Good fixed blade for camping?

There are so many good options out there for a camp knife. However, one that tends to get overlooked is the USMC Ka-Bar. I have carried one with me for a LONG time and I can say, without a doubt, it's worth a mention. I have literally beat mine into the ground, much farther then I push most knives and it has never once let me down. If nothing else you may want to consider it.
 
I would take anything off the Scrapyard knives website.

Any Bussekin knife will outperform any other factory made blade, but I also prefer the Resiprene handles on Scrapyard knives.
 
I would take anything off the Scrapyard knives website.

Any Bussekin knife will outperform any other factory made blade, but I also prefer the Resiprene handles on Scrapyard knives.

Wow! That's quite a blanket statement. In my experience Bark Rivers/Blackjacks will out - cut just about anything right out of the box. Since knives are first and foremost cutting tools, this is my primary focus of a knife's "performance".

Having said that, has Busse worked out his blade coatings so they do not drag when slicing? The coatings are my primary reason for staying away from his work, because I have never used a coated blade that did not seriously inhibit a blade's slicing potential. If he has figured it out, please let me know. I'm all ready to give them a try....
 
attachment.php
attachment.php
Esee 3 is a great knife
 

Attachments

  • 2014-04-24_18-06-46_491(1).jpg
    2014-04-24_18-06-46_491(1).jpg
    65.9 KB · Views: 26
Man, yall got me all worked up thinking about camp knives, now I've got one of these coming in the mail:

bn2_red_g10__61013.1389138273.1280.1280.jpg


Thanks a lot!
No seriously, thank you guys. I've been curious about BRKs for a while now.
This thing is gonna pair up nicely with my GSO-10.
I'm calling it "The Summer of CPM-3V" :D
 
Man, yall got me all worked up thinking about camp knives, now I've got one of these coming in the mail:

bn2_red_g10__61013.1389138273.1280.1280.jpg


Thanks a lot!
No seriously, thank you guys. I've been curious about BRKs for a while now.
This thing is gonna pair up nicely with my GSO-10.
I'm calling it "The Summer of CPM-3V" :D

I'm strongly leaning towards the Bravo 1 in CPM-3V. I love the fact that I can choose the blade style, handle color and material, and blade steal. And from everything I've heard, the quality is outstanding. It's versatile too which is what I want. It can be used in a wide variety of situations.
 
Get a Mora and save 90% of the funds. It'll do what you need while camping.
Maybe so for the smaller tasks. I don't think it can compete with a GSO-10... :P
Maybe one day I will try a Mora, but they don't fulfill that "second type of cool" for me.
 
I prefer the ESEE Laser Strike over the 4 or 5. I'm happy with an ESEE 3 until I need harvesting utility. At that point, I'm looking for light chopping or light batoning, and I want good heft and strength, so I'd go to the Laser Strike until I need to get all the way into a dedicated chopper or saw.
 
What do you guys think of the new upcoming ZT 0180 fixed blade? It's based off of Rick Hinderer's Fieldtac which I am not too familiar with but apparently it is an excellent hard use knife. From what I have read, it's considered an all purpose knife but with a stronger emphasis on "tactical" applications. I'm no newbie when it comes to knives but to be honest, I've never quite fully understood what "tactical" means. I've always just assumed military and law enforcement use. But the new ZT 0180 is a smaller version with some minor tweaks and changes to appeal to wider range of customers. It uses Vanadis 4 Extra for the blade steel and the general consensus seems to suggest its good stuff. It comes with a really nice sheath too. I find the ZT 0180 very intriguing and I'm wondering if it would make a suitable camp knife? My usage would include cutting rope, cutting down small branches, prepping kindling, making marshmallow roasters for my wife and daughter, and other typical camp shores. I'm just looking at all my options. Like I said, I strongly value the opinions and suggestions of the members here and any input is always helpful to me.
 
