Originally posted by marty123
Also, fishbulb, you say that you've seen many strange failures of injection-molded nylon parts.
I can recall having some injection-molded parts fail on me on odd occasion, things like Fastex-type quick-release buckles, but I believe those items that failed are not FRN (Fiberglass Reinforced Nylon); not reinforced nylon but just plain nylon with nothing added.
I know a some others on BF have criticized FRN, but FRN knives without metal liners, as done by Spyderco, seem fine with me.
And I am secure enough in my emasculation to state this opinion openly. (funny)
I'm an engineer for a manufacturing company that uses both standard nylon and FRN in many parts. When I first saw the applications that we used it for I was very impressed, and there are a few of my earlier posts around here that express a favorable opinion of FRN.
The more I started working with the materials and learning about some of the less favorable properties that they have I started to lose faith in it. There have been many occasions where I have seen these parts fail in unexpected ways, usually with no warning.
Even something as simple as changing the mold or changing suppliers can drasticly change the properties of supposedly identical parts.
Nylon also absorbs quite a bit of moisture, and the properties can change drasticly because of this.
While these problems cannot be eliminated, they can be controlled.
Spyderco is a good company that has a lot of experience with the material, so I would expect that they have a handle on these issues.
Personally I have had generally unfavorable experiences with FRN and am unwilling to trust it for important applications, but I have found that when paired with quality sheet metal work it is one of the very best low-cost engineering materials. I am more inclined to purchase knives that reflect this.