a white one. But as they say, you will know the right one, or it will know you. We came upon two Miniature
Doberman Pinschers, and every single member of the family agreed immediately. There was a male and a female. We brought the bitch home:) Later that day, we talked to my wifes Dad. Turns out he was really looking for a mini Pin too. He went the next day and took the male home. So, now the brother and sister will still get to visit each other. They have been together all thier life. We named the girl Bella Star. She is not really an attack dog, well, you might be surprised! But, she is a real good watch dog. Housebroken, excellent with kids and cat. Calm, yet willing to play. Already spayed with shots too. Needless to say I am very happy with her. A big THANK YOU to everyone who replied to this thread!
 
I'be been around both breads (boxers and a dobbie). My mother's got 100 lbs + dobbie that is great dog, he is around strangers all the time and does nothing, not aggressive just trys to beg. He is around my wife's four Chihuahuas (not my fault!) does not try to eat them, they just run around his legs. No issue with other dogs or people.

Most recent boxer I've been around is a bit of a goof and one fast dog but very nice and freindly.

Patrick
 
Ask the breeder about hip and vision problems in both dogs. I agree that Dobes can be a little snappy, but that might just be the few that I have known. My co-pilot is a pit bull mix and I am firm believer that solid training and constant reinforcement do outweigh natural tendencies.
 
We came upon two Miniature
Doberman Pinschers, and every single member of the family agreed immediately.
Miniature Pinschers are cool little dogs . . . they look very much like a Dobie, but are just a little bigger than the average lapdog. Very well behaved dogs (generally), and non-threatening to folks who'd flip out over a Doberman.

They make outstanding watchdogs. After all, a watchdog's primary function is simply to alert the household when there is an intruder. Unlike other small dogs, they are not "yappy" and are typically rather quiet, so when they bark you know something's up.

Good choice! Give the puppy a few slices of Carl Buddig sliced beef -- they love that stuff!
 
Well, Sunday afternoon the family decided to drop by the local Castaway Animal Rescue Effort (CARE) place and "just look" at the dogs. There were many different kinds. There was even a Boxer, a white one. But as they say, you will know the right one, or it will know you. We came upon two Miniature
Doberman Pinschers, and every single member of the family agreed immediately. There was a male and a female. We brought the bitch home:) Later that day, we talked to my wifes Dad. Turns out he was really looking for a mini Pin too. He went the next day and took the male home. So, now the brother and sister will still get to visit each other. They have been together all thier life. We named the girl Bella Star. She is not really an attack dog, well, you might be surprised! But, she is a real good watch dog. Housebroken, excellent with kids and cat. Calm, yet willing to play. Already spayed with shots too. Needless to say I am very happy with her. A big THANK YOU to everyone who replied to this thread!


Sounds like you found a great dog, Ironman - congratulations on the new additions to your family.
 
I'm obviously late to the party, but I have 2 boxers, and they are great dogs.

for the unbiased truth about them, you can check out this for some light reading:

http://www.flbr.org/boxers.html

great dogs, but not exactly low impact. I wouldn't trade 'em, though.
 
Good choice! Give the puppy a few slices of Carl Buddig sliced beef -- they love that stuff!

NO! Bad Tyr... not a good idea unless you LIKE pancreatitis. I've seen my share of pancreatitis in min-pins, they can be prone to it.
The Min-pin is not derived from the Doberman, rather they are a terrier breed. They do tend to be good watchdogs, but I'll disagree on their yappiness, my neighbor's min-pin was (RIP) rather yappy. It's been kinda quiet since his demise.

congrats on your family's dual adoption!
 
NO! Bad Tyr... not a good idea unless you LIKE pancreatitis. I've seen my share of pancreatitis in min-pins, they can be prone to it.
I am terribly sorry . . . I had no idea the breed was succeptable to pancreatitis. My full-sized Rottweiller and rescued Dobie-Shepard loved the Carl Buddig (and lamb chops, pizza, cheeseburgers, 10-ingredient lo mein :D ). They were occasional treats, and they never experienced any ill effects. What I would strongly advise you against is canned dog food. Many canned foods are very bad for dogs, as QC is virtually non-existant. I'd generally feed Purina ONE Lamb & Rice kibble mixed with cooked ground turkey.

Mongo said:
They do tend to be good watchdogs, but I'll disagree on their yappiness, my neighbor's min-pin was (RIP) rather yappy. It's been kinda quiet since his demise.
I only knew one fellow who had a Miniature Pincher. Dog never barked . . . unless you got to close to his dune buggy. Fellow would drive around town in his open top VW kit car, and the dog would just sit in the seat and wait for him when he went in places. Never hopped around like a spaz, never jumped out to chase a squirrel . . . very well behaved dog.

Of course, the dog has to recieve some training . . . most housepets only learn "sit" and "don't crap in the house." :rolleyes:
 
NO! Bad Tyr... not a good idea unless you LIKE pancreatitis. I've seen my share of pancreatitis in min-pins, they can be prone to it.
Pancreatitis is not a good thing and in case you are wondering, dogs or people can die from it. Trust me on this, I spent two and a half weeks in ICU because of non alcholic pancreatitis.
 
Congratulations on the new addition to the pack Ironman. You did a good deed and got a great companion.

For anyone else considering getting a dog check out www.petfinder.com .

A great resource for finding dogs in need of rescue. I found my current dog, an Akita mix, through this website. I can't speak highly enough of my new pup or the website.
 
I had a white Boxer for 14 years, we took good care of her and she lived happy a long time. I've had several other dogs over the years, but the Boxer outshined them all. SHe was loyal and extremely smart, overly gentle and playful with kids and a great watchdog. Her only fault was that she hated all other dogs and went after any that came close
 
thing to remember in all breeds of dogs is each dog can vary a lot. i've seen dobies that where very aggressive toward people they didn't know and others that where fine. boxers can be great but i know of one thats pretty bad about wanting to bite anyone he doesn't know. same with pit bulls i've owned some that will lick anybodies face, the one i own now wants to go after any stanger that comes in the yard. (i live out away from people so other than keeping her home its not a problem.) why shes like that i have no idea. take her out in public shes fine but home shes very protective. you can't really say a dobie or boxer or any other breed of dog thats prone and able to be aggressive will or won't be. you can raise it and help make it less likely to be but a lot depends on the individual dog.
 
And the OP's dog is now 12 years old...But it's good you could help them decide...
 
Boxador, boxers good legs (less hip dysplasia), Labradors longer muzzle (improved breathing), & more stable temperament.
BoxadorBoxerLabradorRetrieverMIxBreedDogNimble1Year5MonthsOld3.jpg
 
Spammer woke up a 13 year old thread to post his spam link.
He and his link have been removed.
Closing this thread, the original question having long ago been answered.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top