If you put the qualifier of little upkeep, the Alaskan Guide Vanguard is the better of the two stainless knives you are considering. The blade has a better grind with a better edge than the Benchmade. It will also hold an edge longer. The Benchmade will probably be easier to sharpen, though. If you do go with the Bark River, it is not stainless, but will resist corrosion better than normal carbon steels like 1095. Also, you can get a really good deal on Bark River knives from AG Russell, he has the Highland (4" blade) for $60, and the Woodland (3" blade) for $55. That is a really good deal, and either one would be a good choice. Plus, AG is great to deal with.