What do you guys think of the new upcoming ZT 0180 fixed blade? It's based off of Rick Hinderer's Fieldtac which I am not too familiar with but apparently it is an excellent hard use knife. From what I have read, it's considered an all purpose knife but with a stronger emphasis on "tactical" applications. I'm no newbie when it comes to knives but to be honest, I've never quite fully understood what "tactical" means. I've always just assumed military and law enforcement use. But the new ZT 0180 is a smaller version with some minor tweaks and changes to appeal to wider range of customers. It uses Vanadis 4 Extra for the blade steel and the general consensus seems to suggest its good stuff. It comes with a really nice sheath too. I find the ZT 0180 very intriguing and I'm wondering if it would make a suitable camp knife? My usage would include cutting rope, cutting down small branches, prepping kindling, making marshmallow roasters for my wife and daughter, and other typical camp shores. I'm just looking at all my options. Like I said, I strongly value the opinions and suggestions of the members here and any input is always helpful to me.

I've had great success with ZT's in Elmax. However, I've been around the block enough times to know that you never really know how a given piece of equipment will perform until you go out and use it.

I'll also add that I've seen all sorts of super duper new rifles, pistols, optics and knives hit the market that look like a whole new level of performance, only to find that they suck in reality. My policy now is to pretty much wait when something new is in the pipeline until enough other people spend their money on it to determine if it's worth spending my money on trying one out. Once it has enough good reviews to suit me, then I'll spend my cash on one and then wring it out really, really well before deciding to keep it. I've done that with the Bravo 1, TOPS BOB and TOPS Dragonfly 4.5 and have had excellent results with them all, but the Bravo is clearly "on top" :D.

Also, keep in mind that we knife geeks tend to get really wrapped up in the minutia. I live way out in the boonies of East Tennessee and there are folks here who use something like a Case Sodbuster to do everything from whittling down at the old country store with the other geezers, to dressing out deer and hogs. These guys live in the woods, and would not know the difference between a "survival" knife, a "tactical" knife, a "Bushcrafter" or a drop point skinner. They would, however, be able to go out in the woods and live as long as they wanted to and/or bring home a deer or turkey at will.

As someone previously stated, our ancestors used sharp rocks for full time "camping and survival"......Pick a decent knife that you like and then go out in the woods and use it - skills are way more important than toys. I am not saying this to be in any way disrespectful at all, but to just keep things in focus. I know that sometimes I spend so much time and effort on some minute point, that I drive myself (and those around me) to a point of frustration.

In other words, just buy a decent knife and go have some fun!
 
Sykco 1111 paired with a opinel nr10 or 12! Sr-101 has the advantage over 3v in edge stability, edge retention, lateral strength and toughness. Compaired my 911 to my fehrman EJ - in normal use you can't really see the difference but when impacting hard objects the advantage went to sr-101.
 
I'll also recommend buying a Mora, but I'll add that I prefer the slightly thicker blades (0.126") over the thinner blades (0.080). In hand they don't feel THICK ... its just that they don't feel thin. Sigh ... this is why I'm not a Pulitzer prize winning author.

I like both their carbon and stainless steel blades. The carbon blades do seem to get a tad sharper, but they both sharpen nicely.

When I was a kid in a college botany class (maybe 1979 ish) I was told that I needed a knife to dig plants out of the ground. I didn't want to destroy my Buck folder, so I stopped by the local PAMIDA (like a small Walmart) and bought the only low cost fixed blade knife they had. I used it to dig plants out all summer without any real damage. That fall I was kind of surprised to at how well it sharpened back up. Over the years that cheap knife with the molded black plastic handle and the weird looking plastic tube sheath became my favorite go-to knife. Tough. Sharp. Cheap enough that if lost I wouldn't worry about it. It wasn't until maybe 20 years later that I realized that it was a MORA knife. Great knife!! Still have it.
 
I view Moras much like I view the inexpensive Victorinox kitchen knives that I have many of. They work great, but Moras are simply not the knife I want to carry unless that is all I can afford OR I am digging out plants with it. These days I would choose a Condor Bushlore forthe plant digging purpose. I have a couple Moras. Absolutely nothing wrong with Mora's in general. They just don't fit into my concept of "style". Those plastic handles and sheaths just don't do it for me. The Bark River knives in general hit the mark pretty well; cost, style, function. The Kabar Beckers work for me too and I consider them to be pretty affordable/cost effective relative to what you get. But on the Beckers, I wish they were not coated.

As stated above... "Buy a decent knife and go have some fun!"
 
Esee will take an insane edge. Easy to sharpen. Other than that, Bark river has pleasd me with both their 3v and a2 offerings.
 
Back
Top