Great Eastern Cutlery: thoughts & discussion

Joined
Nov 5, 2001
Messages
8,969
Howdy all,
Man, I don't know what's gotten into me. First "peanut fever", now the itch for a large carbon steel bladed slippie. Which one of you bastids infected me with slip-joint fever?;) So, in my search for this, I have come across GEC and it's sub-brands.

I am interested in your opinions and recommendations. I am looking at the #23 and #73 patterns. At first I thought I wanted a single blade, but am pondering the double trapper. I didn't care for the single blade beaver-tail/spey blade pattern, but did like the single blade drop/clip one. What is the opinions on the locking ones? Does the linerlock tab get in the way when gripping the knife?

How do these compare with a "Mountain Man" pattern? Who does a good one of these?

Thanks, eagerly awaiting your replies...
Mongo
 
I've only had one example of a GEC (Northfield) thus far. A large single bladed trapper in green tea bone.

Pros were good fit and finish (for the most part), carbon steel and reasonably sharp edge.

Cons were way overdone backspring tension (and I like 'em on the firm side), plastic looking scales (on the green tea version) and unattractive etching (especially the numbering on the back of the blade).

I've seen some GEC models that have tempted me but not quite enough just yet. I don't doubt that that day will come however.
 
i have the pioneer trapper and like the good fit and finish, the nicely done half stops and the super tight springs-i feel absolutely safe using such long blades with these blades on these springs where i haven't really felt comfortable using a Case trapper because i was worried the blades might close by accident.

the blades are a bit tricky to get open, not for those with weak nails, but i love the tight tension.

the whole knife is large and heavy, but not too much larger or heavier than my large Case stockman, so i don't mind carrying it with most pants.

i thinned up the edges and made them shave nicely. so far a great knife.

and the etching is being covered up with a nice patina already so its no big worry.
 
Does anyone have one of the linerlocks? I'm looking to see if the linerlock tab gives an uncomfortable grip. I got my sights set on a Pioneer linerlock...
 
From what I've seen, the Tidioute liner-lock sits above the handle, and I can't imagine that's very comfortable. Seems It would be easy to release unintentionally as well.

I prefer the old SchradeUSA 125OT, where the mark side bolster is relieved for access to the lock lever, and but the pile-side bolster is the standard profile, so it provides some protection for the liner-lock lever. If I ever get a get a linerlock knife again, I'll probably get one of the old SchradeUSA's.

edited to add: this member has one (fishface - maybe pm & ask what he thinks if he doesn't comment here) http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5989925&postcount=11

thx - cpr

ps - by the way, weren't these lock called "lever-locks" at one time? Seems I remember that term growing up.:confused:
 
The only part of the linerlock above the frame itself is in the last 3/4". Thus it should not be in the way of a grip and acts somewhat as a guard. I don't expect these were ever referred to as a lever-lock, as there is nothing "lever" about it.

Mike Latham
CollectorKnives.Net
 
I'm a big fan of GEC! I just "discovered" them a few weeks ago and I have 5 already. I'll go through what I have and what I like and dislike about them.

1) Tidioute Scout (#73) double blade trapper with green cut bone. This is the knife that really set the hook for me. There's a lot on the plus side of this knife. It's gorgeous- with crisp jigging, great color and beautiful lines. It's built like the proverbial tank, it has great heft without being too heavy. The blades have excellent grinds and are crazy sharp- they remind me a lot of Bark River's blades, except they're in a folder. The blades have nice snap, and the flush joint is lovely.

On the minus side- the backsprings really are too tight for my taste. I think it's something you can get used to though.

2) Northfield Scout #23 single-blade trapper in "Brimstone Bone". This one is a real looker. With the over-the-top coloring and deep, craggy jigging, this may be the best looking knife in my collection. It is a good deal thinner and lighter than the double-bladed model. It is comfortable in the hand, and the backspring is not too tight- they got it just right. I love this knife. No minuses on this one.

3) Northfield Pioneer #23 single-blade trapper in "Brimstone Bone"- matching serial numbers with #2 (above). This is very similar to knife #2, except it is quite a bit bigger. It is relatively thin, and isn't too heavy. I think this is basically a "Mountain Man" pattern. I like it a lot, except it is too big to carry legally where I live. And the jigging is just a hair less nice than the #73 version. The backspring is nice on this one.

4) Northfield Barlow #25 with tan sawcut bone. It is a very nice little knife. It is a tad smaller than your average Barlow, and has a great feel to it. It's a departure from the normal pattern in that it has a small clip and a large spearpoint instead of the usual small pen/ large clip arrangement. The only thing I don't like about this knife is that the backsprings are too tight. It's just tight enough to be annoying when I pull the knife out and try to use it for something. You really have to focus on what you are doing, there is no casual opening of this knife. But overall, I love it. I'm trying very hard not to order one of the new variants with the traditional blade arrangement.

#5) Tidioute #53 Cuban with "Dead Skunk" acrylic. Another real looker- this is a "purty knife". I am carrying this knife today, and I like it very much. I've never carried a knife with acrylic scales before, but the swirled red, black and white on this one are gorgeous, and seem tough enough to handle hard use. The whole knife has a very vintage vibe to it, it's unlike anything else I've come across. Very classy! The backsprings on the Cuban are much lighter than any of my other Great Easterns, the blades are quite easy to open. This is the only GEC I have that doesn't have half-stops. The blade profiles have great, slightly unusual lines. The only thing I don't like about the Cuban are the etches on the main blade. The HUGE "1 of 50" on the reverse side is a tad ostentatious, but will probably wear off. I'm slightly concerned that the handles may be too slippery, but I haven't had any problems yet.

