Well, a decade later and this is a post I was looking for. I overshot a strike with my BRAND NEW GB maul, only like 30-50 chops in, and the head just snapped right off. I hit hard, but not full power.
I'm not proud of the the overstrike, but they happen! I've never broken a maul, and have chopped dozens of cords. I wonder if that metal. Collar is a stress-riser for the handle??
I was amazed. $300 for a maul, and I break it with less effort than any other? I've used wood, plastic, fiberglass, and metal handled mauls - no failures. I really don't know what to make of it... But I have to say I see the wisdom in the idea of expensive axe but cheap maul...
I did like the maul a lot. Heirloom quality, beautiful feel and finish. Should I try another one I wonder?? Maybe a fluke?