Good GEC all-rounder for dipping a toe into carbon steel traditionals? (Found!)

Hi Dadpool!.
The Bullnose is a great everyday knife. The blade gets most of the action so the liners get just a little "contamination". Just have to remember to rinse occasionally. When done get a q-tip in there after washing. Mine has minimal patina. I like coconut oil. large jar for cheap. and don't worry of getting rancid if its a user.

Do you currently have any knife with 1095? It might be good to taste that "food reaction" flavor. Some hate it, some tolerate it, some don't notice it at all and some don't care ( me)


72,73,74 ...I like the 72 clip among them ( I have a Mustang)

The 35 HJ ( 2016 forum knife) would a nice one, although a spear , it is longer than a 77, but much harder to find and will be at an upcharge.

Would you consider a #98 ?" There are a few around still, whittler or cattle knife. it is large at oal around 4 3/4, not easy to carry around, but if its at camp or the kitchen, no problem. I have the camp knife...long gone or over expensive. Its GEC and rare! I don't use it.
I did though get a Remington UMC, R4243. which is Stainless. They don't go for too much right now. But you can check out that size! It fits in a Buck 110 case well.


Finally, how about a fixed blade? GEC recently and I think may still be in the process of releasing a few fixed blades in 1095. I keep two H10's one SS and one 1095, a couple H50's one SS other 1095 , and a 1095 H73 in my steak knife set. The stainless ones double as petty knives. Teh H10's has a great little sheath and used often on hikes.
 
Last edited:
The current Bullnose are great for all around knives in 1095. Can't go wrong, and not a huge expense.
 
Another for the bullnose. If I had to pick only one pocket knife for all my cutting needs, it would probably be a sodbuster. 48 would be a good choice too. There's an upcoming run of northwoods on this frame . I hope GEC does their own run as well
 
I like Sodbusters, and a drop point blade would be fine. With the Bullnose it's the liners that give me pause. And maybe they shouldn't, I don't know.



It does seem like a good "food blade." I have a Mustang, and the blades look pretty similar to me. I should take a harder look at the #42s.

Thank you both!

Sorry, didn't realize you had the 74. Then a 42 or even a 23 would be the way to go, I think. Even a one of the 98s that are still out there--they are the "cattle knife" variant. They have a big clip--nearly 4" I believe.
 
You've all convinced me to set aside the smaller patterns on my initial list, and to look at larger blades. I'm going to start looking for a 77, 23, 42, 71, or 99 that strikes me.

Thank you very much to everyone who contributed to this thread! I appreciate all of your thoughts and suggestions. :)
 
before completely setting small patterns aside, consider a two blade 14 while they are still available. It is a great little knife. Maybe not food friendly, but very practical, pocket friendly, and perfect compliment to another larger traditional or modern folder.
 
Dont forget the #21 BullBuster its great for food and is comfortable in back pocket.
 
GEC Farmer Lock #99 might fit the bill...
00809d3d8c99b11775378edda61839d6.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
before completely setting small patterns aside, consider a two blade 14 while they are still available. It is a great little knife. Maybe not food friendly, but very practical, pocket friendly, and perfect compliment to another larger traditional or modern folder.

If I try and like having a knife with a patina, I'll definitely explore other patterns, including smaller ones. I enjoy my stainless traditionals in a variety of sizes, and it would be neat to be able to enjoy some carbon steel models I can't get in stainless.

Dont forget the #21 BullBuster its great for food and is comfortable in back pocket.

Huh, a larger Bullnose. Neat! I'll add that to the list.
 
Dadpool-hey! Long time , no see post! Whatever that means. :D I do use my farm&afield 99 for food, at least cutting up hotdogs and such for my 2 year old. He doesn't seem to notice anything wrong with the flavor, but he's a , hmm, stout eater? He's not fat, more built like a climbing linebacker. Hey you need to post up in the books and blades thread-you've got some of the best!
Thanks, Neal
 
Dadpool-hey! Long time , no see post! Whatever that means. :D I do use my farm&afield 99 for food, at least cutting up hotdogs and such for my 2 year old. He doesn't seem to notice anything wrong with the flavor, but he's a , hmm, stout eater? He's not fat, more built like a climbing linebacker. Hey you need to post up in the books and blades thread-you've got some of the best!
Thanks, Neal

I haven't bought a knife in 6 months, and my last one -- my current EDC -- is a modern folder, so I've lurked a bit but haven't felt like I could add much. But I've missed the Porch! I need to start posting here again.

I looked at the blades-on-books thread (which is excellent), but I thought my photos would be an odd fit because I tend to crop out most of the cover to focus on the knife.
 
GEC Farmer Lock #99 might fit the bill...

Neat! I've never seen those before, and it does indeed look like a dandy option.

Dadpool I just sent you a PM my friend.

Thank you very much for your offer!

For other folks reading this (and without airing anything private), bloody_pawprint did something totally exemplary of why the Porch is such a great place. :thumbup:
 
Neat! I've never seen those before, and it does indeed look like a dandy option.



Thank you very much for your offer!

For other folks reading this (and without airing anything private), bloody_pawprint did something totally exemplary of why the Porch is such a great place. :thumbup:

Well, haven't been much of a poster around here, but definitely a long time lurker. You guys are a bunch of GREAT guys, and I've always been fond of reading the stories and conversations. Lot of good knowledge, and good experiences around here. It was the least I could do [emoji4]
 
No one has mentioned the #92? I cut a few steaks with mine.

 
I was fortunate to acquire a 77 Barlow, and, after wiping off the factory oil and snapping a few photos, I immediately put it to use in the kitchen. :D

Sorry about the terrible lighting. I had great light when the knife arrived, and none when I made my snack.

hAxpESx.jpg

lkNwcFy.jpg


Many thanks to everyone who suggested patterns and offered ideas about how to make my foray into carbon-steel traditionals a successful one! :thumbup: If I like carbon steel, I see more GECs in my future.
 
The #23 would be a good choice. You can still find some of the Schrade Fire & Steel versions around which were made by GEC.

Some of my favorites are the GEC #63, #64 & #65 patterns. The long, thin blades work very well for food prep with lots of handle to grip. They haven't been made in a while so may be tough to find new. However, these patterns never were very popular for some reason so some real deals can be had in the used market. I think I picked my last one up for <$60.

 
Abhhh, well your #77 Barlow should be a great slipjoint, congratulations!

I'm late to this party, but my sheepsfoot #15 was my do it all knife for one month. Part of a challenge on another forum. It was absolutely fun, did great, and definitely has more patina now.


A sandwich, and fixing dinner for the dog:








 
Back
Top