Overall, I am very happy with all of my GECs. I have never come across their equal, and the prices are reasonable.
 
I love my GEC's!
I own a #73 single blade in buffalo horn, 2 #23 dual blades, one in burnt grizzly bone and one green river valley bone, and one single blade #23 in natural bone (beaver tail).
I like them all. There are several models in the $50-70 range that are a great value. I find the fit and finish to be excellent; top notch for the price range. The back springs on some can be WAY too stiff! But my scales certainly do not appear to look like plastic, like Blues' did. I also am not a fan of all the etching on the blades but for me the pros far out way the cons.

The biggest con in my opinion has not been brought up yet: Inconsistency. Not in f&f, or appearance. But some blades come razor sharp, some not so much. Also some springs are real nail-breakers others are just reasonably stiff.

Now heres my question:
Is there any way to remove the blade etchings? I would love to have just one that didn't have any etchings (or even shiny finish) so I could let a natural patina develop with out feeling guilty. I don't know what process is used to etch blade steel, so this could be a very stupid question, but I'd really like to know.
 
Welcome, LC. You can probably remove the etch by just using the knife or with a little Flitz or Simichrome and a light abrasive (like 0000 steel wool).

Others will be able to provice you with better ideas.
 
oh yeah, GEC! Orca is correct, I do indeed have two UNXLD 73s, one a river bone w/liner-lock and one in stag w/o liner-lock (SN 3, no shield, collector's item I think). I did not find the liner-lock to be too intrusive to the grip, BUT I did end up filing it down to about 1/2 the original depth and it feels better. I actually find that it enhances the grip. The "liner-lock" is really just a tab in front of the blade, rather than beneath it, to give a little more security. So thinning the tab this way did not diminish its functionality.

The F&F on both of mine are excellent, not quite custom level but very pleasing to own. The liner-lock version feels noticeably thicker and heavier in the hand, which is odd since the liner adds only about 1/16" difference. Maybe there's a difference in bone density.

I have heard varying reports about spring tension. Mine is moderately strong, very satisfying snap on the river bone version, and less tension on the stag. One thing you can do is tel the dealer what you are looking for - I got mine from spaceworld or something, forget the name, and the owner (Pete? Phil? He posts here) picked out the river bone model with the darkest & best-matching scales, per my request. You could make a request for a certain level of spring tension.

I like the carbon blades A LOT, although they do patina if you're not careful.
on the river bone model, I also lengthened the nail-nick and cold-blued the blade on the river bone model, and convexed the edge. It's ugly but I love it! Meanwhile, the stag version is so freaking beautiful it scares me to use it. But both of them are easy to got hair-flinging sharp. Carbon = yum!
 
Fishace, it sounds like your talking about Perry Miller of Spaceport Cutlery. (A man who knows a thing or two about knives and is the president of the NKCA.)
 
I have Flitzed (?) a couple of my GEC and the etch fades but doesn't quite go away. I like the way it looks, not as flashy as before.
Overall I really like the GEC line and am looking forward to getting a few more. I just have to decide which ones. Decisions, decisions.
 
To Blues and Sharpfella: I appreciate the advise! I plan on using steel wool and oil to remove (or lighten) the etching, and polishing if necessary.

For those of you considering a new GEC knife, I cannot say enough about the burnt grizzly bone. It has great color and the unique jigging gives it a nice feel. The smooth buffalo horn is nice as well, and I have been eyeing the brimstone bone for my next purchase.
 
I have several GEC knives. I like them all. IMHO -- What's really cool about them is that you can look at the knives and see that they are really trying hard to do a good job on them.
 
My view on this knife company is very positive.It has an ever expanding range, a lot of scale choices and seems to have very good fit&finish(at least on the 4 I have).

The single blade Liner Lock No.73 I have in burnt stag is a particular favourite.At 3.75" it's not as massive or bulky as its No.23 counterpart(suits many people though). It came sharp, it develops good blade patina and the liner lock is safe and is in no way obtrusive in grip-must depend HOW you grip your knife and if you have very big hands it could get in the way.Backspring is firm but not a nuisance at all. I go for this liner lock model especially and Mongo,you will like the choices of handle material.Check Great Eastern's website for dealer links as the range is always changing.

Their No.25 Barlow now also comes with clip blades and with an end cap giving it jackknife lines as well, a Peanut rival maybe??
 
Anyone have a web address for this company. If they have that strong of a backspring then I'm interested.
 
Anyone have a web address for this company. If they have that strong of a backspring then I'm interested.

Mike, the name is the url. But really, doesn't google work for you? It's the first thing that comes up. ;)
 
Anyone have a web address for this company. If they have that strong of a backspring then I'm interested.

Like strong backsprings huh? You'll love GEC! But be careful what you wish for; I broke both my thumb nails playing with my single blade #23 the first day I got it! Like I said earlier all their springs are strong but some are too strong.

Here are some dealers:
www.collectorknives.net -A great company to deal with.
www.knivesshipfree.com
www.spaceportculery.com
or your favorite (or most hated) auction site often has the best deals.
 
Back
Top