Good, Cheap Survival Knife

I picked up a few Mora's for $15 each and couldn't be any more delighted. Does everything I expected it to do. And when people show up in the wild and their knife (which costs more) doesn't perform as advertised I thrown them one of the Mora's and tell them to keep it. They do!

Granted I don't use the Mora as a splitting maul, I use an ax for splitting.

My thought is I'd rather have a spare or two of one good knife so if something happens I'm not left out in the cold. Also it is good to have more than one to give them away.
 
I'd echo azamie10 with the Fallkniven F1 if you want a survival knife.

It's already a bit of a legend as far as survival / utility designs go as opposed to survival choppers. Both the design and the materials are outstanding for real world use. Although it is a bit thick and strong [the survival aspect] it cuts very well. It's extremely unlikely that you'd break it and it is very low maintenance. I never got so much as a speck of rust on mine and I expect survival / utility patterns to be semi-amphibious and I am very intolerant of those that can't perform in blood, juice, sap, rain, river blah blah without needing their diaper changed. In fact, look them up, they always come immaculate and they tend to staying that way. QA / QC of that caliber is far more interesting to me than “if we sell you a crap one we'll make it good”. It's got a nice basic handle that allows you to get up close to the business end for fine work but done in a way that still allows you to put plenty of power into a cut. Have a careful look at the leftmost one below, that's it.

kf20100311192258.jpg


To be fair I did let mine go but that's not 'cos I don't think it is an awesome knife. I let it go because I moved away from the survival thing and more towards utility. That's mainly because when I also have an ax or golok I don't really require such strength or toughness in my knife and I could move to something much thinner and with a handle I really love. None of that does anything to negate the well deserved status of the F1. I've seen them at $102 in the US so perhaps a better search would find them even cheaper. A couple of threads here recently have found some very happy buyers turning on to the F1. Superb value. Who knows, in years to come you may pimp the handle out with tortoise shell and abalone to create an heirloom. The blade is certainly of sufficiently high quality to take it.


That said, as you mentioned light weight being nice for hiking I think it must be worth flagging up a Lone Wolf Trailmate. It could be that you are on a similar page to me in that a good utility knife that does a wide range of stuff but is compact and always on you is a survival knife too. Especially so when it is often backed up by some dedicated chopper. The Trailmate is a design by Steve Kelly A.B.S J.S and owner of the Knife Dogs forum. I've seen those here in 154CM and G10 for £105 GBP so I'd expect it to be much less than that on the home market $. You can read up on the genesis of the Lone Wolf version here.

20100412132036v.jpg


Seems like great value in a light and compact knife for hiking that'll do the survival stuff to me with 154 CM around the ton mark. Needs more research though 'cos I've never used one.
 
Any other suggestions?

I would put Moras at the TOP of your list. Don't let the low cost fool you. They are fantastic knives.

You may want to look at the Becker like of Ka-Bar knives, as well as other Ka-Bar designs.

Everyone loves ESEE knives, and they are reasonably priced.
 
I'd get a Condor Rodan, Cold Steel GI Tanto, Becker BK7 or BK9 for a beater,and a Mora or Cold Steel Finn Bear, Condor Bushlore/Bushcraft/Nessmuk, R Murphy Canadian Belt Knife, something like that for a slicer. If you're looking for just a companion knife, check out Helle Knives and the ROSARMS Fry 2-I'm drooling over them right now.
 
If you don't own a Bark River yet, and are on o budget, maybe you shouldn't consider it because you won't stop at one. :D
If you think you may, look at the fox river, aurora or the barvo1, probably the 3 most popular.
A great and underrated survival knife is the cold steel bushman, you can get one for 20-25 bucks, and it will be indestructible. Spend the rest of the money on some other survival goodies, or a sak farmer or one hand trekker.
 
The Beckers look like interesting knives. How would the bk9 perform in the role suggested? Is it too big? Or the 7?
The cold steel GI Tanto looks nice, and is definitely in my budget. How does it perform?
How about the CS true flight thrower? I know its a 'thrower', but would it work? It seems like a no-nonsense, simple, affordable blade...
Seems like everyone likes moras! Might as well pick them up, at there price point...
Any other suggestions?
 
Also, maybe this is really obvious, but what does a knife like the mora have over a well made folder, other than price?
 
The Beckers look like interesting knives. How would the bk9 perform in the role suggested? Is it too big? Or the 7?
The cold steel GI Tanto looks nice, and is definitely in my budget. How does it perform?
How about the CS true flight thrower? I know its a 'thrower', but would it work? It seems like a no-nonsense, simple, affordable blade...
Seems like everyone likes moras! Might as well pick them up, at there price point...
Any other suggestions?

