First, a quick story. This weekend I'm over a friend's house, where he is cutting out a small notch for a screw head in a strip of wood cabinet trim. The tools he's using? A tiny drill bit and a steak knife! Why? "My Dad had the router"
(Mind you, this guy has every hand & power tool known to man, but no pocketknife). First he was drilling it like a dentist would drill out a filling, and then using the steak knife (holding it partly by the blade of course, for leverage) to scrape the edges out. I decided - he needs a pocketknife.
In addition, I meet regularly with this guy and a few others for a men's breakfast/bible study. None of them carry a knife of any sort, and I think now would be a perfect time to get them all a little something for Christmas.
Here's the question: Given that the cost would be about the same, should I get them a tiny lockback (MiniBuck, Gerber LST type) or the tiny SAK (with blade, scissors, nail file)? I'm leaning towards the lockback, because I dislike non-locking blades, and I think a sturdy locking blade is more useful than a flimsy blade, scissor, and nailfile. Keep in mind, it would be a accomplishment if these guys start to carry anythying - there's no way they'd carry anything bigger.

In addition, I meet regularly with this guy and a few others for a men's breakfast/bible study. None of them carry a knife of any sort, and I think now would be a perfect time to get them all a little something for Christmas.
Here's the question: Given that the cost would be about the same, should I get them a tiny lockback (MiniBuck, Gerber LST type) or the tiny SAK (with blade, scissors, nail file)? I'm leaning towards the lockback, because I dislike non-locking blades, and I think a sturdy locking blade is more useful than a flimsy blade, scissor, and nailfile. Keep in mind, it would be a accomplishment if these guys start to carry anythying - there's no way they'd carry anything bigger.