Actually, this thread makes me philosophic.
I think I've been dancing around the edge of this for a few years now. After my huge downsizing some years back, I've been getting on with fewer and fewer pocket knives in an ever downward spiral. I'm down to just under a half dozen now, and day to day, I don't use half of them. When I went on our 5 week road trip last fall, there I was roaming around the country with a peanut in my pocket and a classic on my keying, and I was perfectly happy. Making a conscious choice to leave my collection home, and just travel with my usual everyday choice, was far easier than I thought. The fact that I had a nice sharp knife in my pocket was all that mattered. Anything past that is excess gravy on the potatoes.
By midway on the trip or even less, I wasn't even missing my other knives much. I was too busy having fun galavanting all over Texas, New Mexico, California, and other points on our travels. When I needed a knife to open a package, or cut something, I had one. End of problem.
I wonder if most people, sooner or later come to the epiphany that mudguard came to, and I've been dancing on the edge of?
Even my three children did not inherit the knife knut gene in tow of the three cases. When I was having my downsize, I couldn't interest my older son and daughter in any of my knives. In both cases, they both were die hard SAK carriers. When I offered my yellow Case sodbuster to her, she answered, "Dad, I have my Swiss Army knife, what more do I need?" To this day, Jess is fanatic about having her larger SAK in her purse, and her pink classic on her keyring. My older boy John, travel's a lot, and is a SAK fan. Only my youngest, Matt, has a love of traditionals, and that is only for scout knives. He has my old boy scout knife that my dad gave me, and he carries it some, but has slowed down and now carries one of a couple of boy scout knives he's got of the big internet auction site. It's all he carries or wants. Camillus, Ulster, PAL, Imperial, all scout knives. No interest in any other pattern or even a SAK. He loves the old vintage stuff.
But…and this is the thing, none of then spend any time on knife forums. They know they need a knife, so they have one, and that's it. They are satisfied. They are not suffering from our affliction for the never ending search for the perfect one.
I don't now where I was going with this, just rambling. Now I have to polish and oil my precious five pocket knives that will serve me for the rest of my life.
Carl, Grand High Muckba, in search of contentment.