I used to have a true flight thrower that I pimped into a survival knife(sold it.)
It was not the greatest idea, as it gave me hots spots and wasn't a very good slicer even though I convexed it. I just bought an SRK ( aus-8a) to compliment my carbon V one. Great knife for under 100 bucks. I haven't seen any major failures with that knife, and the steel ( made by Aishi steel in Japan, I believe) is pretty good all around. Ease of sharpening, edge holding, corrosion resistance.) If you can spend a little more and like a smaller blade than that, I highly recommend the F1 Fallkniven like others do. Moras are OK for back-up knives as far as I'm concerned , but I would not use one as my main blade. You are seriously considering a survival knife ; let your needs decide and money second. Saving a few bucks won't help you when you're SOL in the bush.

Other options:

BK-2 Becker
Cold steel Pendleton hunter
Any ESEE's
SOG Seal pup elite
 
I heard the sog seal pup a couple of times...
I really like the design, and sog seams to have a good rep. What about the larger version seal team elite? How does it stack up?
 
Theres the SRK again!
I'm just wondering, what does it really have over the sp2? Blade shape?
The bushmans an interesting alternative, I have the Pocket Bush, and really like it, so that might be an option...
 
I heard the sog seal pup a couple of times...
I really like the design, and sog seams to have a good rep. What about the larger version seal team elite? How does it stack up?

Actually they don't seem to have a very good rep these days. Seal team knives are more of a tactical knife, not woods knives. If your O.K. waiting, order one of the JK's, a full tang custom for that price is an amazing deal. If you can upgrade to G-10 for only a few more bucks I would definitely recommend doing it. If $100 is pushing it as far as what you want to spend and you don't want to wait, go for a AUS8 SRK. It's a great knife for the money and even if you move on to other knives eventually you won't regret having picked up the SRK. I would also recommend stripping it. Having a coated AUS8 blade is stupid unless you really are in a tactical situation.
 
Drop another $ 10.00, pushing up to $ 110.00 and consider a Blind Horse Knives Bushcrafter. I really like mine and it has been USED! Since you will have a hawk with you, the BHK will excel at cutting as designed. Also a Buck 105 might be an option. Good luck.
 
I used to have a true flight thrower that I pimped into a survival knife(sold it.)
It was not the greatest idea, as it gave me hots spots and wasn't a very good slicer even though I convexed it. I just bought an SRK ( aus-8a) to compliment my carbon V one. Great knife for under 100 bucks. I haven't seen any major failures with that knife, and the steel ( made by Aishi steel in Japan, I believe) is pretty good all around. Ease of sharpening, edge holding, corrosion resistance.) If you can spend a little more and like a smaller blade than that, I highly recommend the F1 Fallkniven like others do. Moras are OK for back-up knives as far as I'm concerned , but I would not use one as my main blade. You are seriously considering a survival knife ; let your needs decide and money second. Saving a few bucks won't help you when you're SOL in the bush.

Other options:

BK-2 Becker
Cold steel Pendleton hunter
Any ESEE's
SOG Seal pup elite



Yessir ,

Mora's are great in their own right , buy a few to keep around , they make wonderful 'anything' knives and can be replaced easily , the carbon are great but if you dont want to fiddle with keeping rust off your blades go for stainless.

I recommend the Fallkniven S1 , as good as the F1 just a little different configuration. You are getting awesome stainless and a proven design , a knife you could strap on and go swimming with if you wanted , try that with a carbon blade and your in for trouble , especially in a survival situation , IMO.

Baldtaco II what is the third knife from the left in your pic ? I like the looks of it !

Tostig
 
Originally posted by ctg1231
Theres the SRK again!
I'm just wondering, what does it really have over the sp2? Blade shape?
The bushmans an interesting alternative, I have the Pocket Bush, and really like it, so that might be an option...
Reply With Quote

Although both have similar capabilities, the SRK blade geometry and grind makes it a better slicer, chopper and gives it a stronger point. Let's put it this way, the sp2 is combat knife designed with survival situations in mind (saber grind, curved clip point, about 2 inches-long distal taper). The SRK is a survival knife designed with rescue operations in mind (high flat grind, straight clip point, 2-stage taper).

If you like the Pocket Bushman, you are going to love the Bushman. Since it isn't as thick as other blades, at first I thought wouldn't handle some tough chores. Being inexpensive, I decided to put it through the numbers, and it performed every task with flying colors. If you go with the Bushman, carry with it some eyescrews. They make it easier to secure a branch or stick into the hollow handle to use the Bushman as a hatchet, machete or spear.
 
Back
Top